Waufukweni
JF-Expert Member
- May 16, 2024
- 5,383
- 18,776
Mahakama Kuu ya Gauteng imeamua kuwa kampuni ya uwekezaji ya Patrice Motsepe, African Rainbow Capital (ARC), haiwezi kuwajibishwa katika kesi ya dola milioni 195 (Tsh. Bilioni 505.7) iliyofunguliwa na kampuni ya Marekani, Pula Group.
Mahakama hiyo pia ilibainisha kuwa ARC haiwezi kubeba lawama katika kesi hiyo inayohusiana na madai ya kuvunjwa kwa makubaliano ya usiri (confidentiality agreement) yaliyohusishwa na mradi wa grafiti nchini Tanzania.
Katika uamuzi uliotolewa Aprili 15, Jaji Leicester Adams aligundua kuwa Pula Group na kampuni yake tanzu, Pula Graphite Partners, walishindwa kuthibitisha madai halali ya uvunjaji wa mkataba dhidi ya ARC.
Mahakama ilieleza kuwa makubaliano ya kutofichua taarifa (NDA) yaliyokuwa kiini cha mgogoro huo yalitiwa saini mwaka 2019 kati ya African Rainbow Minerals (ARM) na Pula Group, si ARC. Kwa hiyo, ARC haikuwa sehemu ya makubaliano hayo na haiwezi kuwajibishwa chini yake. Jaji alibainisha kuwa hatua zozote za kisheria zinazohusiana na mkataba huo zingepaswa kuelekezwa kwa ARM, si ARC.
Soma pia;
The Gauteng High Court has ruled that Patrice Motsepe’s investment firm, African Rainbow Capital (ARC), cannot be held liable in a $195 million (R3.2 billion) lawsuit brought by U.S.-based Pula Group.
The Gauteng High Court has ruled that Patrice Motsepe’s investment firm, African Rainbow Capital (ARC), cannot be held liable in a $195 million (R3.2 billion) lawsuit brought by U.S.-based Pula Group over an alleged breach of a confidentiality agreement linked to a Tanzanian graphite project.
In a judgment delivered on April 15, Judge Leicester Adams found that Pula Group and its subsidiary, Pula Graphite Partners, failed to establish a valid breach of contract claim against ARC.
The court held that the non-disclosure agreement (NDA) at the centre of the dispute was signed in 2019 between African Rainbow Minerals (ARM) and Pula Group, not ARC. As a result, ARC was not a party to the agreement and could not be held liable under it. Any potential contractual remedies, the judge noted, would lie against ARM, not ARC.
Legal win, but case continues
The ruling marks a significant legal win for Motsepe’s investment vehicle, although it does not end the broader dispute. Proceedings in Tanzania continue, with ARC as the only Motsepe-linked entity to actively defend the case.
Motsepe, ARM, and ARCH Sustainable Resources lost standing in Tanzania after failing to appear at a scheduled hearing in December 2023, with a default judgment application against them still pending.
The dispute traces back to 2019, when ARM entered into a confidentiality agreement with Pula over a proposed graphite mining investment in Tanzania’s Chilalo region. The deal never materialised.
However, in 2022, Pula alleged that confidential information shared during negotiations had been used to support a competing project after ARCH invested in Evolution Energy Minerals, which operates nearby. Pula claims this undermined its commercial position and damaged the value of its exploration rights.
In 2023, Pula filed a damages claim in Tanzania against Motsepe, ARC, ARM, and ARCH. Motsepe has dismissed the allegations as “baseless,” while ARC has consistently argued it had no contractual obligations under the NDA.
Jurisdictional tensions have also marked the case. Pula accused the Motsepe-linked parties of “forum shopping” after ARC approached South African courts following setbacks in Tanzania. ARC countered that South African courts had proper jurisdiction, as the NDA was signed and governed under South African law, a position upheld by the court.
While ARC has been cleared in South Africa, the outcome of the wider $195 million claim against other parties remains uncertain.
Katika uamuzi uliotolewa Aprili 15, Jaji Leicester Adams aligundua kuwa Pula Group na kampuni yake tanzu, Pula Graphite Partners, walishindwa kuthibitisha madai halali ya uvunjaji wa mkataba dhidi ya ARC.
Mahakama ilieleza kuwa makubaliano ya kutofichua taarifa (NDA) yaliyokuwa kiini cha mgogoro huo yalitiwa saini mwaka 2019 kati ya African Rainbow Minerals (ARM) na Pula Group, si ARC. Kwa hiyo, ARC haikuwa sehemu ya makubaliano hayo na haiwezi kuwajibishwa chini yake. Jaji alibainisha kuwa hatua zozote za kisheria zinazohusiana na mkataba huo zingepaswa kuelekezwa kwa ARM, si ARC.
Soma pia;
- Rais wa CAF, Patrice Motsepe ashtakiwa Dar es Salaam, Kesi ya Tsh. bilioni 525.8 kuunguruma leo Novemba 4, 2024
- Baada ya kesi kuwa ngumu, kampuni za Patrice Motsepe zimeanza kuomba "kinga" kutoka Afrika Kusini dhidi ya mahakama za Tanzania
- Bilionea Patrice Motsepe kikaangoni katika kesi nzito ya madini ya shilingi bilioni 490 nchini Tanzania
The Gauteng High Court has ruled that Patrice Motsepe’s investment firm, African Rainbow Capital (ARC), cannot be held liable in a $195 million (R3.2 billion) lawsuit brought by U.S.-based Pula Group.
The Gauteng High Court has ruled that Patrice Motsepe’s investment firm, African Rainbow Capital (ARC), cannot be held liable in a $195 million (R3.2 billion) lawsuit brought by U.S.-based Pula Group over an alleged breach of a confidentiality agreement linked to a Tanzanian graphite project.
In a judgment delivered on April 15, Judge Leicester Adams found that Pula Group and its subsidiary, Pula Graphite Partners, failed to establish a valid breach of contract claim against ARC.
The court held that the non-disclosure agreement (NDA) at the centre of the dispute was signed in 2019 between African Rainbow Minerals (ARM) and Pula Group, not ARC. As a result, ARC was not a party to the agreement and could not be held liable under it. Any potential contractual remedies, the judge noted, would lie against ARM, not ARC.
Legal win, but case continues
The ruling marks a significant legal win for Motsepe’s investment vehicle, although it does not end the broader dispute. Proceedings in Tanzania continue, with ARC as the only Motsepe-linked entity to actively defend the case.
Motsepe, ARM, and ARCH Sustainable Resources lost standing in Tanzania after failing to appear at a scheduled hearing in December 2023, with a default judgment application against them still pending.
The dispute traces back to 2019, when ARM entered into a confidentiality agreement with Pula over a proposed graphite mining investment in Tanzania’s Chilalo region. The deal never materialised.
However, in 2022, Pula alleged that confidential information shared during negotiations had been used to support a competing project after ARCH invested in Evolution Energy Minerals, which operates nearby. Pula claims this undermined its commercial position and damaged the value of its exploration rights.
In 2023, Pula filed a damages claim in Tanzania against Motsepe, ARC, ARM, and ARCH. Motsepe has dismissed the allegations as “baseless,” while ARC has consistently argued it had no contractual obligations under the NDA.
Jurisdictional tensions have also marked the case. Pula accused the Motsepe-linked parties of “forum shopping” after ARC approached South African courts following setbacks in Tanzania. ARC countered that South African courts had proper jurisdiction, as the NDA was signed and governed under South African law, a position upheld by the court.
While ARC has been cleared in South Africa, the outcome of the wider $195 million claim against other parties remains uncertain.