A CRITICAL REVIEW OF THE COURT OF APPEAL’S DECISION IN ‘Mlimani Holdings Limited Versus Commissioner General (TRA)’

A CRITICAL REVIEW OF THE COURT OF APPEAL’S DECISION IN ‘Mlimani Holdings Limited Versus Commissioner General (TRA)’

Joined
Dec 18, 2023
Posts
73
Reaction score
20

Introduction​

In the global race for Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), the United Republic of Tanzania has deliberately positioned itself as an attractive and predictable investment destination. This commitment has been operationalised through the institutional framework of the Tanzania Investment Centre, now reconstituted as the Tanzania Investment and Special Economic Zones Authority. A central feature of this framework is the conferment of Strategic Investor Status, typically accompanied by negotiated fiscal incentives embodied in Performance Contracts, intended to assure investors of stability, predictability, and government support.

However, the recent judgment of the Court of Appeal of Tanzania in Civil Appeal No. 505 of 2022 (decided on 9th April 2025) has unsettled these expectations. By affirming a tax liability of TZS 2.4 billion against an investor who held a valid government agreement granting tax exemption solely on the basis that a Government Notice (GN) had not been published the Court appears to have prioritised procedural formalities over substantive justice. This approach raises critical concerns regarding the reliability of state commitments and the extent to which investors can legitimately rely on government agreements.

This article examines the factual matrix of the case, the reasoning adopted by the Court, and the broader implications of this decision on Tanzania’s investment climate and tax jurisprudence. It further draws from comparative landmark decisions across jurisdictions, with a view to demonstrating how courts have addressed similar tensions between administrative compliance and substantive rights. In doing so, the article argues for a more principled and consistent approach in tax adjudication one that promotes certainty, fairness, and coherence particularly in instances where the Court of Appeal departs from its own established jurisprudence without clear doctrinal justification.

The Factual Matrix
The Appellant, Mlimani Holdings Limited, entered into a formal Performance Contract with the Government of Tanzania. A key provision of this agreement granted exemption from withholding tax on interest arising from foreign loans intended to finance its investment project.

Relying on the sanctity of contract and its Strategic Investor status, the Appellant proceeded with its operations and structured its financial obligations accordingly. Subsequently, the Tanzania Revenue Authority (TRA) conducted an audit and issued a tax demand amounting to TZS 2.4 billion.

The TRA’s position was straightforward: notwithstanding the existence of the Performance Contract, the exemption had no legal effect because the Minister for Finance had not issued a Government Notice in the official Gazette. In the absence of this formal step, the exemption was deemed not to exist in law.

Form over substance
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and endorsed a strict interpretation of the statutory framework. It held that, tax exemptions are creatures of statute, not contract, the issuance and publication of a Government Notice is a mandatory condition precedent; and the existence of a Performance Contract does not estop the TRA from collecting tax where statutory requirements remain unfulfilled.

This reasoning reflects a formalistic approach in which procedural compliance takes precedence over the substantive arrangement between the investor and the State.

Misapplication of section 10(1) of the Income Tax Act, Cap 332.
The decision of the Court of Appeal of Tanzania, adopts an unduly rigid approach by insisting that tax exemption is only valid upon publication of a Government Notice (GN) under section 10(1) of the Income Tax Act, Cap. 332 [R.E. 2023], despite an existing government agreement granting such exemption. This elevates form over substance. Once the Government commits to an exemption, it creates a legitimate expectation that must be honoured. Interpreting “may” as absolute discretion ignores the duty to act in good faith. Penalizing the taxpayer for the Minister’s failure to gazette the exemption is unfair and undermines certainty.

Intellectual and professional reflections​
  • Administrative absurdity and state responsibility. Is it legally sound to penalize a taxpayer for the Government’s own failure to perform an administrative duty?​
  • While the Court answers this in the affirmative, the outcome produces what may properly be described as an administrative absurdity. The TIC and the Ministry of Finance are both organs of the same Government. Where one arm grants an incentive and another fails to formalize it, the State effectively benefits from its own omission.​
  • A particularly troubling provision is section 4(3) of the Tanzania Revenue Authority Act, Cap 399 [R.E. 2023], which expressly states that the TRA is an agent of the Government and operates under the general supervision of the Minister for Finance. The section provides: “The Authority shall be an agency of the Government and shall be under the general supervision of the Minister.”​
  • This raises a fundamental question: how can an agent disregard or fail to comply with an agreement lawfully entered into by its principal, the Government and a taxpayer?​
  • Comparative jurisprudence offers a more balanced perspective. In R vs. Inland Revenue Commissioners, ex parte MFK Underwriting Agencies Ltd [1990] 1 WLR 1545, the English Court held that a legitimate expectation arises where a representation is “clear, unambiguous and devoid of relevant qualification.”​
  • Similarly, in R (Davies) vs. HMRC [2011] UKSC 47, it was affirmed that where such representation exists, it cannot be withdrawn in a manner that is unfair or retrospective.​
  • Applying these principles, a formally executed Performance Contract issued under a statutory investment regime arguably meets the threshold of clarity required to found a legitimate expectation. Denying its effect due to an internal administrative lapse undermines the very purpose of governmental assurances.​
  • Fair and Equitable Treatment (FET). The decision also raises concerns when examined against the principle of Fair and Equitable Treatment (FET) in investment law. This principle requires host States to provide a stable, predictable, and transparent legal framework.​
  • The Supreme Court of India in Vodafone International Holdings BV vs. Union of India (2012) 6 SCC 613 emphasized that tax liability must rest on clear statutory authority and that investors are entitled to certainty and predictability in the legal framework governing their investments. The Court further cautioned against stretching tax provisions beyond their express terms.​
  • In contrast, the Mlimani Holdings decision introduces uncertainty by allowing a procedural omission wholly outside the investor’s control to defeat a substantive entitlement. These risks reducing Strategic Investor Status to a mere statement of intent rather than a legally enforceable right.​
  • The Position of the TRA and Governmental Integrity. Although the TRA is established as a body corporate, it remains an agent of the Government. Allowing it to disregard obligations arising from a Performance Contract executed by the Government creates what may be termed a “syndicated institutional contradiction.”​
  • UK jurisprudence further underscores the need for fairness in such circumstances. In R (Cameron) vs. HMRC [2012] UKUT, it was held that a legitimate expectation, once established, should not be withdrawn retrospectively in a manner that produces unfairness.​
  • In practical terms, the Government secures investment through negotiated incentives, only for another arm of the same Government to negate those incentives through tax enforcement. This outcome undermines the principle of governmental integrity and coherence.​
The overlooked doctrine of sanctity of contract
A critical omission in the decisions of the Tanzania Revenue Authority (TRA), the Tax Revenue Appeals Board (TRAB), the Tax Revenue Appeals Tribunal (TRAT), and ultimately the Court of Appeal is the failure to give due weight to the doctrine of sanctity of contract. The Performance Contract executed between the Appellant and the Government was a formal and binding instrument issued within the statutory investment framework, granting a clear exemption from withholding tax. By disregarding this contractual entitlement solely due to the absence of a Government Notice, the authorities effectively subordinated a lawful government agreement to internal procedural formalities. This approach undermines the principle that agreements entered into by the State particularly those intended to induce investment must be honored.

The consequence of this omission is both legal and practical. It exposes the Appellant to tax liability contrary to an express contractual exemption, thereby penalizing it for a procedural lapse attributable to the Government itself. Comparative jurisprudence, including R (Davies) vs. HMRC [2011] UKSC 47 and Vodafone International Holdings BV vs. Union of India (2012) 6 SCC 613, underscores the importance of certainty, consistency, and respect for binding representations in public and tax administration. In failing to uphold these principles, the decisions collectively weaken the enforceability of government commitments and risk eroding investor confidence in the integrity of Tanzania’s legal and investment framework.

A crisis of tax jurisprudence
The Presidential Tax Reforms Commission has observed that a rigid and overly literal approach by the Court of Appeal may, in certain instances, disrupt the development of sound tax jurisprudence.

Taxation is not merely a tool for revenue collection; it is an instrument of economic policy and investment facilitation. Principles such as objectivity and best judgment require tax administrators to consider all relevant circumstances, including the existence of binding agreements.

Comparative authority reinforces this position. In Vodafone, the Indian Supreme Court emphasized that taxation must not be imposed by implication and that authorities must consider transactions holistically rather than mechanically. Likewise, UK authorities demonstrate that administrative powers must be exercised consistently with fairness and legitimate expectations.

To disregard a Performance Contract solely due to the absence of a Government Notice is to prioritize form at the expense of substance, thereby undermining the purpose of incentive-based investment policies.

The way forward
The uncertainty created by this decision calls for deliberate corrective measures. Judicial review, there is a strong basis for seeking review under the Court of Appeal Rules. The critical issue is whether a ministerial omission over which the investor has no control can nullify rights arising from a formally executed government agreement without affording any remedy.

Comparative jurisprudence suggests that courts should adopt a more purposive approach, balancing statutory interpretation with fairness, legitimate expectation, and administrative justice.

Legislative reform, there is also a need for legislative intervention. The law should be amended to ensure that incentives granted through TIC mechanisms are self-executing. The requirement for a Government Notice should operate as a procedural formality that follows automatically from the contract, rather than as a substantive condition capable of defeating the investor’s rights.

Such reform would align Tanzania’s legal framework with international best practices and restore investor confidence.

Conclusion
The Mlimani Holdings decision stands as a cautionary precedent within Tanzania’s investment and tax landscape. It demonstrates that an investor may comply with all contractual obligations, rely on governmental assurances, and yet face substantial tax exposure due to a procedural lapse beyond its control.

Comparative jurisprudence from the United Kingdom and India makes it clear that while taxation must be grounded in statute, it must also be administered with fairness, predictability, and respect for legitimate expectations. For Tanzania to remain competitive in attracting and retaining investment, a recalibration is necessary. The legal framework must balance statutory compliance with fairness, coherence, and economic rationale.

Tax justice must ultimately be just, fair, and objective. Anything less risks transforming taxation from a tool of development into a constraint on growth.

Author,
Respicius E. Mwijage (Advocate cum Tax Consultant),
SARC Law Chambers,
City Mall, 1st Floor, F-27A Bibi Titi /Morogoro Road
P. O. Box 13452, Dar Es Salaam
Tel: +255 754 302 054
Website:
www.sarclawchambers.co.tz
E-Mail: [email protected]
/[email protected]. ​
 

Attachments

Mie sijaelewa, lakini naunga mkono hoja...🤭
 
Back
Top Bottom