what is the effect of declaring a provision of the statute unconstitutional?

what is the effect of declaring a provision of the statute unconstitutional?

Retired

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2016
Posts
44,629
Reaction score
83,056
In India, the statute is published only once in a government notification called "The Gazette of India" published by the Directorate of Printing, Department of Publication under the Ministry of Urban Development.
Once the Supreme Court or the High Court declares a specific provision of a statute as invalid, the section becomes operationally invalid thereinafter. The Parliament is not required to specifically repeal it through a motion or make a publication to this effect. The courts would consider that provision as no longer effective and would abstain from applying it to cases before it.

In Indiana (US) and the US Supreme court:
The Supreme Court of Indiana has said that if a statute is unconstitutional it "is no law, and cannot be used to give appellee a right of action against appellant." And again, in passing upon an amendment to a statute which was held to be unconstitutional, the court said in Carr v. State,3 "An act which violates the Constitution has no power and can, of course, neither build up or tear down. It can neither create new rights nor destroy existing ones. It is an empty legislative declaration without force or vitality."

In accordance with the views expressed above it is held in Indiana that a repealing act which is unconstitutional can have no effect upon the statute sought to be repealed and the previous statute remains the law as though the legislature had not made any attempt to change it.


Does this position of the law apply in Tanzania?
 
This is United Republic of Tanzania not less not more...this definition is clear!
 
This is United Republic of Tanzania not less not more...this definition is clear!
Sijakulenga wewe, hakuna unachojua, hapa hakuna siasa (after all na siasa huzijui, kama kweli hapa TZ kuna siasa) . Give sight for law intellectuals to comment!
 
Sijakulenga wewe, hakuna unachojua, hapa hakuna siasa (after all na siasa huzijui, kama kweli hapa TZ kuna siasa) . Give sight for law intellectuals to comment!
Hata law intelligentsia hawakuelewi
 
In India, the statute is published only once in a government notification called "The Gazette of India" published by the Directorate of Printing, Department of Publication under the Ministry of Urban Development.
Once the Supreme Court or the High Court declares a specific provision of a statute as invalid, the section becomes operationally invalid thereinafter. The Parliament is not required to specifically repeal it through a motion or make a publication to this effect. The courts would consider that provision as no longer effective and would abstain from applying it to cases before it.

In Indiana (US) and the US Supreme court:
The Supreme Court of Indiana has said that if a statute is unconstitutional it "is no law, and cannot be used to give appellee a right of action against appellant." And again, in passing upon an amendment to a statute which was held to be unconstitutional, the court said in Carr v. State,3 "An act which violates the Constitution has no power and can, of course, neither build up or tear down. It can neither create new rights nor destroy existing ones. It is an empty legislative declaration without force or vitality."

In accordance with the views expressed above it is held in Indiana that a repealing act which is unconstitutional can have no effect upon the statute sought to be repealed and the previous statute remains the law as though the legislature had not made any attempt to change it.


Does this position of the law apply in Tanzania?
Mkuu am not a lawyer parse, but when we deal with the issue of interpretation of law, only the Jury has that duty to do so.
The issue here is what if the Jury invalidate the provision of the law provided in the statue as unconstitutional, can legi
 
Mkuu am not a lawyer parse, but when we deal with the issue of interpretation of law, only the Jury has that duty to do so.
The issue here is what if the Jury invalidate the provision of the law provided in the statue as unconstitutional, can legi
Nadhani swali langu ni hili hilo na ndilo hapo chini in a different formulation. Katika common law jurisdiction msimamo ni kama huo niliouweka kwenye post yangu
 
In India, the statute is published only once in a government notification called "The Gazette of India" published by the Directorate of Printing, Department of Publication under the Ministry of Urban Development.
Once the Supreme Court or the High Court declares a specific provision of a statute as invalid, the section becomes operationally invalid thereinafter. The Parliament is not required to specifically repeal it through a motion or make a publication to this effect. The courts would consider that provision as no longer effective and would abstain from applying it to cases before it.

In Indiana (US) and the US Supreme court:
The Supreme Court of Indiana has said that if a statute is unconstitutional it "is no law, and cannot be used to give appellee a right of action against appellant." And again, in passing upon an amendment to a statute which was held to be unconstitutional, the court said in Carr v. State,3 "An act which violates the Constitution has no power and can, of course, neither build up or tear down. It can neither create new rights nor destroy existing ones. It is an empty legislative declaration without force or vitality."

In accordance with the views expressed above it is held in Indiana that a repealing act which is unconstitutional can have no effect upon the statute sought to be repealed and the previous statute remains the law as though the legislature had not made any attempt to change it.


Does this position of the law apply in Tanzania?

Kuna gazeti la serikali 'Government Gazette' ambalo linatangazwa issue kama hizi.Nafikiri hata hapa Tanzania ina apply.Mfano appeal ya kumfutia DPP mamlaka ya kuendelea kumsotesha mtuhumiwa rumande itawekwa kwenye 'Government gazette'.Ila sina uhakika kama bado lipo au lilishakufa.Lilikuwa linachapwa na Government printers walikuwa na ofisi hapo mitaafulani ya posta mpya
 
Kuna gazeti la serikali 'Government Gazette' ambalo linatangazwa issue kama hizi.Nafikiri hata hapa Tanzania ina apply.Mfano appeal ya kumfutia DPP mamlaka ya kuendelea kumsotesha mtuhumiwa rumande itawekwa kwenye 'Government gazette'.Ila sina uhakika kama bado lipo au lilishakufa.Lilikuwa linachapwa na Government printers walikuwa na ofisi hapo mitaafulani ya posta mpya
Lipo maana lazima gov reports zichapishwe humo.. hata sheria zinaripotiwa humo etc...
 
Lipo maana lazima gov reports zichapishwe humo.. hata sheria zinaripotiwa humo etc...

Lakini yawezekana hata copies zake ni chache sana maana hata kiwanda chake kiliishafilisiwa na watawala wetu
 
Back
Top Bottom