Huku Watanzania wakichekelea changamoto za SGR ya Kenya, TAZARA waliyopewa kama msaada miaka zaidi ya 40 haijawapa faida yoyote

Huku Watanzania wakichekelea changamoto za SGR ya Kenya, TAZARA waliyopewa kama msaada miaka zaidi ya 40 haijawapa faida yoyote

MK254

JF-Expert Member
Joined
May 11, 2013
Posts
32,408
Reaction score
50,809
Imekua desturi kwa baadhi ya Watanzania kusubiria kama fisi kila tangazo hasi la SGR ya Kenya, huwapa muhemko fulani hivi wa kuja kupost humu kwa raha, huku wakisahau TAZARA waliyojengewa na Mchina kama msaada imetimiza miaka zaidi ya 40 bila kuwapa faida yoyote.

-------------------------

Tazara Fails to Meet Its Targets Despite Huge Business Potential

Dar es Salaam — The Dar es Salaam-based Tanzania-Zambia Railway Authority (Tazara), which operates the 1,860-kilometre long railway running between Kapiri Mposhi in Zambia and Dar es Salaam in Tanzania, has adopted the principle of 'break even point' as a measure for operational success.

Construction of the railway line, which was formally commissioned in 1975, was started in 1970, with financial and other support provided by the People's Republic of China.

At its completion, Tazara became the longest railway line in sub-Saharan Africa. It was also the largest single foreign-aid project undertaken by China at the time, at a total construction cost of $406 million (roughly $2.67 billion today).

Yet, roughly 45 years after the railway became operational, it is yet to achieve its goal of transporting 600,000 metric tonnes of freight a year.

The Authority is yet to achieve this target partly due to certain operational challenges. Speaking to The Citizen in an exclusive interview, the Zambian Tazara managing director and chief executive officer (CEO), Mr Bruno Ching'andu, said one of the major challenges that are plaguing the Authority is a lack of ways and means of adequate recapitalisation and operating capital.

"Generally, this tends to lead to lack of spare parts that are needed to repair or replace malfunctioning or broken parts and other equipment, as well as lack of materials that are required to repair damaged portions of the railway track," he said.

According to the CEO, as the result of financial and other inadequacies, Tazara is left with a rolling stock that is not available for continuous operations, or that which simply cannot be relied upon for functional and sustained operations.

"Equally, the poor condition of the railway track about 50 years down the line invariably leaves us with no choice but to run our trains at slower speeds. If nothing else, this limit the frequency and volumes of traffic in a year," Mr Ching'andu said.

Revealing that Tazara has yet to break-even, he nonetheless said that its operations and general performance have been on a positive trend for the past six years.

"The last six years have seen to an average growth of 22 percent a year in freight traffic, and 9.9 percent per year in passenger traffic."
During the financial year which ended on June 30, 2019, the Authority had moved in all a total of 362,710 metric tons, he said - adding that this was a gain in terms of the total net freight volumes taken off the roads.

However, the freight traffic had been nose-diving since 2007 - reaching the lowest level of 88,000 metric tons in 2015. Then the freight traffic started to show improvements from 2016, when it reached 130,000 metric tons.

"The performance in 2015-2016 was a consequence of acute limitation of working capital, which led to shortages of fuel and delayed payment of workers' salaries, resulting in numerous incidents of work stoppages," he virtually lamented.

Then in the 2016/2017 financial year, the freight volume increased to 171,000 metric tons - and then rose to 220,818 metric tons in 2017/2018.

Passengers traffic
Tazara operates three kinds of passenger trains, including cross-border or interstate trains.

In the 2018/2019 financial year, Tazara transported a total of 3,046,002 passengers as against a target of 3,400,000 passengers.
This was roughly 90 percent performance vis-à-vis the target that was set earlier.

However, that figure was nine (9) percent lower than the 3,355, 551 passengers transported in the previous financial year, namely: 2017/2018.

Role played by private operators
The Tazara CEO revealed that "the Authority recently entered into an agreement with a private operator to use the Tazara infrastructure on an 'Open Access' basis.

"This has enabled the Authority to earn revenues in the form of 'Access Fees.'"

The private operator - namely 'Calabash Freight Limited' - was able to move 187,113 metric tons of freight under the agreement in 2018/2019, which boosted the total tonnage moved on the Tazara facility to 362,710 metric tons.
Private shareholders?

Tazara is binational railway jointly owned by the Governments of the United Republic of Tanzania and the Republic of Zambia on a 50-50 share holding basis.

Regarding the issue of allowing private operators to use the Tazara facility, the managing director said this has not substantially changed the current share-holding structure, which remains as it has always been from the beginning.

"The public will be informed should any changes occur in the share-holding structure," he assured Zambians and Tanzanians as the 'ultimate shareholders' of Tazara.

Tazara's contribution to Tanzania's economy
The establishment of Tazara has been a catalyst for growth and expansion of small settlements along the line: settlements which have now become big communities as administrative districts and urban centers.

For instance: places like Mlimba, Makambako and Ifakara in Tanzania are some of towns that have developed tremendously in the last 45 years or so - and continue to grow through Tazara's services and spin-off effects, to the benefit of the country, says Mr Ching'andu.
Tazara is the only means of transport and vehicle for poverty alleviation for most of the people living along the line.

If nothing else, this has effectively incorporated the communities in those areas into the mainstream economy of the country. And what is said for Tanzania can equally well be said for Zambia, the other partner in what amounts to a joint venture between the two Governments.

What is more, Tazara provides an opportunity to functionally decongest the roads and the Port of Dar es Salaam, thereby saving the resources which would otherwise be lost through frequent repairs of roads which ordinarily should not be transporting heavy and bulky cargo, as well as other logistical facilities in the region.

Tazara also contributes to tourism development, for example: transporting tourists to and from the Selous Game Reserve and other en route parts in the Southern regions of the country.

The Authority directly employs over 1,500 Tanzanians who earn their livelihoods from the railway system.

Given improved operations, the Authority indeed has the potential to positively impact even more Tanzanian lives.

Tanzania: Tazara Fails to Meet Its Targets Despite Huge Business Potential
 
Quick things I have noted. Tazara is their MGR so I will not compare it to Kenyan sgr which is a beast on another level since the Kenyan sgr hauls about 2,000,000 tonnes of cargo every quarter and growing.
I will compare it to our MGR, which is currently being renovated and revamped.

i) 45 years and not yet achieving 600,000 metric tonnes annually is a huge under performance, if I am to compare it with the Nairobi- Nanyuki MGR which currently does 5000 tonnes of processed fruit juice weekly,8000 tonnes of edible oils weekly and 12,000,000 litres of oil every month among other products. All this has been achieved in 2 months since this branch of the MGR started working after decades of being idle.

ii) The trains seem to be unreliable even for passenger services carrying only three million passengers yearly for a country as populated as Tanzania is lacklustre at best, compare that the currently under renovation Nairobi Metropolitan commuter rail way with only 11 DMUs and will shuttle that same number of passengers monthly at speeds of 80 km/hr- 100 km/hr around Nairobi Metropolitan area.

iii) employing over 1500 staff for a railway that does less than 600,000 metric tonnes yearly is not prudent. It is a sign of over dependence on government institutions in employment.

NB: We are yet to see what the future holds for Nakuru-Kisumu and Nakuru-Malaba railway MGR under renovation, but from the current kisumu port cargo traffic it will definitely carry more cargo than Tazara in a few months of being launched. Noting also that all current MGR upgrades in Kenya include replacing the 50lbs sleepers with 80 lbs sleepers and word is new MGR rolling stock for cargo from Naivasha ICD will be procured.
 
Mimi kama raia wa Banana republic naunga mkono hoja boss
 
Quick things I have noted. Tazara is their MGR so I will not compare it to Kenyan sgr which is a beast on another level since the Kenyan sgr hauls about 2,000,000 tonnes of cargo every quarter and growing.
I will compare it to our MGR, which is currently being renovated and revamped.

i) 45 years and not yet achieving 600,000 metric tonnes annually is a huge under performance, if I am to compare it with the Nairobi- Nanyuki MGR which currently does 5000 tonnes of processed fruit juice weekly,8000 tonnes of edible oils weekly and 12,000,000 litres of oil every month among other products. All this has been achieved in 2 months since this branch of the MGR started working after decades of being idle.

ii) The trains seem to be unreliable even for passenger services carrying only three million passengers yearly for a country as populated as Tanzania is lacklustre at best, compare that the currently under renovation Nairobi Metropolitan commuter rail way with only 11 DMUs and will shuttle that same number of passengers monthly at speeds of 80 km/hr- 100 km/hr around Nairobi Metropolitan area.

iii) employing over 1500 staff for a railway that does less than 600,000 metric tonnes yearly is not prudent. It is a sign of over dependence on government institutions in employment.

NB: We are yet to see what the future holds for Nakuru-Kisumu and Nakuru-Malaba railway MGR under renovation, but from the current kisumu port cargo traffic it will definitely carry more cargo than Tazara in a few months of being launched. Noting also that all current MGR upgrades in Kenya include replacing the 50lbs sleepers with 80 lbs sleepers and word is new MGR rolling stock for cargo from Naivasha ICD will be procured.

Umeiweka vizuri sana, well put.....thanks
 
Tatizo huelewi kuhusu Tazara mkuu MK254,Tazara inamilikiwa na nchi 2 Tanzania na Zambia kutokana na mkataba uliongiwa huko nyuma hata mkurugenzi mkuu ilikuwa lazima atoke Zambia.Hivyo kwa sasa kuna mabadiliko yanafanyika hasa alipokuja raisi Lungu tazania kwenye ziara rasmi.Mojawapo ilikubaliwa kila nchi itoe 10 Bilion ili kufufua engine na kurekebisha njia zile sehemu korofi but Zambian hawajatoa kabisa.Tanzania walitoa na baadhi ya fedha zimenunua traction motor ili kufufua Engine 7 na nadhani mpaka mwezi wa 10 zote zitzkuwa zimekamilika hivyo kuongeza ufanisi.Pamoja na hilo kuna ukarabati wa mabehewa ya mizigo unaendelea Dar es salaam.
Pia ilikubaliwa kila nchi iweze kuhudumia sehemu yake hivyo kwa sasa kama limepita Tanzania inaweza kununua Engine na Mabehewa yake yenyewe ikawa mali yake tofauti na sasa ukiwekeza kila kitu kinakuwa cha nchi mbili.Na kumbuka Rais Magufuli alisema sasa wanageukia kwa TAZARA hivyo soon hili shirika linarudi kwa kasi maana hata mishahara kwa sasa GOT inalipa kwa upande wa Tanzania.Tatiozo kubwa lilikuwa ni juu ya muundo wa TAZARA hivyo changamoto zinamalizwa.
 
Quick things I have noted. Tazara is their MGR so I will not compare it to Kenyan sgr which is a beast on another level since the Kenyan sgr hauls about 2,000,000 tonnes of cargo every quarter and growing.
I will compare it to our MGR, which is currently being renovated and revamped.

i) 45 years and not yet achieving 600,000 metric tonnes annually is a huge under performance, if I am to compare it with the Nairobi- Nanyuki MGR which currently does 5000 tonnes of processed fruit juice weekly,8000 tonnes of edible oils weekly and 12,000,000 litres of oil every month among other products. All this has been achieved in 2 months since this branch of the MGR started working after decades of being idle.

ii) The trains seem to be unreliable even for passenger services carrying only three million passengers yearly for a country as populated as Tanzania is lacklustre at best, compare that the currently under renovation Nairobi Metropolitan commuter rail way with only 11 DMUs and will shuttle that same number of passengers monthly at speeds of 80 km/hr- 100 km/hr around Nairobi Metropolitan area.

iii) employing over 1500 staff for a railway that does less than 600,000 metric tonnes yearly is not prudent. It is a sign of over dependence on government institutions in employment.

NB: We are yet to see what the future holds for Nakuru-Kisumu and Nakuru-Malaba railway MGR under renovation, but from the current kisumu port cargo traffic it will definitely carry more cargo than Tazara in a few months of being launched. Noting also that all current MGR upgrades in Kenya include replacing the 50lbs sleepers with 80 lbs sleepers and word is new MGR rolling stock for cargo from Naivasha ICD will be procured.
Its Cape Gauge and design speed was 110km/h
 
40 years vs 3 years of operation! I couldn't think one can stoop this low!
Hahaha tena upande mmoja wamepigwa kabisa marufuku kutumia malori huku upande mwingine wakitumia excessively malori na reli simultaneously
 
So kama hii ndiyo haijawahi pata faida what about SGR?
Miujiza gani itatumika this round especially itahudumia small countries like Burundi,rwanda eastern DRC
 
Ulitegemea nini mleta mada? Hawa hawa ndio watu ambao wamekuwa wakihamia Dodoma tangia miaka ya 70's.
 
Imekua desturi kwa baadhi ya Watanzania kusubiria kama fisi kila tangazo hasi la SGR ya Kenya, huwapa muhemko fulani hivi wa kuja kupost humu kwa raha, huku wakisahau TAZARA waliyojengewa na Mchina kama msaada imetimiza miaka zaidi ya 40 bila kuwapa faida yoyote.
Tazara ni ya Tanzania na Zambia,hatuwezi kufanya mabadiliko mpaka Zambia wakubali
ongelea SGR inayomilikiwa na Tanzania kwa 100%
 
Tazara ni ya Tanzania na Zambia,hatuwezi kufanya mabadiliko mpaka Zambia wakubali
ongelea SGR inayomilikiwa na Tanzania kwa 100%

Hizo ngonjera, sasa mnaelekeza lawama kwa Wazambia..hehehe waswahili bana...miaka zaidi ya 40 bila faida hata shilingi moja, mpo mpo tu.
Hata hiyo SGR kasafu kadogo ka 200km Dar-Moro mlitutambia kataanza kazi mwaka jana, sasa mwaka huu unaelekea kuisha, bado hamjakamaliza kaonekane walau hata mkatumie kuomba kura.
Hivi hii awamu ya tano, mna kitu gani cha kuonekana ambacho mnaweza kukitumia kuomba kura, zaidi ya mikwara ya kikabila kwa lugha ya Kisukuma sioni chochote kingine.
Sema tu ni vile kwenu huko ni wafia vyama, mnapofushwa na uchama hadi hakuna atakayehoji chochote au kuskliza chochote ilmradi alishakua na msimamo wa chama. Hizi kampeni huwa maigizo tu maana hazibadili misimamo ya watu, utakuta mtu kwa umaskini wote anapiga kura kwa kuegemea chama bila kujali nini wala nini.
Lakini pia hiyo kete ya ukabila inaweza kuwatoa kimasomaso maana Wasukuma ndio wengi Tanzania, sasa mkiendelea na hizo kampeni za "mimi ni mtoto wenu Msukuma"....mtanyofoa kura nyingi.

Japo naona mwanasheria Tundu Lissu anaendelea kuwayumbisha, sio kwa nyomi inayomlaki, dah nilijua upinzani umekufa Bongo baada ya kuzuia wasiwe wanakusanyika, sikutegemea maelfu ya watu wawe wanajitokeza hivi na kumlaki mgombea wa upinzani.
CCM hata kama mtashinda, nahisi kwa kura za kipindi hiki mtahisi maumivu fulani. Japo mimi kama Mkenya ningependa CCM mshinde maana nyie tumewazoea, hamna jipya, kikomo cha chuki zenu ni kutia vifaranga wetu kiberiti na kukamata ng'ombe ila mengine yote mumeachia, takwimu za kibiashara baina ya Kenya na Tanzania zimeongezeka, bidhaa zetu zinazidi kutia fora huko. Sasa kwa huyu Lissu hatujui urais wake utakua wa namna gani, anaweza akaboresha uhusiano zaidi au akaharibu sana. Wazungu husema better the devil you know....hehehe
 
Hata hiyo SGR kasafu kadogo ka 200km Dar-Moro mlitutambia kataanza kazi mwaka jana, sasa mwaka huu unaelekea kuisha, bado hamjakamaliza kaonekane walau hata mkatumie kuomba kura.
tatizo lenu huwa hamna habari za Tanzania mnategemea sana mitandao tofauti na sisi ambao tunajua kila kitu kuhusu nyinyi
 
tatizo lenu huwa hamna habari za Tanzania mnategemea sana mitandao tofauti na sisi ambao tunajua kila kitu kuhusu nyinyi

Ok wewe mwenye taarifa za Tanzania naomba kufahamu nauli ya treni ya SGR, Dar hadi Moro, leo shilingi ngapi na kama kuna treni ya mchana....hehehe
 
Back
Top Bottom