Serikali ikate rufaa dhidi ya uamuzi wa Mahakama Kuu ulioagiza baadhi ya mashahidi utambulisho wao usifichwe, Kesi ya Kisutu isimame kwanza

chiembe

JF-Expert Member
Joined
May 16, 2015
Posts
20,711
Reaction score
31,331
Nashauri serikali ikate rufaa dhidi ya uamuzi wa Mahakama Kuu uliosema kwamba baadhi tu ya mashahidi ambao ni raia, utambulisho wao ufichwe, ila wengine utambulisho wao uwekwe wazi.

Hivi kama wafuasi wa Lissu wanatishia kuua au kudhuru mashahidi, hao mashahidi wasio raia hawawezi kuuliwa au kudhurika? Au thamani ya maisha yao ni ndogo, haifai kulindwa? Nini maana ya usawa mbele ya sheria?

Nashauri kesi ya Lissu Mahakama ya Kisutu isiendelee mpaka Mahakama ya Rufani watakapotoa muongozo.

TrappedInLegalCobweb
 
Kuna kitu hukijui kuhusu Lissu na Chadema, wala hawana haraka na hiyo kesi, Lissu ni Mandela Mpya, Chadema wako Tayari hiyo kesi iende hata miaka 20 ili mradi tu haki ipatikane.

Hatutakubali kamwe mashahidi kufichwa, hilo Masaju anajua na hata Samia anajua
 
Kwanini mashahidi wafichwe?
CCM ni watu wa GIZA...wanataka kumnyonga Lissu kwa kesi ya kubumba...kisa hawataki hizo Reforms za uchaguzi.

Hawa watu ni wabaya mno - hawafai hawana ubinadamu.
 
Lissu ameshalegea, na sisi tuko tayari kesi ikae miaka 30
 
Lissu kasema amechoka kukaa gerezani we pimbi uliejaa uoga hadi kijiko kikianguka breki ya kwanza ni uvunguni unasema Lissu yuko tayari kwenda hata miaka 20 na kesi, mbona we unaogopa kwenda mahabusu hata wiki mbili
 
Huo Mchezo wa kukata rufaa ili mwenzenu akae miaka 4 mahabusu kusubiria tarehe ya rufaa na hukumu , si ndio? Sijui ni lini ndondocha nao wataanza kuonja adha ya kuwekwa mahabusu maana kutesa watu sio jambo zuri. Hilo litakoma tu kama watatenda haki na au nao watawekwa mahababusi...
 
 
Anglo Saxon
Concealed witness testimony can be considered credible and reliable, but it requires careful assessment by the court. While the court must consider the testimony of a concealed witness in the same way as any other witness, the fact that the witness is concealed can be a factor in determining the weight given to their testimony.
"The credibility of a witness can also be determined
in two ways; one when assessing the coherence of
the testimony of that witness; two, when the
testimony of that witness is considered in relation to
the evidence of other witnesses including that of the
accused person .
Figurative decision quote by a Jewish Jurist Maimonides
1. "it is better and more satisfactory to acquit a thousand
(1000) guilty persons than to put a single innocent one to death".
The sacred principle behind those rules is that, protection of the innocent is
more significant for mankind than punishing the guilty.
2. Justice Benjamin Franklin of England wrote:
"It is better one hundred (100) guilty persons should
escape than that one innocent person should suffer".

Kimatumbi
Ushahidi wa shahidi aliyejificha unaweza kuonekana kuwa wa kuaminika na wa kutegemewa, lakini unahitaji tathmini makini na mahakama. Wakati mahakama inapaswa kuzingatia ushahidi wa shahidi aliyejificha kwa njia ile ile kama shahidi mwingine yeyote, ukweli kwamba shahidi amejificha unaweza kuwa kipengele katika kuamua uzito unaotolewa kwa ushahidi wao.

"Uaminifu wa shahidi pia unaweza kuamuliwa kwa njia mbili; moja ni wakati wa kutathmini uwiano wa ushahidi wa shahidi huyo; mbili, wakati ushahidi wa shahidi huyo unazingatiwa katika uhusiano na ushahidi wa mashahidi wengine ikiwa ni pamoja na wa mtu anayedaiwa."

Nukuu ya uamuzi wa mfano kutoka kwa mwanasheria Mwisraeli Maimonides

1. "ni bora na kuridhisha zaidi kuwaachia watu elfu
(1000) wenye hatia kuliko kumwua mmoja tu asiye na hatia".
Kanuni takatifu nyuma ya sheria hizo ni kwamba, ulinzi wa wasio na hatia ni
muhimu zaidi kwa wanadamu kuliko kuadhibu wenye hatia.
2. Jaji Benjamin Franklin wa Uingereza aliandika:

"Ni bora watu mia (100) wenye hatia waondoke kuliko kwamba mtu mmoja asiye na hatia akateseka".
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…