Devils Advocate
Member
- Dec 16, 2009
- 78
- 8
Mahakama ya Rufaa imeamua:That the High Court erred in law in proceeding with the determination of the petition without framing issues.
- Serikali imepoteza hoja ya 1In fact, we are just being consistent with a recent decision of this Court in Jaffari Sanya Jussa and Another v. Salehe Sadiq Osman, Civil Appeal No. 51 of 2009 (unreported) citing 17th Edition of MuIla at p. 719 which is in pari materia with page 1421 of the 15th Edition.
We, therefore, dismiss this ground of appeal.
mahakama ya rufani:That the High Court erred in law and in fact by subjecting the Constitution to International Instruments.
Katika hoja ya pili serikali imeshindwa! -So, we are at one with Mr. Rweyongeza in his reply that reference to International Human Rights Instruments has been ordained by this Court.
We, therefore, cannot fault their lordships in any way and this ground of appeal is dismissed, too.
Mahakama ya Rufani imeamua:That the High Court erred in law by assuming legislative powers.
Hoja ya tatu ya rufaa, serikali imepoteza vile vile!!The A. G., the chief legal advisor of the Executive was to take the necessary steps to amend the laws and the Constitution so that independent candidates could be permitted. We are, therefore, of the settled view that the learned judges did not clothe themselves with legislative powers. This ground fails, too.
Mahakama ya rufani imeamua:That the High Court wrongly assumed jurisdiction in entertaining the Petition.
Hoja ya nne nayo serikali imepotezaThus the High Court of Tanzania is both for the Mainland Tanzania and for the Union on matters pertaining to the Constitution, such as the one that is the subject matter of this appeal.
So, the High Court had jurisdiction to entertain the petition and ground one is dismissed in its entirety.
Sasa ukisoma mtiririko wa hoja za mahakama utaona kuwa wamejenga hoja kwenye msingi wa kisheria sana na kutudokeza tatizo la sheria yetu na Katiba yetu. Nitawaaacha msome wenyewe.That the High Court erred in law in nullifying the provisions of the Constitution.
Na Majaji wanamaliza hukumu yao kwa maneno haya ambayo ni ujumbe mkubwa kwa wapiga kura.Ground one is, therefore, allowed: a court cannot declare an article of the Constitution to be unconstitutional except where the article has not been enacted in accordance with the procedure under Art 98(1)(a) and (b).
However, we give a word of advice to both the Attorney General and our Parliament: The United Nations Human Rights Committee, in paragraph 21 of its General Comment No. 25, of July 12, 1996, said as follows on Article 25 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, very similarly worded as Art 23 of the American Convention and our Art 21:
The right of persons to stand for election should not be limited unreasonably by requiring candidates to be members of parties or of specific parties.
Tanzania is known for our good record on human rights and particularly our militancy for the right to self determination and hence our involvement in the liberation struggle. We should seriously ponder that comment from a Committee of the United Nations, that is, the whole world.
Swali lililopo je ushauri utafuatwa? Na ili ufuatwe embu tujiulize haya.......however, we give a word of advice to both the attorney general and our parliament: The united nations human rights committee, in paragraph 21 of its general comment no. 25, of July 12, 1996, said as follows on article 25 of the international covenant on civil and political rights, very similarly worded as art 23 of the American convention and our art 21:
The right of persons to stand for election should not be limited unreasonably by requiring candidates to be members of parties or of specific parties.
Tanzania is known for and hence our involvement in the liberation struggle. We should seriously ponder that comment from a committee of the united nations, that is, the whole world.
Uandishi wa habari ni taaluma tegemezi. Ili uwe mwandishi wa habari mzuri ni lazima uwe umesoma vizuri taaluma nyingine pia.Wandishi wa habari wa tanzania oyeeeeeeeee, duuuuuuu, Heading zote leo Mtikila kashindwa? jamani hatuna waandishi kwa sasa, Journalist Vipi?
Kaeni chini msome kwanza na sio kukurupuka
AndrewK.. naomba uniangalizie hivyo vichwa cha habari vinasemaje maana naona kuna haja ya kutoa elimu kidogo..
Ni AG vs Mtikila na sio Mtikila vs AG!
Hivi ni Kwa nini Hii Kesi ilisikilizwa na Majaji Saba?
Je, siyo Janja ya Mahakama kuweka Kikwazo kwa Mtikila kukata Rufaa endapo angeshindwa?
Mimi sijui mambo ya Sheria jamani naombeni Ufafanuzi as to "Why Jopo la majaji Saba na siyo watatu?" kwa mfano
Wadau wa sheria nimejitahidi kwa kadiri ya uwezo wangu kuitafuta hii hukumu na kuileata mbele yenu ili tuijadili. Nimefanikiwa kuipata na naomba tuisome kwa kina halfu tuijadili. Ni ndefu ni kama kurasa 51 lakini nafikiri its worth reading the whole document.
Nimeiatach.
AndrewK.. naomba uniangalizie hivyo vichwa cha habari vinasemaje maana naona kuna haja ya kutoa elimu kidogo..