Question:Do you think it's recommended and legal to punish a trainee?.

[article]

As part of training in mastering provisions of a specific service which require specific skills and capabilities many training institutions subject their students under special field trainings to enable them to acquire practical skills and capabilities and as part of training numerous criminal offences and academic mistakes may be committed with these students during their training sessions.

For instance, a Doctor trainee may commit a murder after injecting a patient with poisonous substance instead of recommended medication after diagnosis or commit any other offences during his/her training sessions.Do you think she/he must be legally punished?

Another Good instance, is recent accident which went viral through a social networks of Teacher Trainees battering a student during their teaching training sessions .Do you think they should be legally punished?.

I have put this puzzle before you after facing a dilemma in reaching a conclusion whether the the recent decision taken to suspend from studies and sue the teacher trainee by a relevant minister and authority for their act of teaming up and unleashing unrecommendable disciplinary actions against the offensive student were correct or wrong taking into consideration training protocols and putting other factors static.
I present this to you,legal contributions will be highly embraced.
Thanks,
Article.

 

[MotoKazi]

View attachment 415028

As part of training in mastering provisions of a specific service which require specific skills and capabilities many training institutions subject their students under special field trainings to enable them to acquire practical skills and capabilities and as part of training numerous criminal offences and academic mistakes may be committed with these students during their training sessions.
View attachment 415029

For instance, a Doctor trainee may commit a murder after injecting a patient with poisonous substance instead of recommended medication after diagnosis or commit any other offences during his/her training sessions.Do you think she/he must be legally punished?
View attachment 415030

Another Good instance, is recent accident which went viral through a social networks of Teacher Trainees battering a student during their teaching training sessions .Do you think they should be legally punished?.

I have put this puzzle before you after facing a dilemma in reaching a conclusion whether the the recent decision taken to suspend from studies and sue the teacher trainee by a relevant minister and authority for their act of teaming up and unleashing unrecommendable disciplinary actions against the offensive student were correct or wrong taking into consideration training protocols and putting other factors static.
I present this to you,legal contributions will be highly embraced.
Thanks,
Article.

Ni watu wa ovyo tu ndo wanaweza kuwashtaki wanafunzi walio mafunzoni, na wanaweza pia kuwa na mizuka iliyopitiliza.....sikuwahi ona motto ashambuliwe na vijana wane na asitoke damu na isemekane amepigwa sana.....

 

[Mo-TOWN]

Mtoa mada...tujuze your understanding of the word trainee na uhusiano kati ya kosa lililofanywa na trainee na punishment unayozungumzia.

 

[Mo-TOWN]

Kwa hiyo yule aliyekuwa trained karate ... akitoa macho watu ni sawa kwa sababu yuko trained au? Mungu tunusuru....kuna threads humu (za walimu I presume) zinanipa shida kweli kuelewa mentality ya hawa wadau.

 

[Mo-TOWN]

[emoji115] Du [emoji15] [emoji15] [emoji15] kazi ipo kutoka damu ni sign umeshambuliwa sana.

 

[mkuuwakaya]

also we need to review this punishment of expelling student (someone) from studies. You expel him/her from studies and remain to be uneducated Tanzanian. What have we done? Expelling student(someone) from studies should be our last resort after all others.

 

[mkariman]

Je vipi kuhusu wanafunzi walovamia kwa Mwl na kumshambulia na kumng'oa meno????!!!!!!! Ilikuwaje vile??

Walimu kazi wanayoooo, wavumilie tu ni upepo unapita

 

[Ahmad Mtunda]

Tatizo ni kwa viongozi wetu kuongozwa na kuongoza kwa hisia.Kwa mfano,suala la yule mwanafunzi lilivyoshughulikiwa na mawaziri watatu kutoka wizara tatu tofauti ni ishara kwamba hawawasiliani.Suala lilikuwa dogo sana kiasi ilikuwa ni kumwachia waziri wa elimu ashughulike nalo.Na yeye kwa busara za kiuongozi ilikuwa ni kuwasiliana na REO kumuuliza kama anataarifa ya tukio like na kama hana afatilie atoe ripoti Mara moja.Ingefanyika hivi hata habari yenyewe isingepewa uzito wa juu kama ilivyokuwa.

 

[Dogo1]

Ni watu wa ovyo tu ndo wanaweza kuwashtaki wanafunzi walio mafunzoni, na wanaweza pia kuwa na mizuka iliyopitiliza.....sikuwahi ona motto ashambuliwe na vijana wane na asitoke damu na isemekane amepigwa sana.....

Stupid comment!

 

[Dogo1]

View attachment 415028

As part of training in mastering provisions of a specific service which require specific skills and capabilities many training institutions subject their students under special field trainings to enable them to acquire practical skills and capabilities and as part of training numerous criminal offences and academic mistakes may be committed with these students during their training sessions.
View attachment 415029

For instance, a Doctor trainee may commit a murder after injecting a patient with poisonous substance instead of recommended medication after diagnosis or commit any other offences during his/her training sessions.Do you think she/he must be legally punished?
View attachment 415030

Another Good instance, is recent accident which went viral through a social networks of Teacher Trainees battering a student during their teaching training sessions .Do you think they should be legally punished?.

I have put this puzzle before you after facing a dilemma in reaching a conclusion whether the the recent decision taken to suspend from studies and sue the teacher trainee by a relevant minister and authority for their act of teaming up and unleashing unrecommendable disciplinary actions against the offensive student were correct or wrong taking into consideration training protocols and putting other factors static.
I present this to you,legal contributions will be highly embraced.
Thanks,
Article.

Good question. I am of the opinion that answers to almost all issues you raised in your article can be found on the law/rules/directives or instructions governing/controlling those under field training - be it the would be teacher or a doctor, if any. If these are not in existence surely there will not be a perfect answer. And if this is the case, then the incident should taken as a starting point to have at least a standard operating operating procedure (SOP) for those in field training