Tanzania: Why Kikwete & CCM are culpable of religious intolerance in the nation?

Tanzania: Why Kikwete & CCM are culpable of religious intolerance in the nation?

Rutashubanyuma

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2010
Posts
219,468
Reaction score
911,184
Last time I went to Unguja; I must admit, I felt safe and secure and at no time I had any lingering thoughts that my life was in danger and that was 2004. And in comparison with my regular trips to Nairobi, I have always felt insecure in Nairobi, and an alien for reasons which still baffle me even today.

With a number of killings and threats posed by gangs of Islamic radicals in Zanzibar, and knowing my government is long on lip-service but short on tangible commitment, I will think twice now to even contemplate setting my foot in zenji because I no longer consider myself welcomed there. And I believe this perception is shared by many a Christian.

May I outline a couple of reasons which leads me to consider Kikwete & his CCM government are liable and complicit to the religious intolerance now conspiring to tear this nation into many a part:-

1.0
WHERE DID KIKWETE GO WRONG ON RELIGIOUS HARMONY?

a) Over-ambition did it all!

The real costs of this nation accommodating JK's quest to presidency is beginning to be felt across the entire national spectrum. In 2005, Kikwete made it a personal crusade that led to his election as our president which though was anybody's constitutional right, the path that he chose roused, facilitated and precipitated religious frictions never experienced before!

Part of his strategy was to remind his fellow Muslims that it was their turn to eat as Christians had eaten through Mkapa's presidency! What Kikwete forgot was that fanning religious insecurity as a tool to acquire power was a double-edged sword: It benefited him then but now Kikwete had unleashed a monster that is threatening even his presidency. On religious conflicts, many Tanzanians prefer to bury their heads on the sand hypocritically claiming to be above the shore but in reality they are part and parcel of the crisis, and it is only when they are personally victimized that they begin to moan about insecurity!

In 2010, faced with a mammoth challenge from Dr. Slaa, a Christian, Kikwete exploited
"udini" to evade confronting gargantuan policy implementation failures on his part. I am still patiently waiting for Kikwete to dilate to the nation what was all about this "udini" beyond scaring voters and balkanizing the nation along religious fissures!


b) Kikwete presidential appointments tilted in favour of his fellow Muslims!

JK considered there were religious injustices inflicted against Muslim by both colonial and post-colonial governments; and ensuing from this, he perceives himself as burdened with redress onus. From this cockeyed attitude, JK has skewed his presidential appointments in favour of his fellow Muslims compromising meritocracy in the process. JK feels that education system and access to government largesse have all been recruited to leave Muslims behind and he has to deploy at least government senior jobs to address the coined imbalances!

In central committee of ccm, number of Christians representation has continue to dwindle rendering it almost impossible for his successor to be a Christian! There are no mechanisms in place in the election of ccm central committee membership to ensure the demographic realities are being captured there. Under-representation of Christians is deliberate to ensure policy directions are geared towards their marginalization despite being the majority in the nation. The Augusta House; to much consolation and relief, captures demographic realities on the ground.

Because JK has shown less sensitivity towards the assault of Christians when on podiums, radical Islam has erroneously intepreted the state is on their side and have been more audacious and vocal to claim what is in many ways unconstitutional rights.

c) Institutionalization of Mahakama za kadhi!

Under Mwinyi; a Muslim, there was no clamouring of Mahakama za kadhi but because of JK's personal intiatives, this is now a national carthasis ready to burst at any moment something a presidential statement to the contrary was sufficient to quell that improper quest for an islamic government.

d) Kikwete refuses to place the religious intolerance blame where it belongs!

I keep wondering if JK really is concerned of arresting simmering religious discontent why does he pass blanket blames even to the victims as if they have incited the treatment they are getting from their traumatizers?

JK ought to criticize his fellow muslims for instigating violence, and that will go a along way to calm the hot tempest now pushing this nation into a cliffhanger.

e) Overlooking the incompetence of the IGP Saidi Mwema!

When a juniour police officer was elevated to IGP post from Interpol in Nairobi, some of us had doubts but politicians hailed the appointment as keen to root our criminality but now time has proved skeptics to be on the right side of history.

Where forensic science is now a leading technological breakthrough in criminal investigations, IGP Mwema still rely on coerced hearsay, tampering of evidence and witnesses to run the police force! It is of little wonder why no progress is ever recorded to arrest and punish those who are hiring assassins to create havoc and insecurity atmosphere around us.

In comparison to Kenya, our police force remains the least professionalized, under-equipped, under-resourced and unfit to do the job they are being paid for. You will be surprised to learn Kenyan politicians; on campaign trail, still talk of furthering their police reforms to the betterment while we keep on cavorting with underachievers!

With the state house connections IGP Mwema has, one had expected him to have done more than less but it is incompetence well captured by his growing obesity demonstrates better. When he was at Interpol he was trimmed and flaunted a lanky figure ready for police work but now he has sired a pot-belly sending a wrong signal for the whole police force he runs. All over the world, police force is known for discipline and physical exercise, but here overweight seems to be one of the mediocre qualifications one needs to have and survive in the police force!

f) Money launderers, drug barons and Islamic radicals have formed an axis of evil.

Though we have painstakingly patched up money laundering laws but enforcement has been the weakest link there. Laundered money is now being used to pay up hired assassins now terrorizing prelates in Zanzibar and nudging Muslims elsewhere to use violent disobedience as a tool to secure a better religious deal for themselves. Now we see even criminal suspects like Sheikh Ponda do enjoy popular support among Muslims despite being linked with terrorist organizations such as Al-Shabab!

In a summary, Kikwete ought to end his vacation of doling out an intemperate greenlight to his fellow muslims and take them to task, and salvage whatever is left of our national unity.

g) Surrounding himself with questionable characters.

Those who are being mentioned adversely in national scams seem to have encapsulated and regimented themselves with State house and CCM as their last standing fortress! Kikwete ought to know better that evil company corrupts even good manners.

We still need to know what had happened to the lists of drug barons and criminal suspects Kikwete had collated with his sidekicks if we are to take him serious enough as a committed leader to end a culture of impunity now threatening to drive a wedge among us!

h) Interior Ministerial appointments have always tapped incompetence!

I am bamboozled to learn why ministers of interior never had sufficient exposure to security matters before they were appointed?????? It appears to be a dumping ground for whomever Kikwete wants to hibernate.......It is high time Kikwete is pinched by a reminder that such frivolous and vexatious appointments are putting him in a poor light for being insensitive to the actual needs of securing our collective security.

The only conspicuous similarity I see conjoining Shamsi Nahodha and Dr. Nchimbi at the hip is mediocrity and that tells us a lot about Kikwete as an appointing authority!

Senior appointments in the police force have applauded tribal calculations, loyalty and compromised professionalism and merits! Work morale in the police force has never been in such a shamble!

In such environment, few expect insecurity will be dealt a permanent blow.......

 
The Tanzanian elections in 2005 and in 2010 were all about "divide and conquer", rather than finding a person who can unify the party and the country it was all about whose group could suppress the opposing groups.

2005:
Our previous presidents are as follows:- Nyerere (Christian, Tanganyikan), Mwinyi (Muslim, Zanzibari), and then Mkapa (Christian, Tanganyikan).

Why did I state the above? If you guys remember in 2005 there was a lot of noise that it was the turn for a person for Zanzibar to be president. Kikwete happens to be Muslim but not Zanzibari. Since the man who was to be his predecessor was a Christian, the mtandao group figured the best way is to kill the "its a Zanzibaris turn" notion with a "its a Muslim's tun" notion but in order to do so they had to get rid of the thread of a viable Zanzibari muslim candidate and we all know the character assassination of Salim Ahmed Salim that took place.

The good thing about 2005 it was that the use of religious division was not public because it took place only in the corridors of the CCM nominating process and this division did not enter the general elections. The reason this division did not occur at the general election level was due in large to the fact that the public at that time were in awe with Kikwete, both Christians and Muslims, even leading to a church leader to label JK "chaguo la Mungu", thus the notion of its "zamu ya waislamu" in the general elections were not needed. However what was the problem? The problem was religious division was now seen as a viable political tool, now come 2010.

2010:

In 2010 for obvious reasons JK had no significant challenge within his party, as per party tradition to allow the incumbent to seek a second term. However this time JK was vulnerable in the general elections after what was perceived by many to be an unsuccessful, unfruitful first term which was bound to happen considering the amount of expectations JK himself allowed to be build up around his presidency. Now what to do? This time the strategy used to gain the CCM nomination would be used to gain him reelection.

Let as look at who posed the greatest threat to JK's ambitions in 2010, it was Dr. W. Slaa. W. Slaa happens to be a former member of the clergy. Thus what was the strategy this time, to paint Chadema as a Christian party and Dr. W. Slaa as a former clergy with a religious agenda. Sadly but true, most of our Muslim brothers and sisters are more sensitive to religious matters than are Christians and they took it to heart that Chadema was a Christian party and that those who opposed JK only did so out of spite for Islam "udini". If memories serve you all well it was CCM and not any other party which was trumpeting "udini".

Now 2012:

Like I said religious divide was not ripe in 2005 because it was not a strategy used in the general elections then but after the elections of 2010 the seeds of divide were now implanted at the national level. JK no longer enjoys the popularity he enjoyed in 2005 and thus Muslims feel that those against JK, if they are Christians, they are only doing it because JK is a Muslim. Now Muslims feel that they are being mistreated upon and that there is a "mfumo Kristo" in the country which is against Muslims even though Muslims hold the presidency, vice presidency, chief justice, IGP, major ministries, and other important positions.

My View:

When Muslims complain that they are being mistreated in their own country I usually ask them, why is it that to Muslims the only religions in Tanzania are Christianity and Islam? What about the other religions which have never had any of their own hold a high office let alone the presidency, what should they complain of? If they truly believe that JK is being mistreated because of his religion and if they believe he won the elections fair and square in 2010 then how did he win without the votes of a majority of Christians? Remember that do to the religious composition of Tanzania no one can win the presidency without a majority from both these two main religions. Jk could not have won 2010 even if he got 1000% of the Muslim vote if Christians did not vote for him. Muslims should also ask themselves, if Chadema was a Christian party then why didn't it get a majority of the Christian vote? Because the only way you can justify JK been elected even with a Christian bias against him is if you also claim he rigged the vote otherwise it is impossible.

My advice to our Muslim brothers and sisters in Tanzania is for them to sit down and think and to not let themselves be used as political tokens. No Christian has a problem with a Muslim holding power or else JK would have never won the presidency to begin with.

My advice to the government is to fix the problem they created. Trust me if there will be religious divisions in this country in 2015 even JK himself will not enjoy his retirement unless if he wants to be the first ever former president in our country's history to relocate abroad.
 
What is the way forward?

I will give my opinion, and this is just my opinion.

In my opinion, the average Muslim Tanzanian feels like the current system favors Christians more than it does Muslims "mfumo Kristo". So I have two sets of advice, one for the average Muslim and the other for the privileged Muslim.

Average Muslim:
Please sit down and sincerely ask yourself the following questions:

  • If the odds were really stacked against Muslims, would a Muslim have ever become president? Would a system which favors Christians over Muslims allow a Muslim to ever ascend to the presidency? Would a Christian ever vote for a Muslim as president? Would such a system have a Christian clergy come out and label a Muslim presidential candidate "chaguo la Mungu"?
  • If Muslims are so mistreated in Tanzania then what of other religions? If your religion has produced presidents, prime ministers, chief justices, speakers of parliament etc, how do you look in the eye a person whose religion hardly has a member of parliament and tell them Muslims are being mistreated?
  • You talk of mfumo Kristo, what of mfumo dume? There has never been a woman president/vice president, prime minister, chief justice and it is just recently that a woman became speaker of parliament, and mind you women are the majority in Tanzania. If Muslims are being mistreated what of women?
  • Do you honestly look around you and not see fellow Tanzanians who are Christians but going through the same problems as you are? Do you not see Christians who are unable to get an education, access to good healthcare, and no employment?

Privileged Muslims:
When I talk of privilege I am merely referring to those of us who are lucky enough enough to have more than the common mwananchi and that means those of us with a good education, with wealth, with good positions etc.
Now to the privileged Muslims, especially those of you who are either educated or a lucky to be leaders in society (either in politics or within the religion), why don't you speak up and tell your brethren that their perceived sense of injustice towards them is simply non existent? If you are Muslim and you had access to education why don't you speak out against those who claim the education system is skewed in favor of Christians? If you are a Muslim and you hold a significant political office why don't you speak out against those who claim that it is Christians who control the political landscape? If you are a Muslim with a significant position in the civil service and you are at the table when different policies are being cooked up why don't you speak out against those who claim the policies of this country favors Christians alone?

Sometimes what's even more important than the message is who delivers it. No matter how good of an argument a Christian gives towards religious equality in this country no Muslim is going to believe but if Muslims themselves come out and say so they have a better chance of properly delivering the message. This should start with the President himself. He should come out and say loud and clear that he is the President of the United Republic of Tanzania and that he would not be in the position he is in right now without votes from both Christians and Muslims. As a person who was raised within the system he should come out and say the opportunities afforded to his Christian peers are the same ones afforded to him and that is why he sits today at the helm of Tanzanian political power. The President should come out and say that as the president he makes a number of political appointments some of which include fellow Muslims hence no policy clearly in favor of one religion over the other can be conjured up. This habit of waiting until disaster strikes to come out and simply pronounce that "the government and its agency will do everything in its power to ensure justice prevails" will not help.

This is my opinion.
 

Sometimes what's even more important than the message is who delivers it. No matter how good of an argument a Christian gives towards religious equality in this country no Muslim is going to believe but if Muslims themselves come out and say so they have a better chance of properly delivering the message. This should start with the President himself. He should come out and say loud and clear that he is the President of the United Republic of Tanzania and that he would not be in the position he is in right now without votes from both Christians and Muslims. As a person who was raised within the system he should come out and say the opportunities afforded to his Christian peers are the same ones afforded to him and that is why he sits today at the helm of Tanzanian political power. The President should come out and say that as the president he makes a number of political appointments some of which include fellow Muslims hence no policy clearly in favor of one religion over the other can be conjured up. This habit of waiting until disaster strikes to come out and simply pronounce that "the government and its agency will do everything in its power to ensure justice prevails" will not help.

This is my opinion.

Nakubaliana na opinion zako na hasa pale unaposema anayefikisha ujumbe awe mtu sahihi.
Vyuo vikuu pia vina nafasi katika hili. Kama centers of knowledge vinapaswa kudevelop courses zinazoendana na mazingira yetu, for this matter religious conflicts resolution/management, inter-religion understanding, plurireligious co-existence etc
 
I belive JK will get a chance to read this . I wonder how comes a president doesn't know what r tha real causes of this prevail serial killing ?
I presume our gvt security system is weak as presidency .
 
My advice to our Muslim brothers and sisters in Tanzania is for them to sit down and think and to not let themselves be used as political tokens. No Christian has a problem with a Muslim holding power or else JK would have never won the presidency to begin with.

My advice to the government is to fix the problem they created. Trust me if there will be religious divisions in this country in 2015 even JK himself will not enjoy his retirement unless if he wants to be the first ever former president in our country's history to relocate abroad.

MwanaFalsafa1 let us not be surprised to hear Kikwete belittling all these in a mischievous dismissal that we are seeking cheap popularity.............
 
What is the way forward?

ZeMarcopolo acknowledging the problem is a political one and not a religious one is the first step in resolving the impasse. Second reforming the police force and enforcing money laundering laws is a second step to disrupt the command and control structures of the criminal gangs. They need money to hire goons who are doing their killings and fomenting chaos, for their own sake!
 
I belive JK will get a chance to read this . I wonder how comes a president doesn't know what r tha real causes of this prevail serial killing ?
I presume our gvt security system is weak as presidency .

Mwakalinga Y. R we have individuals masquerading as leaders but they have no idea what leadership entails......
 
Nakubaliana na opinion zako na hasa pale unaposema anayefikisha ujumbe awe mtu sahihi.
Vyuo vikuu pia vina nafasi katika hili. Kama centers of knowledge vinapaswa kudevelop courses zinazoendana na mazingira yetu, for this matter religious conflicts resolution/management, inter-religion understanding, plurireligious co-existence etc

ZeMarcopolo wnaoongoza hivyo vyuo wana sifa?
 
I will give my opinion, and this is just my opinion.

In my opinion, the average Muslim Tanzanian feels like the current system favors Christians more than it does Muslims "mfumo Kristo". So I have two sets of advice, one for the average Muslim and the other for the privileged Muslim.

Average Muslim:
Please sit down and sincerely ask yourself the following questions:


  • If the odds were really stacked against Muslims, would a Muslim have ever become president? Would a system which favors Christians over Muslims allow a Muslim to ever ascend to the presidency? Would a Christian ever vote for a Muslim as president? Would such a system have a Christian clergy come out and label a Muslim presidential candidate "chaguo la Mungu"?
  • If Muslims are so mistreated in Tanzania then what of other religions? If your religion has produced presidents, prime ministers, chief justices, speakers of parliament etc, how do you look in the eye a person whose religion hardly has a member of parliament and tell them Muslims are being mistreated?
  • You talk of mfumo Kristo, what of mfumo dume? There has never been a woman president/vice president, prime minister, chief justice and it is just recently that a woman became speaker of parliament, and mind you women are the majority in Tanzania. If Muslims are being mistreated what of women?
  • Do you honestly look around you and not see fellow Tanzanians who are Christians but going through the same problems as you are? Do you not see Christians who are unable to get an education, access to good healthcare, and no employment?


Privileged Muslims:
When I talk of privilege I am merely referring to those of us who are lucky enough enough to have more than the common mwananchi and that means those of us with a good education, with wealth, with good positions etc.
Now to the privileged Muslims, especially those of you who are either educated or a lucky to be leaders in society (either in politics or within the religion), why don't you speak up and tell your brethren that their perceived sense of injustice towards them is simply non existent? If you are Muslim and you had access to education why don't you speak out against those who claim the education system is skewed in favor of Christians? If you are a Muslim and you hold a significant political office why don't you speak out against those who claim that it is Christians who control the political landscape? If you are a Muslim with a significant position in the civil service and you are at the table when different policies are being cooked up why don't you speak out against those who claim the policies of this country favors Christians alone?

Sometimes what's even more important than the message is who delivers it. No matter how good of an argument a Christian gives towards religious equality in this country no Muslim is going to believe but if Muslims themselves come out and say so they have a better chance of properly delivering the message. This should start with the President himself. He should come out and say loud and clear that he is the President of the United Republic of Tanzania and that he would not be in the position he is in right now without votes from both Christians and Muslims. As a person who was raised within the system he should come out and say the opportunities afforded to his Christian peers are the same ones afforded to him and that is why he sits today at the helm of Tanzanian political power. The President should come out and say that as the president he makes a number of political appointments some of which include fellow Muslims hence no policy clearly in favor of one religion over the other can be conjured up. This habit of waiting until disaster strikes to come out and simply pronounce that "the government and its agency will do everything in its power to ensure justice prevails" will not help.

This is my opinion.

MwanaFalsafa1 they also need to be reminded to ask themselves serious questions why in Islamic countries where Christians are in minority yet Muslims are killing Muslims? Look in Libya, Algeria, Egypt, Iran, Syria, Iraq, Mali etc just to name a few?

The problem of islam is not to trust God to revenge for them and this is why they have "fatwa" to bring retributive justice to them!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
It is so sad that the country is in prevailing situation!
The spark that lit all these fires was the 2010 elections.
How was it possible that the President was just calm despite all the rough campaigns conducted by the muslims against Dr.Slaa?
Kikwete thought that would play to his favour,but unfortunate enough the kindling fire is about to burn his presidency!
 
It is so sad that the country is in prevailing situation!
The spark that lit all these fires was the 2010 elections.
How was it possible that the President was just calm despite all the rough campaigns conducted by the muslims against Dr.Slaa?
Kikwete thought that would play to his favour,but unfortunate enough the kindling fire is about to burn his presidency!

Mpenda Yesu can't agree more.........
 
1) It is totally unfair and premature to rule and judge that the recent death of a priest in Zanzibar is connected to faith.

2) Muslims have raised their concern for years if this can be linked with religion any how. Read:

https://www.jamiiforums.com/jukwaa-...e-rise-of-muslim-militancy-in-tanzania-3.html

Calling the devil by any other name won't change the facts about his evil deeds sir. The sooner the government and people accept that their is a conflict of faith brewing in Tanzania the sooner and more easily we can fix things. Zanzibar is known to burn churches and pass out flyers encouraging its people to give Christians are hard time (wakala hizi zinazo sambazwa sambazwa) so what do you expect people to think when a priest is killed? When you pour gasoline any spark can set things on fire.
 
Calling the devil by any other name won't change the facts about his evil deeds sir. The sooner the government and people accept that their is a conflict of faith brewing in Tanzania the sooner and more easily we can fix things. Zanzibar is known to burn churches and pass out flyers encouraging its people to give Christians are hard time (wakala hizi zinazo sambazwa sambazwa) so what do you expect people to think when a priest is killed? When you pour gasoline any spark can set things on fire.

You should read this:

Christian Hegemony and the Rise of Muslim Militancy in Tanzania
 
Back
Top Bottom