Muigai Jr
JF-Expert Member
- Jun 3, 2020
- 1,762
- 3,362
Kina Kinjekitile na Bw Heri wangepewa majina ya Ngome za kijeshi
Kina Kinjekitile na Bw Heri wangepewa majina ya Ngome za kijeshiWell said Kichuguu, siku hizi watu wakiraka kujustify white elephants projects wanazipa jina la Nyerere
Tuna wazee wetu wa kale kabisa akina Mkwawa, Kinjekitile, Machifu wengi tu akiba Rumanyika, Songea, Marealle, Abushiri na wengineo wengi huoni wakienziwa, kila kitu kizuri kinaitwa jinala Nyerere.
1. uwanja wa ndege wa JKN
2. Bwawa la umeme la JKN
3.Ukumbi wa mikutano wa JKN
4. Uwanja wa Kambarage
5. Chuo cha Nyerere (Kivukoni)
6. Daraja la Nyerere (Kigamboni)
7. Barabara ya Nyerere(Pugu road)
8. Campus ya Mwalimu Nyerere (UDSM)
...
..
Na mengine mengi
Ina maana sisi kama Taifa tuna uhaba wa heroes wa kuenzi majina yao?
Ushauri mzuri katika Muktadha usiofaa ni dharau kufuta jina la mwanzo na kuweka jipya bora wasubirie Vijengwe vipya kisha wataandikwa majina yao hapo inavutia na kupendeza mfano Aboud Jumbe Stadium, Dodoma au Jakaya Kikwete International Airport, Msalato.
I think you are arguing on trivial things and I would not want to go out of the topic. Understand that being illogical is different from sounding badly. The two points you made are not true, and I will give you counterexamples.I think you missed my point. Naming a learning institution after someone isn’t the issue here. All the examples of university names you cited don’t contain the flaw that exists in the “Kikwete University of Dodoma”. A name such as University of XYZ at ——- is usually used by universities that are an integral part of a university system with multiple autonomous universities. A solitary university such as UDOM is not appropriate for such naming style!
Ni kweli; division, brigedi, na kambi zote za kijeshi zipewe majina mashujaa wetu wenye historia ya kukumbukwa kijeshi. Kama ile kambi ya Milambo kule Tabora basi kuwepo kambi zenye majina ya aina hiyo sehemu mbalimbali Tanzania.Kina Kinjekitile na Bw Heri wangepewa majina ya Ngome za kijeshi
Kutokuandikwa ktk landmarks haisaidii kufifisha kazi za mhusika wakati nyenzo nyingine za kumbukumbu zimefanya kazi.Hujajibu mada; nadhani na wewe unaongea kwa hisia tu. Unajuwa kuwa iwapo zile kanuni za Newton hazingepewa jina lake kweli wewe leo ungekuwa na unajua kuwa kulikuwa na kijana anaitwa Newton? Au kama jina la malkia Victoria lisingepewa ziwa letu ungekuwa unajuwa kuwa kulikuwa na malkia Victoria?
Historia huandikwa kwa namna tofauti na wahusika wenyewe, lakini sisi tunapotunza historia zao tunatumia njia nyingi pia ikiwa ni pamoja na kutunza maandiko yao, hotuba zao, picha zao, na majina yao; landamarks ni kwa ajili ya kutunza majina yao.
Hiyo yako ni thesis tofauti kabisa na tunayojaribu kuongelea hapa; ndiyo maana nikasema hujajibu mada. Kama mtu amefanya jambo jema lakini hakuwekwa kwenye landamark yoyote, inawezekana miaka mingi ijayo atawekwa-tunachotaka ni kuwa na utaratibu mzuri wa kufanya hivyo. Bibi Titi Mohammed alishitakiwa kwa kesi ya uhaini na akafungwa maisha, ingawa baadaye Nyerer alimwondoa gerezani na mwishoni sana naye akapewa barabara ya Bibi Titi Mohammed. Mambo mengine ni swala la muda tu.Kutokuandikwa ktk landmarks haisaidii kufifisha kazi za mhusika wakati nyenzo nyingine za kumbukumbu zimefanya kazi.
Unaweza kumuua mtu mwema na msemakweli ila huwezi kuua wema au ukweli aliofanya.
Wewe unaongelea short term frustrations za kisiasa tu; lakini mimi ninajaribu kuangalia mambo ya muda mrefu. Kumbuka magufuli hatakuwepo miaka sita ijayo lakini bado tutaendelea kuwa landmarks mbalimbali zitakazohitaji majina!landmarks kubwa wanayotakiwa kuacha viongozi wetu ni pamoja na;
Uongozi unaofuata sheria na katiba
Kutii mihimili mingine
Kuruhusu demokrasia ifuate mkondo wake (kutokuua demokrasia)
Kutokubana vyombo vya habari
Kutokuwepo kwa upendeleo wa kikanda/kikabila
Umeuliza swali halafu unalijibu mwenyeweKwahiyo hizo landmarks zitasaidia nini bibi yako kule kijijini.
Landmarks kubwa ya kiongozi yeyote wa Tanzania ni kufuata misingi ya uongozi na katiba. Hapo hatasahaulika miongoni mwa wananchi hata kizazi cha 12.
I think you are arguing on trivial things and I would not want to go out of the topic. Understand that being illogical is different from sounding badly. The two points you made are not true, and I will give you counterexamples.
Systems of multiple autonomous universities do not necessarily use "at" as you want to make us believe; if you look for American Universities all over the world, they are called "American University of somewhere", for example "American University of Beirut," American University of Rome, etc. Similarly, you can find Catholic Universities such as "Catholic University of Cameroon", "Catholic University of America", etc
Naming a University by combininga name of one personn and a name of a place is not illogical and there is no flawa! There are many universities that are named just like that. Here are some examples: "Borys Hrinchenko Kyiv University", it combines the name of "Borys Hrinchenko" and the name of the city of Kiev; "Chaminade University of Honolulu ", it combines the name of "Father William Joseph Chaminade" and the city of Honolulu where it is located; "Chea Sim University of Kamchay Mear", it combines the name of the longtime Cambodian politician "Chea Sim" and the name of the place where it is located Kamchay Mear; and "David Agmashenebeli University of Georgia" is named after "King David IV the Builder of Georgia 9David Agmashenebeli)" and the country of Georgia where it is located.
You better suggest that the naming does not sound well instead of calling it illogical!
Daraja la MfugaleMi naona Ni ushamba tu
Kila mradi una jina la kiongozi
Disgust halafu jina lina jirudi rudia
Hivi Ina maana hakuna hata Norma citizen ambao sio wanasiasa waliifanyia makubwa nchi hii mchango wako ukaheshimiwa kwa kuzipata baadhi ya hizo landmark majina yao
Wanasiasa bhana wabinfsi sana
Saivi Kuna Jokate mwegelo secondary schools just imagine[emoji849][emoji15]
I hope he gets the point.I think you missed my point. Naming a learning institution after someone isn’t the issue here. All the examples of university names you cited don’t contain the flaw that exists in the “Kikwete University of Dodoma”. A name such as University of XYZ at ——- is usually used by universities that are an integral part of a university system with multiple autonomous universities. A solitary university such as UDOM is not appropriate for such naming style!
Do you know how many "Chaminade Universities" are there? and why do we have "Chaminade University of Honolulu"?You’re arguing for the sake of it. The examples you’re citing aren’t solitary institutions like UDOM; there are more than one of each. The first question I asked you was, where else do we have a “Kikwete University” to warrant renaming UDOM as “Kikwete University at Dodoma”? There must be more than one “Kikwete University” to warrant the use of that naming style!
The name “Kikwete University at Dodoma” is just as illogical as a name “Kilimanjaro Region at Moshi” or “Mara Region at Musoma”.
Kabisa, ina maana hata jengo la bunge nalo libatizwe kwa kuliita jina la mtu? Mie sipendelei sana huu utamaduni wa kubadilisha majina ASILI kwa majina ya watu. Mwisho tutabadili hata majina ya vyama vya siasa sasa.Ushauri mzuri katika Muktadha usiofaa ni dharau kufuta jina la mwanzo na kuweka jipya bora wasubirie Vijengwe vipya kisha wataandikwa majina yao hapo inavutia na kupendeza mfano Aboud Jumbe Stadium, Dodoma au Jakaya Kikwete International Airport, Msalato.
Jengo la Bunge pale Dar es Salaam lilikuwa linaitwa Tangayika Legco House, likabadilishwa na kuitwa Karimjee Hall kumuenzi Spika Abdulkarim Karimjee. Chama ccha TAA kilibadilishwa jina kikawa TANU na baadaye kikawa CCM; Azania ilibadilika kuwa Deutch Ostafrika, nayo ilibadilika tena kuwa Tanganyika, na baadaye ikawa Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania!Kabisa, ina maana hata jengo la bunge nalo libatizwe kwa kuliita jina la mtu? Mie sipendelei sana huu utamaduni wa kubadilisha majina ASILI kwa majina ya watu. Mwisho tutabadili hata majina ya vyama vya siasa sasa.
Do you know how many "Chaminade Universities" are there? and why do we have "Chaminade University of Honolulu"?
I want you to know that a name is just a name, you urge about putting logic in naming but I have listed some of the counterexamples that prove you wrong. And I can pull a long list of different names of institutions that will add to that fact: names are not sentences, they are not sentence, in which logic is required. We could remove conjuctions and simply say Kikwete Univesity Dodoma, and it will still be a name as long as that is what is put the the institution's charter or any relevant instrument.
View attachment 1656717
I suggested Kikwete University of Dodoma, you said it is illogical, and I said may be Kikwete University at Dodoma, and you jump another end; it is just a name.
That is an "illogical" argument if you believe that I don't know examples that I gave you, and especially since now you seem to be running away from real the statement that you called illogical. I did not create those names but they do exist in a catalog of world universities, and I even gave you a website of one of them.Names aren’t just names; they have to make sense! You’re citing examples that you really know nothing about.
As far as I know, there’s no “Kikwete University” anywhere else. So if you want UDOM to be renamed to honor Kikwete, then it should just be called “Kikwete University”. As I previously said, calling it “Kikwete University at Dodoma” would be just as absurd as calling Kilimanjaro Region “Kilimanjaro Region at Moshi”!
Chaminade iko chini ya Kanisa Katoliki, chini ya Marian; wana vyuo vidogo vingi nchi mbalimbali na hata Kenya kipo; kwa hawa kuita "Chaminade University of Honolulu" ni sawa kwa kuwa wanaweza kufungua/ kujenga chuo kikuu sehemu nyingine.Do you know how many "Chaminade Universities" are there? and why do we have "Chaminade University of Honolulu"?
I want you to know that a name is just a name, you urge about putting logic in naming but I have listed some of the counterexamples that prove you wrong. And I can pull a long list of different names of institutions that will add to that fact: names are not sentences, they are not sentence, in which logic is required. We could remove conjuctions and simply say Kikwete Univesity Dodoma, and it will still be a name as long as that is what is put the the institution's charter or any relevant instrument.
View attachment 1656717
I suggested Kikwete University of Dodoma, you said it is illogical, and I said may be Kikwete University at Dodoma, and you jump another end; it is just a name.
Chaminade iko chini ya Kanisa Katoliki, chini ya Marian; wana vyuo vidogo vingi nchi mbalimbali na hata Kenya kipo; kwa hawa kuita "Chaminade University of Honolulu" ni sawa kwa kuwa wanaweza kufungua/ kujenga chuo kikuu sehemu nyingine.