Ingredients of treason in Tanzania: Je Lissu katenda yapi/lipi kati ya haya

Ingredients of treason in Tanzania: Je Lissu katenda yapi/lipi kati ya haya

R

Retired

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2016
Posts
52,815
Reaction score
103,955
haya ndiyo mambo ya kujadiliwa na wasomi.

Lisu katenda lipi kati ya haya

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF TANZANIA AT ZANZIBAR

(CORAM: KISANGA J.A, RAMADHANI , J.A, And LUGAKINGIRA, J.A.)

CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO 9 OF 2000

Between.

S. M. Z. ................. ........................................................APPLICANT

A n d

MACHANO KHAMIS ALI &17 OTHERS..........................REPONDENTS

(Application for Revision from the Ruling of the

High Court of Zanzibar at Zanzibar)

( Tumaka Deputy CJ)

dated the 3rd day of April, 2000

in

Session Case No. 7 of 1999

ORDER OF THE COURT​

.........................From the cited authorities, therefore, the following four matters have to be proved in an

Indictment for treason:

1. An act has been committed

2.The act is treasonable

3. The act is against a sovereign or a state; and lastly

4. The act was done by a person who owes allegiance to the sovereign or the state.


1751727810269.png

Court of appeal of Tanzania
 

Attachments

Kisheria, treason siyo kauli au criticism, bali ni kitendo cha wazi kinachoathiri sovereignty ya nchi. Unless Lissu committed a specific and proven act against the state , not just speaking against the government , basi it’s legally weak to label his actions as treasonous.
 

Soma ‘section VII’ ya penal code, treason imefafamuliwa kwa kina in article 39. Au kwenye katiba na ‘Treason Act 1970’ utapata maelezo zaidi.

Hizo ulizoweka ni ‘actus and mens rea’ (burden of proof) za treason.

An act, has various definitions from the law, which include; execution of the intention or public incitement or planning to commit.

Aina maana natetea serikali kuendelea na hiyo kesi ya kijinga (given the gravity of punishment).

Nonetheless you don’t have to collaborate with any to commit a treason offence.
 
Retired said:
haya ndiyo mambo ya kujadiliwa na wasomi.

Lisu katenda lipi kati ya haya

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF TANZANIA AT ZANZIBAR

(CORAM: KISANGA J.A, RAMADHANI , J.A, And LUGAKINGIRA, J.A.)

CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO 9 OF 2000

Between.

S. M. Z. ................. ........................................................APPLICANT

A n d

MACHANO KHAMIS ALI &17 OTHERS..........................REPONDENTS

(Application for Revision from the Ruling of the

High Court of Zanzibar at Zanzibar)

( Tumaka Deputy CJ)

dated the 3rd day of April, 2000

in

Session Case No. 7 of 1999

ORDER OF THE COURT​

.........................From the cited authorities, therefore, the following four matters have to be proved in an

Indictment for treason:

1. An act has been committed

2.The act is treasonable

3. The act is against a sovereign or a state; and lastly

4. The act was done by a person who owes allegiance to the sovereign or the state.


View attachment 3395119
Court of appeal of Tanzania
Click to expand...
Nia ya JMT si kesi ya uhaini.Ni kupoteza muda,kupooza hekaheka za CDM,kutisha jamii iogope serikali,kumnyong'onyeza TAML na CCM kujitengenezea fursa ya kushinda uchaguzi bila bughudha wala hawakupigia hesabu za hasara zake.Basi!
 
Matumizi mabaya ya rasilimali za umma. Garama inayotumika katika kesi hii nadhani mpaka kufikia sasa ni zaidi ya wananchi 1000 na ushehe wangenunuliwa baiskeli
 
Mayor Quimby said:

Soma ‘section VII’ ya penal code, treason imefafamuliwa kwa kina in article 39. Au kwenye katiba na ‘Treason Act 1970’ utapata maelezo zaidi.

Hizo ulizoweka ni ‘actus and mens rea’ (burden of proof) za treason.

An act, has various definitions from the law, which include; execution of the intention or public incitement or planning to commit.

Aina maana natetea serikali kuendelea na hiyo kesi ya kijinga (given the gravity of punishment).

Nonetheless you don’t have to collaborate with any to commit a treason offence.
Click to expand...
The current precedent in Tanzania with regard to treason ingredients is as above. Departure from it is another thing altogether and categorically wamesema ili treason itendeke haya inabidi yawe yamefanyika (acts), that is what the precedent says.

All in all ni discussion nzuri kuelimishana......ngoja nisome hicho ulichokiandika. Thanks.

section vII naiangalia siioni.........that relates to treason
 
Retired said:
The current precedent in Tanzania with regard to treason ingredients is as above. Departure from it is another thing altogether
Click to expand...
The starting point of any prosecutor or defence in a criminal case is not precedence (but looking at the facts of the case)

Thereafter it’s the duty of prosecution to provide the ‘burden of proof’ on the allegations until proven otherwise (the matter is assumed innocence).

There is no such thing as ‘ingredients’ of crime in criminal law anywhere in the world. The basis of criminal offences are always expressed from the nation penal code (summarised, same offenses could be expressed in different acts).
 
Mayor Quimby said:
Nonetheless you don’t have to collaborate with any to commit a treason offence.
Click to expand...
NAJARIBU KU- IMAGINE A SCENARIO NIKIWA PEKE YANGU NINAVYOWEZA KUPINDUA SERIKALI, PEKE YANGU PER SE!

AN IMAGINARY SITUATION, Let say labda niende na bunduki niiteke TBC, nichukue mic nijitangaze kuwa kuanzia sasa mimi ndiye Rais!!!!!! Can this be treason?
 
Mayor Quimby said:
The starting point of any prosecutor or defence in a criminal case is not precedence (but looking at the facts of the case)

Thereafter it’s the duty of prosecution to provide the ‘burden of proof’ on the allegations until proven otherwise (the matter is assumed innocence).

There is no such thing as ‘ingredients’ of crime in criminal law anywhere in the world. The basis of criminal offences are always expressed from the nation penal code (summarised, same offenses could be expressed in different acts).
Click to expand...
You are very correct!1 Lakini literature inasema hivyo, may be let us first define the word "ingredient"/elements
 
Retired said:
haya ndiyo mambo ya kujadiliwa na wasomi.

Lisu katenda lipi kati ya haya

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF TANZANIA AT ZANZIBAR

(CORAM: KISANGA J.A, RAMADHANI , J.A, And LUGAKINGIRA, J.A.)

CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO 9 OF 2000

Between.

S. M. Z. ................. ........................................................APPLICANT

A n d

MACHANO KHAMIS ALI &17 OTHERS..........................REPONDENTS

(Application for Revision from the Ruling of the

High Court of Zanzibar at Zanzibar)

( Tumaka Deputy CJ)

dated the 3rd day of April, 2000

in

Session Case No. 7 of 1999

ORDER OF THE COURT​

.........................From the cited authorities, therefore, the following four matters have to be proved in an

Indictment for treason:

1. An act has been committed

2.The act is treasonable

3. The act is against a sovereign or a state; and lastly

4. The act was done by a person who owes allegiance to the sovereign or the state.


View attachment 3395119
Court of appeal of Tanzania
Click to expand...
tuwaachie mahakama na maloya
 
Mzalendo Uchwara said:
Hiyo kesi ni aibu tu kwa serikali, na ndio maana wanafanya vibweka vya kuomba iahirishwe kila mara, hakuna kesi pale.

Hakimu angekuwa anajielewa angeifutilia mbali zamani sana.
Click to expand...
Uko sahihi kabisa. Na walivyo vilaza, rais anakaa kabisa Ikulu eti anafuatilia kesi. Ksema ukweli sikudhani kuwa serikali hii ina watu wa hovyo namna hii. Huyo hakimu anatumika ili watoto wake na yeye wapate kula japo hili nalo siyo kisingizio. Watu wamelewa madaraka na wasijue kuwa siku moja tu inaweza kubadilisha mengi kwenye siasa. Magufuli na wapambe wake nao walikuwa wamelewa chakari mpaka siku mambo yalipobadilika bila wao kuamini.
 
Retired said:
haya ndiyo mambo ya kujadiliwa na wasomi.

Lisu katenda lipi kati ya haya

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF TANZANIA AT ZANZIBAR

(CORAM: KISANGA J.A, RAMADHANI , J.A, And LUGAKINGIRA, J.A.)

CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO 9 OF 2000

Between.

S. M. Z. ................. ........................................................APPLICANT

A n d

MACHANO KHAMIS ALI &17 OTHERS..........................REPONDENTS

(Application for Revision from the Ruling of the

High Court of Zanzibar at Zanzibar)

( Tumaka Deputy CJ)

dated the 3rd day of April, 2000

in

Session Case No. 7 of 1999

ORDER OF THE COURT​

.........................From the cited authorities, therefore, the following four matters have to be proved in an

Indictment for treason:

1. An act has been committed

2.The act is treasonable

3. The act is against a sovereign or a state; and lastly

4. The act was done by a person who owes allegiance to the sovereign or the state.


View attachment 3395119
Court of appeal of Tanzania
Click to expand...

Facebook

www.facebook.com www.facebook.com

ataumia mwenyewe
 
macho_mdiliko said:
Uko sahihi kabisa. Na walivyo vilaza, rais anakaa kabisa Ikulu eti anafuatilia kesi. Ksema ukweli sikudhani kuwa serikali hii ina watu wa hovyo namna hii. Huyo hakimu anatumika ili watoto wake na yeye wapate kula japo hili nalo siyo kisingizio. Watu wamelewa madaraka na wasijue kuwa siku moja tu inaweza kubadilisha mengi kwenye siasa. Magufuli na wapambe wake nao walikuwa wamelewa chakari mpaka siku mambo yalipobadilika bila wao kuamini.
Click to expand...
Yupo wapi mzee wa MTANIFANYA NN
Jobs Yustino Ndugai! Aliyewadunisha kina mdee hadi kuwavua nguo akiwatumia askari wa bunge na kuwafungia nusu mwaka . Baadae akaja kuwapishia garage na kuja kuwa mtetezi wao??,
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Our Community

Coming Soon

Regional Communities

Coming Soon
Back
Top Bottom
Menu
Forums
New posts
Log in
Register