Mindyou
JF-Expert Member
- Sep 2, 2024
- 2,536
- 7,194
Mahakama ya Katiba nchini Uganda imetoa uamuzi wa kihistoria kwa kufuta vipengele kadhaa vya Sheria ya Matumizi Mabaya ya Kompyuta ya mwaka 2022 (Computer Misuse Amendment Act), ikisema kuwa sheria hiyo inakiuka haki za msingi za binadamu.
Katika hukumu iliyotolewa kwa kauli moja na jopo la majaji watano, mahakama imesema kuwa sehemu kubwa ya sheria hiyo ni "batili" kwa sababu inaminya uhuru wa kujieleza na haki ya kupata habari, mambo ambayo yanalindwa na Katiba ya nchi.
Hata hivyo, Mahakama ilitupilia mbali utetezi huo. Jaji Irene Mulyagonja, katika hukumu yake, alieleza kuwa sheria hiyo ilivuka mipaka inayokubalika kikatiba. Alibainisha kuwa vifungu vya 23, 26, 27, na 29, pamoja na kifungu cha 162 cha Sheria ya Kanuni za Adhabu, vilikuwa na lugha isiyoeleweka na yenye uwezekano wa kutumiwa vibaya kuwakamata watu bila hatia.
Ushahidi kutoka kwenye kumbukumbu za Bunge (Hansard) na maelezo ya Karani wa Bunge ulionyesha kuwa:
==========================
The Constitutional Court has declared several provisions of the Computer Misuse (Amendment) Act, 2022 unconstitutional, ruling that parts of the law violate fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution, including freedom of expression and access to information.
In a unanimous decision by a five-justice panel, the court found that key sections of the law were vague, overly broad, and prone to abuse, effectively criminalising legitimate speech.
Delivering the lead judgment, Justice Irene Mulyagonja ruled that Sections 23, 26, 27 and 29 of the Computer Misuse Act, along with Section 162 of the Penal Code Act, are “null and void” for failing the constitutional test of legality.
The court examined provisions that criminalised sharing information deemed to “ridicule,” “demean,” or “promote hostility,” as well as those targeting anonymous communication and unsolicited content. It held that such offences lacked clear definitions, creating uncertainty and opening the door to arbitrary enforcement.
Petitioners—including Unwanted Witness Uganda, African Centre for Media Excellence, and the Editors' Guild—argued that the provisions violated Articles 29 and 41 of the Constitution, which guarantee freedom of expression and access to information.
The Attorney General defended the law, maintaining that the provisions were necessary to regulate harmful online conduct such as hate speech and malicious information.
However, the court found that the restrictions went beyond acceptable constitutional limits.
"The enactment of the Computer (Amendment) Bill into an Act of Parliament without complying with rule 24 (3) of the Rules of Procedure of Parliament was inconsistent with Articles 88 and 89 of the Constitution," the judges said.
Beyond substance, the court also identified a critical procedural flaw in the enactment of the law. Evidence, including the Hansard of September 8, 2022 and affidavits from the Clerk to Parliament, showed that Parliament passed the amendments without verifying the required quorum.
Katika hukumu iliyotolewa kwa kauli moja na jopo la majaji watano, mahakama imesema kuwa sehemu kubwa ya sheria hiyo ni "batili" kwa sababu inaminya uhuru wa kujieleza na haki ya kupata habari, mambo ambayo yanalindwa na Katiba ya nchi.
Utetezi wa Serikali Wagonga Mwamba
Mwanasheria Mkuu wa Serikali alijaribu kuitetea sheria hiyo akidai kuwa ilikuwa muhimu kwa ajili ya kudhibiti vitendo viovu mtandaoni, ikiwemo lugha ya chuki na usambazaji wa habari za uongo zenye nia mbaya.Hata hivyo, Mahakama ilitupilia mbali utetezi huo. Jaji Irene Mulyagonja, katika hukumu yake, alieleza kuwa sheria hiyo ilivuka mipaka inayokubalika kikatiba. Alibainisha kuwa vifungu vya 23, 26, 27, na 29, pamoja na kifungu cha 162 cha Sheria ya Kanuni za Adhabu, vilikuwa na lugha isiyoeleweka na yenye uwezekano wa kutumiwa vibaya kuwakamata watu bila hatia.
Makosa ya Kiutaratibu Bungeni
Mbali na maudhui ya sheria hiyo, mahakama ilibaini kuwa Bunge lilifanya kosa kubwa la kisheria wakati wa kuipitisha sheria hiyo mnamo Septemba 8, 2022.Ushahidi kutoka kwenye kumbukumbu za Bunge (Hansard) na maelezo ya Karani wa Bunge ulionyesha kuwa:
- Ukosefu wa Akidi (Quorum): Bunge lilipitisha mabadiliko hayo bila kuhakikisha kama kuna idadi ya kutosha ya wabunge ukumbini kama inavyotakiwa.
- Uvunjifu wa Kanuni: Kitendo hicho kilikiuka kanuni ya 24 (3) ya taratibu za Bunge, jambo ambalo ni kinyume na Ibara ya 88 na 89 ya Katiba.
Ushindi kwa Wanaharakati
Kesi hiyo ilifunguliwa na mashirika ya kutetea haki za binadamu na wanahabari, yakiwemo Unwanted Witness, African Centre for Media Excellence (ACME), na Chama cha Wahariri (Editors' Guild). Walidai kuwa sheria hiyo ilikuwa inatumiwa kama silaha ya kunyamazisha wakosoaji wa serikali na kuziba uhuru wa vyombo vya habari==========================
The Constitutional Court has declared several provisions of the Computer Misuse (Amendment) Act, 2022 unconstitutional, ruling that parts of the law violate fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution, including freedom of expression and access to information.
In a unanimous decision by a five-justice panel, the court found that key sections of the law were vague, overly broad, and prone to abuse, effectively criminalising legitimate speech.
Delivering the lead judgment, Justice Irene Mulyagonja ruled that Sections 23, 26, 27 and 29 of the Computer Misuse Act, along with Section 162 of the Penal Code Act, are “null and void” for failing the constitutional test of legality.
The court examined provisions that criminalised sharing information deemed to “ridicule,” “demean,” or “promote hostility,” as well as those targeting anonymous communication and unsolicited content. It held that such offences lacked clear definitions, creating uncertainty and opening the door to arbitrary enforcement.
Petitioners—including Unwanted Witness Uganda, African Centre for Media Excellence, and the Editors' Guild—argued that the provisions violated Articles 29 and 41 of the Constitution, which guarantee freedom of expression and access to information.
The Attorney General defended the law, maintaining that the provisions were necessary to regulate harmful online conduct such as hate speech and malicious information.
However, the court found that the restrictions went beyond acceptable constitutional limits.
"The enactment of the Computer (Amendment) Bill into an Act of Parliament without complying with rule 24 (3) of the Rules of Procedure of Parliament was inconsistent with Articles 88 and 89 of the Constitution," the judges said.
Beyond substance, the court also identified a critical procedural flaw in the enactment of the law. Evidence, including the Hansard of September 8, 2022 and affidavits from the Clerk to Parliament, showed that Parliament passed the amendments without verifying the required quorum.