Hukumu ya mgombea binafsi hii hapa (AG vs Mtikila)

Wrong, lawyers tell Court of Appeal

Speaker Sitta says issue will be discussed in tenth parliament

The Court of Appeal ruling on private candidates has come under fire from lawyers and MPs, but National Assembly Speaker, Samuel Sitta said yesterday that he foresees the matter coming up in parliament.

Speaking to reporters at the parliament grounds, Sitta said time could not allow for the matter to be discussed in the current parliament, but he remained optimistic that the necessary processes, if followed will finally land it in the house.

He said Rev Christopher Mtikila can now channel his thought on the matter through the parliamentary committee on Justice, Constitutional Affairs and Governance, which can bring it to parliament and seek amendments of the constitution.

Alternatively, he said through networking, the matter can be brought to parliament by any Member of Parliament as a private motion.

This comes in just a day after the court of appeal ruled against private candidates contesting in election in Tanzania.

Prominent lawyers and members of parliament interviewed by this paper said by the ruling, the judiciary had failed to exercise its powers. The panel of seven Appeal Court judges led by Chief Justice Augustino Ramadhan ruled that the court had no powers to determine the issue of independent candidate.

In their ruling that lasted for almost two hours, the judges said that the issue of private candidates in elections was political and not legal, and that it could therefore not be settled in court but by the parliament which has the jurisdiction to amend the constitution.

However, an independent lawyer, Prof. Abdallah Safari, told The Guardian yesterday that the ruling has proved that the judiciary, one of the three state pillars, had failed to exercise its powers in determining sensitive issues that touch on the rights of majority of Tanzanians.

"The decision is a clear indication that the judiciary has sold its powers to the Parliament. That was the issue that should be determined by the court and not the Parliament," said Safari.

Kigoma-North Member of Parliament, Zitto Kabwe supported the don saying that the verdict showed that the judiciary had surrendered its independence to the Parliament by failing to give a fair ruling on the question of independent candidate.

Dr Xavier Lwaitama, a lecturer at the University of Dar es Salaam (UDSM) criticized the Appeal Court judges who gave the verdict saying they had abdicated their duties and responsibilities so as to serve the interests of a few people in the government.

He said the Appeal Court had legal powers to determine the case, because the issue of independent candidate was a public interest matter.

The Executive Director of the Legal and Human Rights Centre (LHRC), Francis Kiwanga described the Appeal Court decision as a serious violation of human rights and failure by the judiciary to exercise its powers enshrined in the country's Constitution.

Speaking at a news conference yesterday, the LHRC director said the country's Constitution and principles of separation of powers between the judiciary, the parliament, and the executive-give powers to the judiciary to determine cases related to rights of people such as the one on independent candidate.

"If the judiciary is avoiding its duties and responsibility as interpreter of the country's laws, where should Tanzanians go in search of their rights? Obviously, their rights would be denied, and they would have nowhere to go," said Kiwanga.

Harold Sungusia, LHRC Director of Advocacy and Reform, said the government's efforts and programmes aimed to observe human rights principles and good governance could hardly be implemented if the guardian (judiciary) of the Constitution would abdicate its duties.

He said the centre planned to forward the issue to the international legal instruments if Parliament would not seriously work on the matter of independent candidate as per the ruling of the Appeal Court.

However, Lucas Selelii, Nzega Member of Parliament, has welcomed the Appeal Court verdict, saying that it was the duty of the Parliament to handle such matters.

"The verdict is a clear testimony that Parliament is more powerful than the Judiciary. Because they failed to make the decision, the judiciary should from now onward forward to the Parliament all complicated and contradictory matters," said Selelii.

Professor Haji Semboja of UDSM praised the Appeal Court decision saying, the seven judges gave correct interpretation of the law on the issue of independent candidate.

He said the court was right by forwarding the issue to the parliament to allow wananchi to decide on the matter.

"The High Court erred in its decision to allow independent candidate...the Court of Appeal gave correct interpretation of the law. It's true that the issue concerns the rights of many Tanzanians, but we have to observe the law. The judiciary cannot decide on everything," he said.

The Court of Appeal on Thursday ruled that the issue of private candidates in elections can only be settled by the parliament which has the jurisdiction to amend the constitution and not the courts.

The panel of seven Appeal Judges led by Chief Justice Augustino Ramadhani said in their ruling that private candidates would therefore not participate in the coming general election scheduled for October.

The bench whose other members were Eusebia Munuo, January Msofe, Natalia Kimaro, Mbaruku Mbaruku, Bernard Luande and Sauda Mjasiri said the issue was political and not legal thus quashing and setting aside the earlier High Court decision allowing independent candidates to run for office.

Reading the verdict which lasted for almost two hours, the Chief Justice said the decision on whether or not to introduce independent candidates depended on the social needs of each state based on its historical reality.

He, however, advised both the Attorney General and Parliament to ponder seriously the comment from the United Nations Human Rights Committee that the right of persons to stand for election should not be limited unreasonably by requiring candidates to be members of specific parties.

He said Tanzania was known for its good record on human rights and particularly militancy for the right to self determination and involvement in the liberation struggle.

Rev Mtikila had earlier in 1993 filed a miscellaneous civil cause no. 5 of 1993, challenging among other matters, the prohibition of independent candidates for presidential, parliamentary and civic elections. This was introduced by the eighth constitutional amendment act, 1992.

In 2006, the High Court panel comprising of Judges Amir Manento, Salum Massati and Thomas Mihayo ruled in favour of re-introducing independent candidates.

However, the Attorney General (AG) appealed against the decision asking the appellate court to quash and set aside the decision.

Deputy AG George Masaju had told the court that Mtikila filed his petition to seek for orders allowing independent candidates under section 4 of the Act, Cap 3 revised Edition.

Before the appeal hearing was adjourned in February, this year, the judges allowed ordinary citizens to contest for presidential and parliamentary seats as private candidates during elections.

In April this year, Masaju told the panel that no court in the country had jurisdiction to construe the constitution, and that the High Court had erred in law by assuming legislative powers.




Source: Guardian



My take: Sitta is just dreaming to think that Parliament will discuss the issue and approve private candidates. It will never do so, even though it might try to go through the motions.
 
The biggest problem of this judgement is to allow judge to choose and pick, if someone deem that this issue is complicated or just feel otherwise, will contended that the issue at stake is not a legal one, but domestic, friendship which had gone sour etc etc, hence delaying a cause of justice.
I think this judgement will set a very bad record to the "learned Judge" though i know running with time some of those & judge will di-associate themselves with this Judgement.
It is very unfortunate that some have decided to take this route.
So Sad .................
 
Hebu tujiulize.. kama Bunge likifanya mabadiliko ya Katiba kwa utaratibu halali kabisa na kusema kwenye mabadiliko hayo, kuwa mtu hawezi kupiga kura isipokuwa awe ni mwanachama wa chama cha siasa, je itakuwa halali na hakuna recourse ya mahakama kwa wale ambao hawataki kuwa wanachama wa chama siasa ili wapige kura? -- ukisoma hukumu ya mahakama the answer is an emphatic yes! well this is the reign of idiocy!
 

ngambo.. asante kwa hii umenisaidia kuandika majibu yangu kwani toka juzi nimekuwa nikichambua hiyo section ya mgombea binafsi na kuonesha kuwa kuna makosa ya reasoning ambayo yamefanyika ambayo mwanafunzi yeyote wa falsafa anaweza kuona toka mwanzo.

Kwanza, mahakama ya rufaa haikurudi nyuma kabisa na kusoma reasoning ya Jaji Kisanga alipohutoa hukumu ya awali 1994 kabla ya mabadiliko ya Katiba.

Pili, wamejichanganya kudai kuwa hakuna "basic structure" kwenye Katiba yetu kwani Bill of Rights naamini iko katika basic structure na huwezi kuishambulia bill of rights (ambapo haki ya kuchagua na kuchaguliwa is enshrined) ukabakia salama.
 

Tell them,
 

Yote tisa, kumi , leo bunge likikaa na kurekebisha sheria na kusema kuwa kuanzia leo hii nchi ni monarch (ya kifalme) kinyume cha ibara ya kwanza ya katiba inayosema:

Tanzania ni nchi moja na ni Jamhuri ya Muungano.

Na bunge likapitisha je mahakama itakaa kimya, au mahakama itarudisha suala hilo bungeni kwa marekebisho? Tusome katiba between lines na tuilewe katiba ni hai na haifi, haiendi hospitali, haiendi ICU inatakiwa iwe na uhai, imetungwa na wananchi kupitia bunge maalumu hususan kwa minaajili ya kutunga katiba . Katiba haitakiwi kujali matakwa ya kundi la watu, badala yake iendane na matakwa ya wananchi wote.

Ndio maana katiba inaanza kwenye utangulizi:

KWA KUWA SISI Wananchi wa Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania tumeamua rasmi na kwa dhati kujenga katika nchi yetu jamii inayozingatia misingi ya uhuru, haki, udugu na amani:

Katiba ni ya wananchi wote, sio ya kikundi fulani.
 

Kila nikisoma hii hukumu sipati jibu, naomba msaada wenu Buchannan, Ngoshwe, Zak Malang, Mwanakijiji, Devils Advocate na wengineo hebu jaribuni kulinganisha hukumu hii juu kesi ya Warioba hapo juu,na kesi ya Ally Linus Vrs THA ( 1998) TLR 5 iliyosema "Apart from the historical origin of certiorari, which we do not go into in this case, it is clear that the basic structure of the constitution of this country vests the judicial power in the judicature, that is, the judicial arm of the Government. The function of interpreting the laws of the state is a judicial function and for that reasons the judicial arm of the Government has the final word about the meaning of the laws of this country."

Kutona na hukumu hii na warioba sio kweli kama mahakama haikufanya kazi inavyotakiwa kikatiba na kisheria? jadala uendelee.
 
Tunakushukuru sana Devils Advocate kwa huu mchango maana hii tume ya Warioba na sheria yote iliyotungwa ya mchakato wa katiba ni ukiukwaji mkubwa wa katiba iliyopo na hii hukumu ndiyo ushahidi kamili!!!!!!!!!
 
Independent of the judiciary serikali ilicheza mchezo mkali sana kwenye hii kesi
 
Zitto tehetehetehe
 
Duuh
 
Usimlinganishe kisanga na vitu vya kijinga hawa saba wanaingia mara mbili kwa kisanga mmoja
 
They have time to overrule their decisions though too late
 
Good
 
Tutamkumbuka Jaji Lugakingira na Mwalusanya J
 
Hivi kesi ya kuondoa ukomo wa Urais imeamuliwaje?
 
Mkuu Mzee Mwanakijiji , kwa ruhusa yako, nimetumia uzi wako huu kama mbolea, kuboreshea bandiko langu hili Hukumu ya Mgombea Binafsi Juni 17, 2010

P
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…