Succession Politics: Though underestimated, Kikwete still holds a trump card... Salim Ahmed Salim?

Succession Politics: Though underestimated, Kikwete still holds a trump card... Salim Ahmed Salim?

Rutashubanyuma

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2010
Posts
219,468
Reaction score
911,184
The new ccm cc team that JK has unveiled yesterday is pregnant with intentions of where JK hankers to take the nation to. For beginners, since we gained our independence in 1961 no president has ever assailed to the top seat without being a member of the ruling party top hierarchy and that is the central committee.

Without undermining the spirit of a new constitution which is still unborn baby,
I do expect that this trend of grooming top leaders within a political party will screech to halt after 2015 as there is almost a consensus that most of the societal ills we are imbibed in today are a result of corrupting government positions with party ones. Hence a vigorous quest to separate the two positions has been gaining currency across the political divide.

Knowing a future president will come from ccm cc therefore there is a need to decipher what JK has in mind and here is my personal assessment of the scenarios that are quietly unfolding:-

While JK like any other homo sapien may prefer to promote one of his surrogates, but he understands that the party is bigger than him, and without it, his legacy is but a few ashes on our political terrain. Hence, JK will do anything in his power to ensure a smooth transfer of power to someone within the cc he has just inaugurated.

HOW WILL JK PLAY HIS GAME OF POLITICAL CHASE?

The past conduct of JK on similar matters is an arena where we may glean some of his strategic thoughts on the matter at hand.


a) Learn something from election banner " Ari mpya, nguvu mpya na kasi mpya."

Most of us have forgotten what that inspiring electoral banner entailed, but JK's presidential career has been defined by that electoral mantra:
a burning and yet an insatiable ambition to be a totally different president from his predecessors and possibly his successors........someone who tried to make a difference in our lives and who had also attempted to change political culture in our nation, though with mixed results!

b) But how has JK fared, so far?

i) Do not look far than in the area of appointments because that is where you can discern his zones of "comfortability". It is an area where he has a leeway to surround himself with personalities he cherishes deep in his heart: People who reflects his ideals and share his value systems..for whatever that means.

ii) The appointment of two women; namely, Asha Rose Migiro and Zakhia Hamdani Meghji to head for the first time in our inchoate history the ministries of Foreign affairs and Finance respectively are a case study in hand.

c) What did JK accomplished?

In a twinkling of an eye, JK became the first president in our history to garland our political landscape with women empowerment in such sensitive posts,
not even the saintly Nyerere had the visionary leadership to do the same! It had to be JK who did this and I would add JK promoted those women partly because he had his gimlet eyes firmly transfixed on his legacy. JK wanted to be different from his predecessors; although history will also note, that he was more amenable to promote those women who share his spiritual beliefs! Something that is not within the orbit of this analysis, though.

d) What about Speaker Anne Makinda's promotion?

Those who refuse to give JK credit on promotion of women rights are quick to pull the rag behind those who applaud JK on the duo appointment in the cabinet for Migiro and Meghji that the elevation of Makinda was mere accidental and in many ways was to fix an incumbent speaker -
read Samuel Sitta- who was considered overambitious and who was abusing his position at the Augusta House to promote his personal political futuristic stakes in the party and the nation at large!

e) Was Samuel Sitta demoted for the sake of empowering women?


My crystal ball informs me that Sitta was punished for his political tantrums and Makinda was a mere coincidental beneficiary of the mayhem that led to the former's downfall. And I may add, so long as JK is in power Sitta will never rise beyond his hitherto portfolio, and nothing else. JK does not trust him and he treats him with kid gloves.

f) Then what is JK's trump card again in this succession battle?

JK will do all that is in his sphere of influence to dissuade mainland men -remember the UMOJA WA VIJANA WA CCM chairmanship election fiasco?- from running for the presidency with one exception of Dr. Ahmed Salim because he is from marginalized Pemba and it will be very difficult to convince CCM Isles that the ccm cc presidential proposals will be without one of their own and there is no female there who has the profound acceptability of carrying the Isles flag to their satisfaction beyond being labeled a cheerleader: Dr Maua Daftari.

Although CC CCM will make all the attempts to show the road to State house is wide and open to all but surreptitious efforts will be initiated to promote three mainland women and one man and a woman from Zanzibar to carry the ccm presidential flag.


In UVCCM chairmanship election fiasco, JK parlayed mainland office seekers as powermongers and CC slashed their names with lightning speed and a cunning Zanzibari, though now a confirmed forgerer- went on almost unopposed to clinch that position!

Similar heartwrenching antics await mainlanders notorious for powermongering.


g) Who are these four women and one man?

Maybe the real question be why the figure of five from ccm cc and not any other number? CC CCM from the multiparty elections of 1995 to 2010 have preferred an odd number of five and the national council through secret ballot truncates the number to three and the national convention gathering picks one from those three.

I see no indication, so far, that that political culture will change come 2015 for a simple reason where a presidential primary election that involves all members of the party is the most desirable way to go but JK feels that he may lose control and those "Mr. money bags" will outwit him knowing rank and file ccm members are very venal and may vote to the highest bidder! So lack of trusting the rank and file of ccm, drives JK not to reform ccm constitution to permit presidential primaries picking ccm presidential flag bearer because he will lose his trump card to determine our collective destiny.

h) What about Lowassa, Membe & Sitta?

The last thing JK may want is to divide the party along three fissures generated by the trio: by letting his ccm cc propose even one of those names because they are the most polarizing figures within the party and bad blood among them is threatening to tear the party into three deplorable parts.

Lowassa may goad members of the ccm national council to elevate him, little does he know his name will not be proposed by the ccm cc for reasons I have just earmarked. So for all purposes and intents, if I were a close confidant of Lowassa, I would advise him to forget the president or move to the opposition backbench where political life is as good as in the wilderness.

For Membe & Sitta, I just feel sorry for them for letting the cat out too soon because the chickens are now coming home to roost.


i) CC will pick who?

My predictions lead me to name the following four women for reasons which I will reserve them for now.

The four women and one man are all in the ccm cc new and those are (in preferential random order):-

i) Dr. Asha Rose Migiro.

ii) Professor Anne Tibaijuka

iii) Dr. Maua Daftari.

iv) Ms. Anne Makinda.

v) Dr. Ahmed Salim.

j) National Council will settle for who?


i) Dr. Asha Rose Migiro.

ii) Professor Anne Tibaijuka

iii) Dr. Ahmed Salim.

K)
CCM Congress will pick who?

Dr. Ahmed Salim may turn out to be the eventual winner sending JK succession plans into disarray.........................

l) Will Dr. Ahmed Salim win the 2015 election?

Of course by a huge landslide..............
the guy hates official graft more than Dr. slaa hates ccm! Even here, JK still gets top marks as far as his legacy is concerned as historians will keenly note he was the first president where women outranked men in the ccm presidential nominations. And far more important will be a tiny Pemba, at last had one of their own as the United Republic of Tanzania president........................that will be something to send CDM back to the opposition backbench maybe then they will learn not to touch a Cougar by its tail or audaciously wrestle with a rattlesnake...they will get bitten, here to silence and frustrations.....I just can't wait for this another humiliation accorded to CDM.

And maybe CDM will learn the art of political decency....................again it is just maybe! You never know with them.............they seem hellbent to secure power through anarchy.


Have your say. The reasons behind these trajectories of projected permutations have intentionally been omitted for security reasons............
 
hahaha! Rutashubanyuma... Hii peace yako very interesting... It has made me smile. At the moment cannot comment; more so because am still raw from hurting as a result of Great disappointment imposed by him by his recent endeavor yesterday. It was not worth it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
hahaha! Rutashubanyuma... Hii peace yako very interesting... It has made me smile. At the moment cannot comment; more so because am still raw from hurting as a result of Great disappointment imposed by him by his recent endeavor yesterday. It was not worth it.

AshaDii for the first time there is hope in JK...........I can smell the roses, to say the least
 
If Dr Salim agrees, the story might be different! Am not so sure on other issues but I believe he is not a person of mediocrity. Where we are now, we need a person of his caliber...
 
If Dr Salim agrees, the story might be different! Am not so sure on other issues but I believe he is not a person of mediocrity. Where we are now, we need a person of his caliber...

Ndahani to win the 2015 presidential and parliamentary elections neither ccm nor JK has any choice bu Dr. Salim.,..................and he will win by a landslide........he is a great African statesman the country has..
 
AshaDii for the first time there is hope in JK...........I can smell the roses, to say the least

Nakupa ushauri wa bure.

1. Suala la siasa za majina ni adui wa kwanza wa CCM.

2. Wamepoteza tunu ya kuwa Chama cha Wafanyakazi na Wakulima

3. Huyo JK kama uanaona ana turufu ya Salum A. Salum umebugi kwa sababu ya 2 hapo juu.

4. Nchi sasa hivi iko kwenye "Autopilot" kwa sababu ya udhaifu wa CCM na JK; wamejisalimisha kwenye huruma ya kuhujumu wengine vita ambayo tayari wamepoteza.

5. Ni bahati mbaya ukosefu wa "taifa lenye elimu" lina wachambuzi wanaojiegemeza kwenye majina ya watu na sura zao

Kazi unayoifanya chunguza tija yake
 
Nakupa ushauri wa bure.

1. Suala la siasa za majina ni adui wa kwanza wa CCM.

2. Wamepoteza tunu ya kuwa Chama cha Wafanyakazi na Wakulima

3. Huyo JK kama uanaona ana turufu ya Salum A. Salum umebugi kwa sababu ya 2 hapo juu.

4. Nchi sasa hivi iko kwenye "Autopilot" kwa sababu ya udhaifu wa CCM na JK; wamejisalimisha kwenye huruma ya kuhujumu wengine vita ambayo tayari wamepoteza.

5. Ni bahati mbaya ukosefu wa "taifa lenye elimu" lina wachambuzi wanaojiegemeza kwenye majina ya watu na sura zao

Kazi unayoifanya chunguza tija yake

Mimibaba tija yake ni kufurahia uhuru wa kutoa maoni ambayo ni haki ya kikatiba.......mengineyo uliyoyaandika naona hayana tija kwa hiyo sitahangaika nayo...........................ningeliisifia CDM ungeliniunga mkono.....................nchi inaongozwa na watu na wana majina kuwatathmini mwelekeo wao ndiyo uchambuzi wa kisiasa...............hatuchambui karanga ila watu!

ushauri wako umekataliwa kiujumla yake kwa sababu ambazo nimezitoa...........
 
Mimibaba tija yake ni kufurahia uhuru wa kutoa maoni ambayo ni haki ya kikatiba.......mengineyo uliyoyaandika naona hayana tija kwa hiyo sitahangaika nayo...........................ningeliisifia CDM ungeliniunga mkono.....................nchi inaongozwa na watu na wana majina kuwatathmini mwelekeo wao ndiyo uchambuzi wa kisiasa...............hatuchambui karanga ila watu!

ushauri wako umekataliwa kiujumla yake kwa sababu ambazo nimezitoa...........

Nilijua utakataa kwa sababu nilizotoa. Mimi sichambui majina nachambua mifumo. Sichambui CCM kwa sababu ni Chadema; nachambua kwa sababu kuna ushahidi ambao wasomi kama wewe hauwahusu. Nashukuru kwa kufurahia na kutumia uhuru wa kutoa maoni hata bila tija.

Kwa kweli umejitenga na "reality on the ground" endelea si bure
 
Nilijua utakataa kwa sababu nilizotoa. Mimi sichambui majina nachambua mifumo. Sichambui CCM kwa sababu ni Chadema nachambua kwa sababu kuna ushahidi ambao wasomi kama wewe hauwahusu. Nahukuru kwa kufurahia na kutumia uhuru wa kutoa maoni hata bila tija.

Kwa kweli umejitenga na "reality on the ground" endelea si bure

Mimibaba tatizo hujasoma laiti ungelinielewa ungefahamu ninachambua jinsi viongozi wanavyoitumia mifumo iliyopo kufanikisha azma zao....................................uchambuzi wa mifumo bila ya watu ndiyo tija ya wapi?........................mifumo inaendeshwa na watu na lazima uwaunganishe pamoja na kutafuta majawabu yake.......na hili limefanyika hapa...............labda kama una kero nyingine kama kuwaponda CDM labda tujadili hilo............nina mengi ya kuwaongelea hao kama unataka tujikite huko!
 
May be you're right if, and only if ZNZ watazizika siasa zao za ASP & HIZBU!! Wengi wanaamini kwenye uchaguzi wa 2005, JK alimchafua SAS kiasi cha SAS kushindwa kuchomoza wakati ukweli bado upo pale pale kwamba bado siasa za 1960s bado zina-exist ZNZ!

Kuhusu uwezo wa SAS, sina shaka nae hata kidogo ingawaje am afraid kama ataweza kuendana na kasi ya kisiasa ya sasa for two major reasons:
1. Namuona SAS kwamba ni Mstaraabu na Muungwana kupitiliza!! Nchi kama hii ambayo imeoza kila mahali haipaswi kuwa na kiongozi muungwana na mstaarabu kupitiliza!! Kwa kawaida, waungwana na wastaarabu waliopitiliza huwa wameumbwa na muhari....na hili ndilo lilikuwa tatizo kubwa lingine la Ally Hassan Mwinyi!

2. Sababu ya pili naona kama SAS atakuwa aged sana by 2015....i think atakuwa about 70 years!! Hata kama umri si tatizo katika suala zima la uongozi, lakini bado ukweli unabaki pale pale nchi yenye changamoto nyingi kama Tanzania basi inahitaji kiongozi mwenye siha njema atayeweza kukimbizana na changamoto zinazolikabili taifa! Isingekuwa tatizo endapo nchi yetu tungekuwa na utamaduni wa uwajibikaji; kwamba team yake, especially mawaziri, permanent secretaries and the like inakuwa active and reactive at any given point of time! Unfortunately, Watanzania hatuko hivyo na ndio maana hadi leo ukiwauliza ni kiongozi gani amepata kuwa mchapa kazi hodari nchi hii basi Watanzania walio wengi watakutajia Sokoine; a guy died over a quarter a century ago!!
 
Couldn't do a much better analysis. Kudos.

zomba I have something against you...............but I will reserve till the right opportunity present itself.............lol!
 
May be you're right if, and only if ZNZ watazizika siasa zao za ASP & HIZBU!! Wengi wanaamini kwenye uchaguzi wa 2005, JK alimchafua SAS kiasi cha SAS kushindwa kuchomoza wakati ukweli bado upo pale pale kwamba bado siasa za 1960s bado zina-exist ZNZ!

Kuhusu uwezo wa SAS, sina shaka nae hata kidogo ingawaje am afraid kama ataweza kuendana na kasi ya kisiasa ya sasa for two major reasons:
1. Namuona SAS kwamba ni Mstaraabu na Muungwana kupitiliza!! Nchi kama hii ambayo imeoza kila mahali haipaswi kuwa na kiongozi muungwana na mstaarabu kupitiliza!! Kwa kawaida, waungwana na wastaarabu waliopitiliza huwa wameumbwa na muhari....na hili ndilo lilikuwa tatizo kubwa lingine la Ally Hassan Mwinyi!

2. Sababu ya pili naona kama SAS atakuwa aged sana by 2015....i think atakuwa about 70 years!! Hata kama umri si tatizo katika suala zima la uongozi, lakini bado ukweli unabaki pale pale nchi yenye changamoto nyingi kama Tanzania basi inahitaji kiongozi mwenye siha njema atayeweza kukimbizana na changamoto zinazolikabili taifa! Isingekuwa tatizo endapo nchi yetu tungekuwa na utamaduni wa uwajibikaji; kwamba team yake, especially mawaziri, permanent secretaries and the like inakuwa active and reactive at any given point of time! Unfortunately, Watanzania hatuko hivyo na ndio maana hadi leo ukiwauliza ni kiongozi gani amepata kuwa mchapa kazi hodari nchi hii basi Watanzania walio wengi watakutajia Sokoine; a guy died over a quarter a century ago!!

NasDaz kinachoongoza nchi ni busara na hivi sasa katika khali hii ya kutunishiana misuli na viongozi wengi kuwa hawana hata chembe ya busara na kuabudu matumbo yao...............our history calls for a politically sober guy and this guy fits the bill. Suala hapa siyo siha au umri lakini exposure to local and international realities...............kuhusu ukali anao ule tunaouhitaji na mimi bado ninakumbuka vyema wakati akiwa PM....................he was marvelous but he is unsung hero of this CCM madness.........
 
Rutashubanyuma: I like your good analysis. Salim would be a very good presidential candidate regarding his integrity only if the current political system is overhauled. However, the CCM system that exists today is too wickedly complicated to undo to bring it to its original political intent. Salim would be better off as an adviser to the party at the CCM CC level rather than president. My argument is based on the fact that the president is highly influenced by those around him. Now, if the future president is flanked by a majority of greedy, corrupt, opportunists and many incompetent CCM leaders typical of today's and near future leadership,do you think he can be effective under such circumstances???
 
Back
Top Bottom