Haki ya kikatiba vs vikosi vya ulinzi: kauli ya sheikh mwaipopo na ukimya wa polisi unatafsiri gani?

Haki ya kikatiba vs vikosi vya ulinzi: kauli ya sheikh mwaipopo na ukimya wa polisi unatafsiri gani?

... maandamano ya magaidi OCT29/2025 yameleta umaskini na vifo miongoni wa watu wasio na hatia, HIVYO WATU WANAPOAMUA KUTOA ULINZI SHIRIKISHI WAACHWE!

NB: Ulinzi wa nchi yetu ni jukumu la kila mzalendo!
.............................................................. NYERERE.
Mkuu Kishimbe wa Kishimbe, nakusalimia kwa heshima na taadhima.
Nimesoma kwa umakini sana mtazamo wako, na kwa dhati kabisa, nimejikuta nikikuonea huruma kidogo, japo nafahamu unajiona upo sahihi kabisa kulingana na uelewa wako wa mambo.
Katika historia ya mifumo ya kiimla na ya kikandamizaji kote duniani, huwa kuna jambo moja la kusikitisha sana linatokea. Mara nyingi kukiwa na upofu wa kutochunguza mambo kwa kina, watu ambao ndio waathirika wakuu wa mifumo hiyo—wale wanaoumizwa na umaskini na ugumu wa maisha—wanajikuta wakigeuka kuwa wasifiaji na watetezi wakuu wa wakandamizaji wao wenyewe. Ni jambo la kisaikolojia linalojulikana sana.
Kuhusu kumnukuu Baba wa Taifa, Mwalimu Julius Nyerere, kuna usemi mmoja maarufu unaotukumbusha jambo muhimu sana: "Huwezi kumuelimisha wala kumuelewesha mtu mpumbavu, kwa sababu upumbavu ni kipaji."
(Naomba nikuondolee hofu mkuu wangu, kwa kauli hii simaanishi hata kidogo kwamba wewe ni mpumbavu, la hasha. Bali naitumia tu kueleza uhalisia wa jinsi ilivyo vigumu kumfungua macho mtu ambaye ameamua kufunga fikra zake dhidi ya ukweli).
Mwalimu Nyerere alipozungumzia "Ulinzi Shirikishi" na uzalendo, hakuwa na maana ya kuruhusu vikundi haramu visivyo rasmi vitishie raia "kuwakata vichwa" au "kuwatahiri bila ganzi" hadharani. Ulinzi shirikishi unapaswa kufuata misingi ya sheria na Katiba ya nchi, na siyo kuhalalisha vurugu na sheria ya msituni kwa mgongo wa uzalendo.
Masikitiko yangu kwako yanatokana na upendo wa kitanzania sababu ninajua japo unaandika huku ukielewa ama bila kuelewa kwa kupewa vibahasha ili uwe chawa lakini unabaki kama Mtanzania mwenzangu ninayetakiwa kukupenda. Kila la heri mkuu wangu.
 
Mkuu Kishimbe wa Kishimbe, nakusalimia kwa heshima na taadhima.
Nimesoma kwa umakini sana mtazamo wako, na kwa dhati kabisa, nimejikuta nikikuonea huruma kidogo, japo nafahamu unajiona upo sahihi kabisa kulingana na uelewa wako wa mambo.
Katika historia ya mifumo ya kiimla na ya kikandamizaji kote duniani, huwa kuna jambo moja la kusikitisha sana linatokea. Mara nyingi kukiwa na upofu wa kutochunguza mambo kwa kina, watu ambao ndio waathirika wakuu wa mifumo hiyo—wale wanaoumizwa na umaskini na ugumu wa maisha—wanajikuta wakigeuka kuwa wasifiaji na watetezi wakuu wa wakandamizaji wao wenyewe. Ni jambo la kisaikolojia linalojulikana sana.
Kuhusu kumnukuu Baba wa Taifa, Mwalimu Julius Nyerere, kuna usemi mmoja maarufu unaotukumbusha jambo muhimu sana: "Huwezi kumuelimisha wala kumuelewesha mtu mpumbavu, kwa sababu upumbavu ni kipaji."
(Naomba nikuondolee hofu mkuu wangu, kwa kauli hii simaanishi hata kidogo kwamba wewe ni mpumbavu, la hasha. Bali naitumia tu kueleza uhalisia wa jinsi ilivyo vigumu kumfungua macho mtu ambaye ameamua kufunga fikra zake dhidi ya ukweli).
Mwalimu Nyerere alipozungumzia "Ulinzi Shirikishi" na uzalendo, hakuwa na maana ya kuruhusu vikundi haramu visivyo rasmi vitishie raia "kuwakata vichwa" au "kuwatahiri bila ganzi" hadharani. Ulinzi shirikishi unapaswa kufuata misingi ya sheria na Katiba ya nchi, na siyo kuhalalisha vurugu na sheria ya msituni kwa mgongo wa uzalendo.
Masikitiko yangu kwako yanatokana na upendo wa kitanzania sababu ninajua japo unaandika huku ukielewa ama bila kuelewa kwa kupewa vibahasha ili uwe chawa lakini unabaki kama Mtanzania mwenzangu ninayetakiwa kukupenda. Kila la heri mkuu wangu.
... najua tutaelewana mbele ya safari!
TUPITE HAPA KWANZA!

😅
 
Seriously ina maana haujui ya kuwa ametumwa? Analindwa na hakuna polisi mwenye jeuri ya kumwambia lolote vinginevyo na hao polisi watajikuta wanatairiwa bila ganzi.
Abdul ana nguvu kuliko majeshi yetu yote combined.
Mkuu wangu MONSTER, umeongea jambo zito ambalo kiuhalisia ndilo linaloakisi ukweli wa mambo nyuma ya pazia, na ninaelewa sana mtazamo wako.
Umezungumzia suala la "Abdul" kuwa na nguvu kuliko majeshi yote combined, na kwamba hawa viongozi wa dini wanatumwa na kulindwa na mfumo mkuu kiasi kwamba hakuna polisi mwenye jeuri ya kuwakamata. Kiukweli, katika mifumo ya kisiasa ambapo mamlaka yanajilundika sehemu moja, vyombo vya dola (ikiwemo polisi wetu) mara nyingi hujikuta vikiwa havina meno mbele ya watu waliopo karibu na chimbuko la nguvu hizo za kisiasa. Wakijaribu kufanya kazi yao kisheria, wanaweza kujikuta wao ndio wanaoadhibiwa au kuhamishwa vituo vya kazi.
Hata hivyo, mimi kama Kijana wa Ifoza, uamuzi wangu wa kuweka maoni haya na kusisitiza misingi ya kisheria na kikatiba hapa JamiiForums unatokana na sababu kuu mbili:
  • Kukataa Kuhalalisha Uovu: Hata kama tunajua kuna nguvu kubwa ya kimfumo inawalinda nyuma yao, hatuwezi kukaa kimya na kuacha jambo hili lipite kama jambo la kawaida. Tukikubali ukimya, tunahalalisha ukiukwaji wa Katiba na tunaruhusu jamii iamini kuwa hii ndiyo "new normal" (hali ya kawaida). Lazima mimi kama kijana niliyeamka niendelee kuandika ili iwekwe kwenye kumbukumbu za taifa kuwa wananchi walijua na walipinga.
  • Kuwasaidia Polisi Wetu Mfumo Unapowafunga Mikono: Unaposema polisi hawana jeuri ya kuwakamata kwa sababu ya kulinda ugali wao, uko sahihi kiuhalisia. Lakini sisi wananchi tunapopiga kelele kisheria, tunatengeneza shinikizo la kijamii (public pressure). Shinikizo hili wakati mwingine huwapa nguvu even kwa wale maafisa wa polisi wazalendo ndani ya mfumo kupata sababu ya kuchukua hatua pale amri kutoka juu zinapokiuka usalama wa nchi waziwazi.
Mkuu, nathamini sana mchango wako, na nakubaliana na wewe kuwa katika mazingira kama haya, kuweka maoni na kuamsha fikra za Watanzania ndicho chombo kikubwa zaidi tulichonacho kwa sasa. Hata kama hatuna ushahidi wa nyaraka za kimaandishi mkononi, matokeo ya kile kinachoendelea hadharani yanatosha kabisa kuwa ushahidi wa kimazingira (circumstantial evidence) kwa kila mwenye macho kuona na mwenye masikio kusikia.

Mwisho wa siku, historia inatufundisha kuwa hakuna nguvu ya kimfumo inayoweza kushinda nguvu ya umma uliogundua mnyororo unaowafunga. Kama Kijana wa Ifoza, najua fika kuwa mbwa mwitu wanaweza kulindwa na mchungaji kwa muda fulani ili watishe kondoo, lakini dhoruba ikija, mchungaji hukimbia na kuwaacha mbwa mwitu wakikabiliana na hasira ya msitu wenyewe. Tutaendelea kuandika na kuweka alama za nyakati hapa JamiiForums, kwa sababu hata gizani, macho yetu bado yanaona mistari ya kesho.
Asante kwa kuendeleza huu mjadala kwa weledi mkubwa, mkuu wangu!
 
"Giza" vs "Mwanga"

Mwisho kuna mshindi na atajulikana muda si mrefu.
Mkuu Dr PL,

umezungumzia jambo zito sana lenye uzito mkubwa wa kifalsafa na kiroho.


Huu mnyororo wa pambano kati ya "Giza" na "Mwanga" ndio msingi mkuu wa historia ya mwanadamu na ustawi wa jamii yoyote ile. Katika muktadha wa taifa letu kwa sasa:
  • Giza linawakilishwa na wale wote wanaotumia mifumo ya kikatili, vitisho vya kukata watu vichwa au kuwatahiri bila ganzi, na udumilakuwili wa sheria ili kuwatisha wananchi na kuzima haki zao za kikatiba.
  • Mwanga unawakilishwa na ukweli, uzalendo wa dhati, na sauti za wananchi wanaoamka na kuhoji mifumo inayowakandamiza.
Ni kweli kabisa kama ulivyosema, mwisho wa siku lazima mshindi atajulikana na muda huo si mrefu. Giza linaweza kuwa nene na linaweza kuwa na nguvu zote za kimfumo nyuma yake, lakini lina mapungufu makubwa mawili: halina ukweli na halina uwezo wa kudumu. Mwanga hauhitaji jeshi zima ili kushinda; unahitaji tu cheche ndogo ya ukweli ili kuondoa giza lote lililopo chumbani.
Kama Kijana wa Ifoza, ninaungana na wewe Dr PL kuwa na imani na matumaini haya makubwa. Sauti tunazopaza na mijadala tunayoamsha hapa JamiiForums ndizo cheche za mwanga zinazomulika na kufichua yale yote yanayopangwa gizani. Mapambano haya yanahitaji stamina, imani, na ujasiri wa kutoyasujudia madaraka yanayopita.
Hakika, Mwanga utashinda! Shukrani sana kwa mchango wako mkuu.
 
Mkuu wangu MONSTER, umeongea jambo zito ambalo kiuhalisia ndilo linaloakisi ukweli wa mambo nyuma ya pazia, na ninaelewa sana mtazamo wako.
Umezungumzia suala la "Abdul" kuwa na nguvu kuliko majeshi yote combined, na kwamba hawa viongozi wa dini wanatumwa na kulindwa na mfumo mkuu kiasi kwamba hakuna polisi mwenye jeuri ya kuwakamata. Kiukweli, katika mifumo ya kisiasa ambapo mamlaka yanajilundika sehemu moja, vyombo vya dola (ikiwemo polisi wetu) mara nyingi hujikuta vikiwa havina meno mbele ya watu waliopo karibu na chimbuko la nguvu hizo za kisiasa. Wakijaribu kufanya kazi yao kisheria, wanaweza kujikuta wao ndio wanaoadhibiwa au kuhamishwa vituo vya kazi.
Hata hivyo, mimi kama Kijana wa Ifoza, uamuzi wangu wa kuweka maoni haya na kusisitiza misingi ya kisheria na kikatiba hapa JamiiForums unatokana na sababu kuu mbili:
  • Kukataa Kuhalalisha Uovu: Hata kama tunajua kuna nguvu kubwa ya kimfumo inawalinda nyuma yao, hatuwezi kukaa kimya na kuacha jambo hili lipite kama jambo la kawaida. Tukikubali ukimya, tunahalalisha ukiukwaji wa Katiba na tunaruhusu jamii iamini kuwa hii ndiyo "new normal" (hali ya kawaida). Lazima mimi kama kijana niliyeamka niendelee kuandika ili iwekwe kwenye kumbukumbu za taifa kuwa wananchi walijua na walipinga.
  • Kuwasaidia Polisi Wetu Mfumo Unapowafunga Mikono: Unaposema polisi hawana jeuri ya kuwakamata kwa sababu ya kulinda ugali wao, uko sahihi kiuhalisia. Lakini sisi wananchi tunapopiga kelele kisheria, tunatengeneza shinikizo la kijamii (public pressure). Shinikizo hili wakati mwingine huwapa nguvu even kwa wale maafisa wa polisi wazalendo ndani ya mfumo kupata sababu ya kuchukua hatua pale amri kutoka juu zinapokiuka usalama wa nchi waziwazi.
Mkuu, nathamini sana mchango wako, na nakubaliana na wewe kuwa katika mazingira kama haya, kuweka maoni na kuamsha fikra za Watanzania ndicho chombo kikubwa zaidi tulichonacho kwa sasa. Hata kama hatuna ushahidi wa nyaraka za kimaandishi mkononi, matokeo ya kile kinachoendelea hadharani yanatosha kabisa kuwa ushahidi wa kimazingira (circumstantial evidence) kwa kila mwenye macho kuona na mwenye masikio kusikia.

Mwisho wa siku, historia inatufundisha kuwa hakuna nguvu ya kimfumo inayoweza kushinda nguvu ya umma uliogundua mnyororo unaowafunga. Kama Kijana wa Ifoza, najua fika kuwa mbwa mwitu wanaweza kulindwa na mchungaji kwa muda fulani ili watishe kondoo, lakini dhoruba ikija, mchungaji hukimbia na kuwaacha mbwa mwitu wakikabiliana na hasira ya msitu wenyewe. Tutaendelea kuandika na kuweka alama za nyakati hapa JamiiForums, kwa sababu hata gizani, macho yetu bado yanaona mistari ya kesho.
Asante kwa kuendeleza huu mjadala kwa weledi mkubwa, mkuu wangu!
💯✔️
💪🏾💪🏾
 
Wakuu,
Nadhani wengi wenu mmeona au kusikia taarifa za mkutano na waandishi wa habari uliofanywa na Sheikh Said Mwaipopo mnamo Juni 20, 2026, kuelekea maandamano yaliyopangwa ya tarehe 7 Julai (Saba Saba). Katika kauli yake, ametishia kuwepo kwa "kikosi kazi maalum" kitakachowashughulikia waandamanaji kwa madai ya kulinda miundombinu. Alikwenda mbali zaidi na kutoa lugha ya vitisho vya kikatili akisema, "Tutakayemkamata tutamtahiri bila ganzi...".


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ol5xflQ1lJg

Hili jambo linazua maswali mazito sana ya kisheria na kikatiba ambayo kama wadau wa jukwaa hili tunapaswa kuyajadili kwa mapana:

1. Maandamano ya Amani ni Haki ya Kikatiba, si Hisani
Kwanza kabisa, ikumbukwe kuwa Katiba ya Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania inatambua maandamano ya amani kama haki ya msingi ya kiraia. Kisheria, wananchi wanaopanga kuandamana wanatakiwa kujaarifu tu Jeshi la Polisi na sio kuomba kibali. Polisi wana wajibu mkuu kisheria wa kuwepo eneo la tukio ili kuwalinda waandamanaji na mali zao, na sio kuzuia haki hiyo au kuruhusu makundi mengine kuingilia kati.
Hapa naomba kunukuu kifungu cha Katiba kinacholinda haki hii:



Uamuzi wa Mahakama Kuu na Sheria ya "Taarifa" (Notification):

Msisitizo wa kisheria hapa unakuja kufuatia Uamuzi wa Kihistoria wa Mahakama Kuu ya Tanzania wa Mwaka 1994 katika Kesi ya Rev. Christopher Mtikila v. The Attorney General (Civil Case No. 5 of 1993). Katika uamuzi huo, Mahakama Kuu ilitengua rasmi matakwa ya zamani ya kisheria yaliyokuwa yanawataka raia kuomba "kibali" cha polisi ili kukusanyika au kuandamana. Mahakama ilitamka wazi kuwa sheria inayolazimisha raia kuomba kibali cha polisi inakiuka Katiba na inaminya kwa namna isiyo halali uhuru wa kimsingi wa kukusanyika.

Kufuatia uamuzi huo wa mwaka 1994, chini ya Kifungu cha 43 cha Sheria ya Jeshi la Polisi na Huduma Sadizi (Sura ya 322), utaratibu pekee halali uliosalia ni waandaaji kutoa taarifa ya maandishi kwa mkuu wa polisi wa eneo husika saa 48 kabla ya mkusanyiko. Polisi hawana mamlaka ya kutoa au kuzuia "kibali," bali wajibu wao wa kisheria ni kutoa ulinzi ili kuhakikisha amani inadumishwa na haki ya kikatiba inalindwa dhidi ya vikundi binafsi.

2. Je, Kikosi Kazi cha Mwaipopo Kiko Kisheria?
Katiba ya nchi inasema chombo chenye mamlaka ya kukamata na kuzuia uhalifu ni Jeshi la Polisi pekee. Tamko la raia binafsi au kiongozi wa dini kudai ana kikosi chake cha "kushughulikia" raia wenzake barabarani ni ukiukaji wa wazi wa sheria na ni jaribio la kujichukulia sheria mkononi. Hii inaweza kuzaa machafuko iwapo upande wa pili nao utaamua kuunda vikosi vya kujihami.
Kuhusu suala la mtu yeyote kutishiwa ukatili au kudhalilishwa utu wake na raia mwingine, Katiba inakataza vikali:



3. Fumbo la Ukimya wa Jeshi la Polisi

Hadi sasa, Jeshi la Polisi limekaa kimya utadhani halijasikia kauli hizi za hatari. Ukimya huu unazua maswali mengi ya kiundumilakuwili (double standards):
Mbona upande wa upinzani ukitoa matamko ya kisiasa unashughulikiwa kwa kasi ya ajabu? Mwenyekiti wa CHADEMA, Tundu Lissu, alikamatwa na hadi sasa anakabiliwa na mashtaka mazito ya uhaini na uchochezi, ambapo kesi yake bado inaendelea kuunguruma mahakamani huku akiwa kuzuizini. Inakuwaje mtu anayetoa kauli za kisiasa na kukosoa mfumo anashtakiwa kwa uchochezi na uhaini, lakini kiongozi anayesimama hadharani na kutishia kufanya ukatili wa kimwili ("kutahiri watu bila ganzi") na kuunda vikosi haramu vya ulinzi anaachiwa akidunda mitaani bila hata kuitwa polisi kuhojiwa?
Je, ukimya huu hautafsiriwi kama baraka au kibali cha Polisi kwa makundi haya yanayoiunga mkono dola kufanya fujo na kukiuka sheria?

Mjadala:

Wakuu, hivi nchi yetu inaongozwa na misingi ya Sheria na Katiba au inaongozwa kwa matakwa ya kiitikadi? Je, ukimya huu wa polisi kwa Sheikh Mwaipopo huku upande wa pili kama akina Tundu Lissu wakisota mahakamani unajenga au unabomoa taswira ya vyombo vyetu vya usalama?
Karibuni kwa hoja.



🇬🇧 INTERNATIONAL AUDIENCE VERSION
TITLE: CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS VS PRIVATE MILITIAS: WHAT DOES THE SILENCE OF THE POLICE FORCE REGARDING SHEIKH MWAIPOPO’S THREATS MEAN?
Dear members,

I believe most of you have seen the footage or heard about the press conference held by Sheikh Said Mwaipopo on June 20, 2026, regarding the planned demonstrations on July 7th (Saba Saba). In his statement, he threatened the existence of a "special task force" that would deal with the demonstrators under the guise of protecting infrastructure. He went further to use harsh, cruel words of threat, stating, "Whoever we catch, we will circumcise them without anesthesia...".

This incident raises heavy constitutional and legal questions that we, as stakeholders of this platform, need to discuss extensively:

1. Peaceful Demonstration is a Constitutional Right, Not a Privilege

First and foremost, it must be recalled that the Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania recognises peaceful demonstration as a fundamental civil right. Legally, citizens planning to demonstrate are only required to notify the Police Force and not to beg for permission. The police have one primary legal obligation: to be present at the scene to protect the demonstrators and their property, rather than stopping the exercise of this right or allowing other groups to interfere.

Here, let me quote the specific constitutional provision protecting this right:


The High Court Precedent and the "Notification" Requirement:

This legal standpoint is heavily backed by a landmark 1994 Tanzanian High Court Ruling in the case of Rev. Christopher Mtikila v. The Attorney General (Civil Case No. 5 of 1993). In this watershed judgement, the High Court decisively struck down old statutory provisions requiring citizens to acquire a police "permit" before holding a public assembly or demonstration. The Court boldly declared that forcing citizens to seek permission fundamentally infringes upon the constitutional freedom of assembly.

Consequently, following that 1994 precedent and under Section 43 of the Police Force and Auxiliary Services Act (Cap 322), the operational protocol is restricted strictly to a 48-hour prior written notification to the officer in charge. The police have absolutely no legal powers to issue or deny a "permit"; their statutory mandate is solely to regulate traffic, maintain public order, and shield peaceful demonstrators from external interference or private actors trying to hijack the law.

2. Is Mwaipopo's Task Force Legally authorised

The country's Constitution explicitly states that the only institution with the mandate to arrest, investigate, and prevent crime is the Police Force. A declaration by a private citizen or a religious leader claiming to have his own militia to "deal" with fellow citizens on the streets is an open violation of the law and an attempt to take the law into his own hands. This could trigger chaos if the opposing side also decides to form self-defense forces.
Regarding the issue of anyone being threatened with violence or having their human dignity degraded by another citizen, the Constitution strictly forbids it:



3. The Mystery of the Police Force's Silence

Up until now, the Police Force has remained completely silent, acting as if they haven't heard these dangerous remarks. This silence raises many questions about double standards:

Why is it that when the opposition issues political statements, they are dealt with at an incredible speed? CHADEMA Chairman, Tundu Lissu, was arrested and currently faces serious charges of treason and incitement, with his case still roaring in court while he remains in detention. How is it that a person making political remarks and criticizing the system is prosecuted for incitement and treason, yet a leader who stands publicly and threatens physical cruelty ("circumcising people without anesthesia") and forms illegal security forces is left roaming the streets without even being summoned by the police for questioning?
Does this silence not translate to an indirect endorsement or permission from the Police for these pro-state groups to cause chaos and violate the law?

Discussion Point:

Members, is our country guided by the principles of Law and the Constitution, or is it ruled by ideological preferences? Does this silence of the police regarding Sheikh Mwaipopo, while the other side like Tundu Lissu suffers in court, build or destroy the image of our security organs?
Welcome for your arguments.

Mwaipopo(shehe!) Anamlinda mfuasi wake, kama asingekuwa shehe polisi wangekwisha mbada.
 
Samia anavitukanisha vyombo vyetu vya ulinzi na usalama. Yeye kama kiongozi anakaa kimya it means amebariki haya mambo ya mwaipopo na hii inaleta chuki ya wanchi dhidi ya vyombo vya usalama.
 
Umetoa hoja ya msingi sana na yenye ukweli mchungu mno Mkuu binti kiziwi! Ninauona uchungu ulio nao kwenye hii hoja na ninauelewa kwa asilimia mia moja, kwa sababu kila Mtanzania mpenda haki anajisikia vibaya kuona uhuni huu.
Umeigusa kiini cha tatizo la nchi yetu: sheria inatumika kama silaha ya kisiasa (selective justice). Ni jambo linalosikitisha na kukera sana kuona jinsi mfumo wetu ulivyo na upendeleo wa wazi kabisa tukilinganisha matukio ya nyuma na haya ya sasa:
  • Darubini kwa Wapinzani: Kama ulivyosema, mwanasiasa wa upinzani au mwanaharakati akikohoa tu, polisi wanakesha kuchambua kila silabi. Sote tunakumbuka kesi ya jinai namba 279 ya mwaka 2016 ambapo Makamu Mwenyekiti wa CHADEMA Tundu Lissu aliburuzwa mahakamani kwa makosa ya uchochezi kwa kutumia tu maneno mepesi ya kisiasa kama "dikteta uchwara". Pia tunakumbuka jinsi viongozi kama Godbless Lema walivyonyimwa dhamana na kusota selo kwa sababu tu ya "kutoa unabii wa ndoto", au kesi nzito ya ugaidi iliyomkabili Freeman Mbowe mnamo 2021 kwa mambo ya kubatizwa majukwaani. Huko kote neno kwa neno lilipimwa ili kuwasingizia uhaini na ugaidi.
  • Upofu kwa Chawa wa Mfumo: Lakini huku upande wa pili, mtu anaposimama hadharani na kutishia raia kuteswa kwa "kutahiriwa bila ganzi" au "kukata watu vichwa" kwa sababu ya kutumia haki yao ya kuandamana Julai 7, polisi hao hao wanajifanya viziwi na vipofu. Hapa hakuna uchambuzi wa neno kwa neno tena, bali kuna ukimya wa baraka kwa sababu tu wanaotoa vitisho hivyo wanailinda serikali iliyopo madarakani.
Huu undumilakuwili ndio unaothibitisha kuwa Jeshi la Polisi limeacha kuwa chombo cha ulinzi wa raia na mali zao, na limebaki kuwa kitengo cha propaganda cha kulinda watawala. Wananchi tunapaswa kukataa huu uhuni wa kisheria ambapo watu fulani wako juu ya sheria kwa sababu tu wanabeba mabango ya kusifu na kuabudu mfumo wetu mbovu.
Umetisha sana kwa kuweka ukweli huu hadharani mkuu!
Maelezo mazuri mkuu wangu!

Kinachochekesha (kituko) ni hiyo kesi ya Lema kuhusu unabii aliotoa, sasa mtu asiote jamani? au akiota asiseme😅
 
Genge la kigaidi la Mwaipopo linafadhiliwa na Dully ndiyo maana polisiccm wameufyata.
 
Wakuu,
Nadhani wengi wenu mmeona au kusikia taarifa za mkutano na waandishi wa habari uliofanywa na Sheikh Said Mwaipopo mnamo Juni 20, 2026, kuelekea maandamano yaliyopangwa ya tarehe 7 Julai (Saba Saba). Katika kauli yake, ametishia kuwepo kwa "kikosi kazi maalum" kitakachowashughulikia waandamanaji kwa madai ya kulinda miundombinu. Alikwenda mbali zaidi na kutoa lugha ya vitisho vya kikatili akisema, "Tutakayemkamata tutamtahiri bila ganzi...".


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ol5xflQ1lJg

Hili jambo linazua maswali mazito sana ya kisheria na kikatiba ambayo kama wadau wa jukwaa hili tunapaswa kuyajadili kwa mapana:

1. Maandamano ya Amani ni Haki ya Kikatiba, si Hisani
Kwanza kabisa, ikumbukwe kuwa Katiba ya Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania inatambua maandamano ya amani kama haki ya msingi ya kiraia. Kisheria, wananchi wanaopanga kuandamana wanatakiwa kujaarifu tu Jeshi la Polisi na sio kuomba kibali. Polisi wana wajibu mkuu kisheria wa kuwepo eneo la tukio ili kuwalinda waandamanaji na mali zao, na sio kuzuia haki hiyo au kuruhusu makundi mengine kuingilia kati.
Hapa naomba kunukuu kifungu cha Katiba kinacholinda haki hii:



Uamuzi wa Mahakama Kuu na Sheria ya "Taarifa" (Notification):

Msisitizo wa kisheria hapa unakuja kufuatia Uamuzi wa Kihistoria wa Mahakama Kuu ya Tanzania wa Mwaka 1994 katika Kesi ya Rev. Christopher Mtikila v. The Attorney General (Civil Case No. 5 of 1993). Katika uamuzi huo, Mahakama Kuu ilitengua rasmi matakwa ya zamani ya kisheria yaliyokuwa yanawataka raia kuomba "kibali" cha polisi ili kukusanyika au kuandamana. Mahakama ilitamka wazi kuwa sheria inayolazimisha raia kuomba kibali cha polisi inakiuka Katiba na inaminya kwa namna isiyo halali uhuru wa kimsingi wa kukusanyika.

Kufuatia uamuzi huo wa mwaka 1994, chini ya Kifungu cha 43 cha Sheria ya Jeshi la Polisi na Huduma Sadizi (Sura ya 322), utaratibu pekee halali uliosalia ni waandaaji kutoa taarifa ya maandishi kwa mkuu wa polisi wa eneo husika saa 48 kabla ya mkusanyiko. Polisi hawana mamlaka ya kutoa au kuzuia "kibali," bali wajibu wao wa kisheria ni kutoa ulinzi ili kuhakikisha amani inadumishwa na haki ya kikatiba inalindwa dhidi ya vikundi binafsi.

2. Je, Kikosi Kazi cha Mwaipopo Kiko Kisheria?
Katiba ya nchi inasema chombo chenye mamlaka ya kukamata na kuzuia uhalifu ni Jeshi la Polisi pekee. Tamko la raia binafsi au kiongozi wa dini kudai ana kikosi chake cha "kushughulikia" raia wenzake barabarani ni ukiukaji wa wazi wa sheria na ni jaribio la kujichukulia sheria mkononi. Hii inaweza kuzaa machafuko iwapo upande wa pili nao utaamua kuunda vikosi vya kujihami.
Kuhusu suala la mtu yeyote kutishiwa ukatili au kudhalilishwa utu wake na raia mwingine, Katiba inakataza vikali:



3. Fumbo la Ukimya wa Jeshi la Polisi

Hadi sasa, Jeshi la Polisi limekaa kimya utadhani halijasikia kauli hizi za hatari. Ukimya huu unazua maswali mengi ya kiundumilakuwili (double standards):
Mbona upande wa upinzani ukitoa matamko ya kisiasa unashughulikiwa kwa kasi ya ajabu? Mwenyekiti wa CHADEMA, Tundu Lissu, alikamatwa na hadi sasa anakabiliwa na mashtaka mazito ya uhaini na uchochezi, ambapo kesi yake bado inaendelea kuunguruma mahakamani huku akiwa kuzuizini. Inakuwaje mtu anayetoa kauli za kisiasa na kukosoa mfumo anashtakiwa kwa uchochezi na uhaini, lakini kiongozi anayesimama hadharani na kutishia kufanya ukatili wa kimwili ("kutahiri watu bila ganzi") na kuunda vikosi haramu vya ulinzi anaachiwa akidunda mitaani bila hata kuitwa polisi kuhojiwa?
Je, ukimya huu hautafsiriwi kama baraka au kibali cha Polisi kwa makundi haya yanayoiunga mkono dola kufanya fujo na kukiuka sheria?

Mjadala:

Wakuu, hivi nchi yetu inaongozwa na misingi ya Sheria na Katiba au inaongozwa kwa matakwa ya kiitikadi? Je, ukimya huu wa polisi kwa Sheikh Mwaipopo huku upande wa pili kama akina Tundu Lissu wakisota mahakamani unajenga au unabomoa taswira ya vyombo vyetu vya usalama?
Karibuni kwa hoja.



🇬🇧 INTERNATIONAL AUDIENCE VERSION
TITLE: CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS VS PRIVATE MILITIAS: WHAT DOES THE SILENCE OF THE POLICE FORCE REGARDING SHEIKH MWAIPOPO’S THREATS MEAN?
Dear members,

I believe most of you have seen the footage or heard about the press conference held by Sheikh Said Mwaipopo on June 20, 2026, regarding the planned demonstrations on July 7th (Saba Saba). In his statement, he threatened the existence of a "special task force" that would deal with the demonstrators under the guise of protecting infrastructure. He went further to use harsh, cruel words of threat, stating, "Whoever we catch, we will circumcise them without anesthesia...".

This incident raises heavy constitutional and legal questions that we, as stakeholders of this platform, need to discuss extensively:

1. Peaceful Demonstration is a Constitutional Right, Not a Privilege

First and foremost, it must be recalled that the Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania recognises peaceful demonstration as a fundamental civil right. Legally, citizens planning to demonstrate are only required to notify the Police Force and not to beg for permission. The police have one primary legal obligation: to be present at the scene to protect the demonstrators and their property, rather than stopping the exercise of this right or allowing other groups to interfere.

Here, let me quote the specific constitutional provision protecting this right:


The High Court Precedent and the "Notification" Requirement:

This legal standpoint is heavily backed by a landmark 1994 Tanzanian High Court Ruling in the case of Rev. Christopher Mtikila v. The Attorney General (Civil Case No. 5 of 1993). In this watershed judgement, the High Court decisively struck down old statutory provisions requiring citizens to acquire a police "permit" before holding a public assembly or demonstration. The Court boldly declared that forcing citizens to seek permission fundamentally infringes upon the constitutional freedom of assembly.

Consequently, following that 1994 precedent and under Section 43 of the Police Force and Auxiliary Services Act (Cap 322), the operational protocol is restricted strictly to a 48-hour prior written notification to the officer in charge. The police have absolutely no legal powers to issue or deny a "permit"; their statutory mandate is solely to regulate traffic, maintain public order, and shield peaceful demonstrators from external interference or private actors trying to hijack the law.

2. Is Mwaipopo's Task Force Legally authorised

The country's Constitution explicitly states that the only institution with the mandate to arrest, investigate, and prevent crime is the Police Force. A declaration by a private citizen or a religious leader claiming to have his own militia to "deal" with fellow citizens on the streets is an open violation of the law and an attempt to take the law into his own hands. This could trigger chaos if the opposing side also decides to form self-defense forces.
Regarding the issue of anyone being threatened with violence or having their human dignity degraded by another citizen, the Constitution strictly forbids it:



3. The Mystery of the Police Force's Silence

Up until now, the Police Force has remained completely silent, acting as if they haven't heard these dangerous remarks. This silence raises many questions about double standards:

Why is it that when the opposition issues political statements, they are dealt with at an incredible speed? CHADEMA Chairman, Tundu Lissu, was arrested and currently faces serious charges of treason and incitement, with his case still roaring in court while he remains in detention. How is it that a person making political remarks and criticizing the system is prosecuted for incitement and treason, yet a leader who stands publicly and threatens physical cruelty ("circumcising people without anesthesia") and forms illegal security forces is left roaming the streets without even being summoned by the police for questioning?
Does this silence not translate to an indirect endorsement or permission from the Police for these pro-state groups to cause chaos and violate the law?

Discussion Point:

Members, is our country guided by the principles of Law and the Constitution, or is it ruled by ideological preferences? Does this silence of the police regarding Sheikh Mwaipopo, while the other side like Tundu Lissu suffers in court, build or destroy the image of our security organs?
Welcome for your arguments.

Wanafikiri ndiyo namnavya kuikwepa icc dhidi ya kitakachofanywa na mbwa mwitu wa chawapopo
 
Back
Top Bottom