Jenerali Ulimwengu: Tanzania so close to joining Fatwa culture

Jenerali Ulimwengu: Tanzania so close to joining Fatwa culture

MK254

JF-Expert Member
Joined
May 11, 2013
Posts
32,408
Reaction score
50,809
This past week, I had the dubious fortune of confronting the combined force of the Funny, the Bizarre and the Plain Idiotic. And all culled from one daily newspaper in Dar.

First, the Funny: A gang of South African kidnappers holding a teenager hostage state their ransom, and it is in bitcoin worth some $123,000. Now, the bitcoin has been called a “protocoin,” a mystical currency that only the really initiated can appreciate, and one wonders whether the bandits had some knowledge about the kid’s parents and their savvy around the bitcoin.

Then the Bizarre: An armed militia group in the Congo is holding a number of Ugandan fishermen in Rukungiri district, demanding that they be given 10 boxes of bullets in exchange for the release of their hostages. Like, come take your fishermen but bring us some bullets because we intend to continue kidnapping people when we are done with this deal.

I thought to myself that the underworld was becoming creative. Would it not have been easier for the bandits down south to demand that they be paid in rand? Or in puula, so they could cross into Botswana and have a party? No, they wanted bitcoin, even though it may be difficult for them to translate it into usable cash with which to buy pap.

But, said I to myself, these must be some sophisticates who have gone crooked only because they need to make fast dough, which they shall invest by and by.

They know the real value of the bitcoin, and that, although it sometimes behaves like a yoyo, it is likely to stabilise at some stage and attain real value. Ask the Chinese.

The guys with the guns in the troubled so-called Democratic Republic may also have a point. Just think of it. This is an area where close to no government exists, and where it does exist, its currency is the bullet, because nothing gets done without someone being shot.

It would be beating around the bush (sic) to ask for cash as ransom, because there is precious little you could do with the worthless paper they call the national currency. The bullet will do everything for you — get you food, clothes, beer and women, and earn you respect into the bargain. So what the heck!

FYI

And then the Plain Idiotic: In a heated debate in the Tanzanian parliament, legislators are questioning the wisdom of the government’s plans to build a mammoth hydroelectric dam at the expense of a good chunk of the renowned Selous Game Reserve.

The environmental destruction this project is likely to cause includes the felling of some three million ancient trees and the obliteration of hitherto unverified flora and fauna.

At some juncture during the debate in which both ruling-party and opposition members are calling for at least the usual “impact assessment,” some junior minister gets up and tells them all that this project has already been decided upon, and there is no going back. So far so good, as we used to say as kids.

Then the minister offers a perspective that whoever was listening to him would not forget. “For your information,” he is quoted by the papers as saying, “the government will go on with the implementation of the project, whether you like it or not.” He pauses for dramatic effect, and then adds, “and those who are resisting the project will be jailed.”

This is a fatwa you might have expected to be delivered by a higher-ranking ayatollah, not by a junior minister, but there it is. The fact that no one higher than this middling official has come up to tell him to shut up, leaves one with the feeling that maybe this is policy.

It would not surprise me. Tanzanian officials have become so enamoured of issuing fiats, orders, prohibitions and ultimatums that one wonders whether there are any laws, rules or regulations left somewhere in the books for people to consult. All you hear is fatwa for this and fatwa for that.

Now, for the bandits in the south and the militias in the “Democratic Republic,” the way of the fatwa may be alluring, because that is the law of the jungle in which those hoodlums operate.

How have we come so close to joining the trinity of the Funny, the Bizarre and the Plain Idiotic?

Jenerali Ulimwengu is chairman of the board of the Raia Mwema newspaper and an advocate of the High Court in Dar es Salaam. E-mail: jenerali@gmail.com

Fatwa culture: Criticise the dam and you land in Tanzanian jail
 
This past week, I had the dubious fortune of confronting the combined force of the Funny, the Bizarre and the Plain Idiotic. And all culled from one daily newspaper in Dar.

First, the Funny: A gang of South African kidnappers holding a teenager hostage state their ransom, and it is in bitcoin worth some $123,000. Now, the bitcoin has been called a “protocoin,” a mystical currency that only the really initiated can appreciate, and one wonders whether the bandits had some knowledge about the kid’s parents and their savvy around the bitcoin.

Then the Bizarre: An armed militia group in the Congo is holding a number of Ugandan fishermen in Rukungiri district, demanding that they be given 10 boxes of bullets in exchange for the release of their hostages. Like, come take your fishermen but bring us some bullets because we intend to continue kidnapping people when we are done with this deal.

I thought to myself that the underworld was becoming creative. Would it not have been easier for the bandits down south to demand that they be paid in rand? Or in puula, so they could cross into Botswana and have a party? No, they wanted bitcoin, even though it may be difficult for them to translate it into usable cash with which to buy pap.

But, said I to myself, these must be some sophisticates who have gone crooked only because they need to make fast dough, which they shall invest by and by.

They know the real value of the bitcoin, and that, although it sometimes behaves like a yoyo, it is likely to stabilise at some stage and attain real value. Ask the Chinese.

The guys with the guns in the troubled so-called Democratic Republic may also have a point. Just think of it. This is an area where close to no government exists, and where it does exist, its currency is the bullet, because nothing gets done without someone being shot.

It would be beating around the bush (sic) to ask for cash as ransom, because there is precious little you could do with the worthless paper they call the national currency. The bullet will do everything for you — get you food, clothes, beer and women, and earn you respect into the bargain. So what the heck!

FYI

And then the Plain Idiotic: In a heated debate in the Tanzanian parliament, legislators are questioning the wisdom of the government’s plans to build a mammoth hydroelectric dam at the expense of a good chunk of the renowned Selous Game Reserve.

The environmental destruction this project is likely to cause includes the felling of some three million ancient trees and the obliteration of hitherto unverified flora and fauna.

At some juncture during the debate in which both ruling-party and opposition members are calling for at least the usual “impact assessment,” some junior minister gets up and tells them all that this project has already been decided upon, and there is no going back. So far so good, as we used to say as kids.

Then the minister offers a perspective that whoever was listening to him would not forget. “For your information,” he is quoted by the papers as saying, “the government will go on with the implementation of the project, whether you like it or not.” He pauses for dramatic effect, and then adds, “and those who are resisting the project will be jailed.”

This is a fatwa you might have expected to be delivered by a higher-ranking ayatollah, not by a junior minister, but there it is. The fact that no one higher than this middling official has come up to tell him to shut up, leaves one with the feeling that maybe this is policy.

It would not surprise me. Tanzanian officials have become so enamoured of issuing fiats, orders, prohibitions and ultimatums that one wonders whether there are any laws, rules or regulations left somewhere in the books for people to consult. All you hear is fatwa for this and fatwa for that.

Now, for the bandits in the south and the militias in the “Democratic Republic,” the way of the fatwa may be alluring, because that is the law of the jungle in which those hoodlums operate.

How have we come so close to joining the trinity of the Funny, the Bizarre and the Plain Idiotic?

Jenerali Ulimwengu is chairman of the board of the Raia Mwema newspaper and an advocate of the High Court in Dar es Salaam. E-mail: jenerali@gmail.com

Fatwa culture: Criticise the dam and you land in Tanzanian jail
I like the term “junior minister”
 
so even me nikitry to make argument with government regarding this big Dam project, those jerk Junior Ministers will put me straight to jail? Gademned.. So There is no more freedom of expression and Democracy is in coma!
 
Fatwa itself by definition is nonbinding but authoritative legal opinion or learned interpretation by the mufti can give on issues pertained to Islamic law.

But Mr Ulimwengu is deliberately trying to compare fatwa and statutory and judicial laws of this country which are binding with Parliament which has the legal grounds to amend, pass and make new laws.

This is misleading and it shows our beloved chief writer is going downhill.

By the way, this Stiegler's Gorge Project was initiated during first phase government under Mwalimu Nyerere in which Mr Ulimwengu was for some time one of top civil servants at the time and member of CCM.

So, where were was he to bring all these questions then?
 
Fatwa itself by definition is nonbinding but authoritative legal opinion or learned interpretation by the mufti can give on issues pertained to Islamic law.

But Mr Ulimwengu is deliberately trying to compare fatwa and statutory and judicial laws of this country which are binding with Parliament which has the legal grounds to amend, pass and make new laws.

This is misleading and it shows our beloved chief writer is going downhill.

By the way, this Stiegler's Gorge Project was initiated during first phase government under Mwalimu Nyerere in which Mr Ulimwengu was for some time one of top civil servants at the time and member of CCM.

So, where were you to bring all these questions then?

Without defending his position, I would like to answer your question regarding where was he?
He was there. Things do change. We change. I believe even JKN changed over time before his demise.

My reading of Ulimwengu in this piece, centered on the minister who was vowing "whether you like or not". My hunch was, if it is like that, why bring it to the Parliament?. Ulimwengu was trying to show how our politics has become a mockery to the constitution. The Parliament has become rubber-stamp.
 
Without defending his position, I would like to answer your question regarding where was he?
He was there. Things do change. We change. I believe even JKN changed over time before his demise.

My reading of Ulimwengu in this piece, centered on the minister who was vowing "whether you like or not". My hunch was, if it is like that, why bring it to the Parliament?. Ulimwengu was trying to show how our politics has become a mockery to the constitution. The Parliament has become rubber-stamp.

Its not mockery to the institution because this project has been kept in cabinets in offices for years since the late Mwalimu Nyerere era.

The main reasons I believe is lack of funds.

Now this fifth phase government has come up with funds to continue with the project which previous governments have failed to do so.

The feasibility study was done, TANESCO did it and some foreign experts were consulted for their advice and we need 5000 megawatts by 2020 and then 10000 megawatts by 2025.

That's according to the energy policy of 2015.

The problem we have in this country is that, we have people who had used to conning and now that has stopped.

So, things have changed and what we have now is new ideas and new vision and what these people (disruptive MPs) and their henchmen need to know is only they've got to get used to it.
 
Its not mockery to the institution because this project has been kept in cabinets in offices for years since the late Mwalimu Nyerere era.

The main reasons I believe is lack of funds.

Now this fifth phase government has come up with funds to continue with the project which previous governments have failed to do so.

The feasibility study was done, TANESCO did it and some foreign experts were consulted for their advice and we need 5000 megawatts by 2020 and then 10000 megawatts by 2025.

That's according to the energy policy of 2015.

The problem we have in this country is that, we have people who had used to conning and now that has stopped.

So, things have changed and what we have now is new ideas and new vision and what these people (disruptive MPs) need to know is only to get used to it.

My friend, I have no problem with project itself if it is according to what you are saying. We all need enough energy for the propagated industrial economy. My problem which I think was Ulimwengu's problem, is the language used by a minister to Parliamentarians. If the project was shelved for lack of funds and now they are available, just say it.

We are told the last budget was reimbursed below 50% but at the same time we are told money is there. Someone need to explain this paradox instead of displaying the might of government in implementing the questionable projects.
 
Fatwa itself by definition is nonbinding but authoritative legal opinion or learned interpretation by the mufti can give on issues pertained to Islamic law.

But Mr Ulimwengu is deliberately trying to compare fatwa and statutory and judicial laws of this country which are binding with Parliament which has the legal grounds to amend, pass and make new laws.

This is misleading and it shows our beloved chief writer is going downhill.

By the way, this Stiegler's Gorge Project was initiated during first phase government under Mwalimu Nyerere in which Mr Ulimwengu was for some time one of top civil servants at the time and member of CCM.

So, where were was he to bring all these questions then?
Not all best questions comes at you in right time. Let him dance what he believes is the best to be....
 
My friend, I have no problem with project itself if it is according to what you are saying. We all need enough energy for the propagated industrial economy. My problem which I think was Ulimwengu's problem, is the language used by a minister to Parliamentarians. If the project was shelved for lack of funds and now they are available, just say it.

We are told the last budget was reimbursed below 50% but at the same time we are told money is there. Someone need to explain this paradox instead of displaying the might of government in implementing the questionable projects.

In June 2017 the deputy minister for energy Dr Medard Kalemani gave all info regarding this and it was after president JPM visited Coastal Region.

He said it clearly that government now has funds for this project and will finance it after the diligent contractor was found.

So we will have this one Stiegler's Gorge at Selous Rufiji water falls (not in the game reserve), Kinyerezi I Extension, MW 185 and Kinyerezi II MW 240.

And by 2025 we will have complete infrastructure of our energy resources which will boots our economy out of stagnation and every Tanzania will have opportunity to flourish in our country.

You know sometimes we work our brain out of creativity but there is a key to process development.

In this one, Energy is the key.
 
In June 2017 the deputy minister for energy Dr Medard Kalemani gave all info regarding this and it was after president JPM visited Coastal Region.

He said it clearly that government now has funds for this project and will finance it after the diligent contractor was found.

So we will have this one Stiegler's Gorge at Selous Rufiji water falls (not in the game reserve), Kinyerezi I Extension, MW 185 and Kinyerezi II MW 240.

And by 2025 we will have complete infrastructure of our energy resources which will boots our economy out of stagnation and every Tanzania will have opportunity to flourish in our country.

You know sometimes we work our brain out of creativity but there is a key to process development.

In this one, Energy is the key.

Agreed. But in development as transformation, the process matter more than results. Unsustainable projects in most cases than not, are due to flawed process that do not respect people's ideas. This is a giant project. To carry it out, persuasion is better than money. Let's go ahead but given an opportunity, I will coach our ministers not to bank on muscles.
 
Agreed. But in development as transformation, the process matter more than results. Unsustainable projects in most cases than not, are due to flawed process that do not respect people's ideas. This is a giant project. To carry it out, persuasion is better than money. Let's go ahead but given an opportunity, I will coach our ministers not to bank on muscles.

Tell them (ministers) to spend time to explain in details to make these people understand and not to be seen bulldozing everything as its been claimed in the article.

They have to accept challenges as these, always building confidence within themselves.

😀😀
 
Does he know exactly the meaning of fatwa huyu mzee
Usichanganye Fatwa na upuuzi huu
 
Back
Top Bottom