Point 4 za Dambisa Moyo (Mwandishi wa Kitabu cha Dead Aid) na Uchumi wa Rais Magufuli

[stakehigh]

Kama ulichosema ni kweli,turudishe fedha zote tulizonazo kwenye mzunguko BoT halafu tuanze upya.Mtumishi afanye kazi halafu alipwe kisicholingana na ukubwa wa kazi na muda aliotumia?Huo ndiyo uchumi mnaotaka kuujenga?Siyo sawa na utumwa?
Mbona Rais,Wabunge,Mawaziri,Ma RC & DC wanapokea mishahara minono?Vipi kuhusu wanaofanya kazi TRA,TAKUKURU,BoT,TANESCO,TANAPA,JWTZ na pia wanalipwa kama Waalimu,Wauguzi,Maofisa Ugani walipwe sawa ili kutokumwaga fedha?

i said i stand corrected: my point was uchumi haujengwi kwa kuongeza mishara peke yake: but it plays a part: it was a typing error

 

[stakehigh]

Kama ulichosema ni kweli,turudishe fedha zote tulizonazo kwenye mzunguko BoT halafu tuanze upya.Mtumishi afanye kazi halafu alipwe kisicholingana na ukubwa wa kazi na muda aliotumia?Huo ndiyo uchumi mnaotaka kuujenga?Siyo sawa na utumwa?
Mbona Rais,Wabunge,Mawaziri,Ma RC & DC wanapokea mishahara minono?Vipi kuhusu wanaofanya kazi TRA,TAKUKURU,BoT,TANESCO,TANAPA,JWTZ na pia wanalipwa kama Waalimu,Wauguzi,Maofisa Ugani walipwe sawa ili kutokumwaga fedha?

To correct you BOT is responsible for only 3% of all the money: Most money comes from commercial banks, they are the ones who create new money into the economy: Sio lazma in form of these papers we use but as we all know money is just digits typed into the computer these days: So ukiweka BOT pemben money will still boom and boom not unless we need new papers

 

[Geofgee]

Hata ukiwaelimisha hawatakuelewa,ni mwendo wa kusifia kila afanyacho/atamkacho kiongozi wa Malaika aishiye duniani tens hapa hapa Tanzania.
Tusipodai Katiba,Huyu Baba hatatuacha salama.Kama within 4 years katusambaratishia nchi kiasi hiki,imagine what will happen after 5 or 10 years? Let's take drastic measures to stop this from happening.

Kumbe nchi hii imesambaratishwa ee.. nilikuwa sijui

 

[Gellangi]

To correct you BOT is responsible for only 3% of all the money: Most money comes from commercial banks, they are the ones who create new money into the economy: Sio lazma in form of these papers we use but as we all know money is just digits typed into the computer these days: So ukiweka BOT pemben money will still boom and boom not unless we need new papers

Nadhani hujaelewa nilichomaanisha.Mkuu aliondoa fedha za serikali na kuzipeleka BoT.Uliona Commercial Banks zilivyoathirika?Pia fedha zote za nchi zinasimamiwa na BoT na siyo Commercial Banks kama sijakosea.

 

[BUBERWA D.]

Yaani mishahara ya wafanyakazi na mikutano ya kisiasa ndio hukuza uchumi? Mimi sikuambii mpumbavu kama ulivyoniambia, lakini jaribu kurejea maoni au kauchambuzi kako.
Mishahara ya wafanyakazi ni; na inatakiwa kuwa ni matokeo ya kukuzwa kwa uchumi kupitia production na appropriate investiment.

Umemjibu vyema

 

[Al Watani]

Nimesoma nitarejea baadae kuja kuunga mkono hoja.
By the way awamu ya tano imeua microfinance institutions nyingi hivyo imeanza kudiverge from middle east model

Umeelewa vibaya. Uchumi Ni Mambo yafuatayo.
C= individual consumption
I= Both foreign and domestic investments.
G= Government spending both recurent and progressive
(X-M) = Net exports

Vyote happy juu jpm anaviharibu na hivyo haukui unadiminis at high decreasing rate.
Mfano ukiincrase mishara ya wafanyakazi unakuza (C) na ukiruhusu mikutano ya wanasiasa unakuza (I) Mana investors wanawekeza kwenye sehemu zenye demokrasia ili serikali ikiwanyanyasa wanapitia kwa wapinzani kutetea maslahi yao bungeni, Sasa hivi bunge limewekwa mfukoni hivyo hakuna mwekezaji mwehu atakayewekeza ambapo serikali onaongozwa kwa matamko tu, it's too risky to investors.
Mwisho kabisa soma uelewa usidownload material na kujustify upumbavu wako.

 

[Gellangi]

Kumbe nchi hii imesambaratishwa ee.. nilikuwa sijui

Mifumo ya kiuchumi mingi imesambaratishwa,wewe hauoni?

 

[Ngwanakilala]

We Ni zero brain. Nimetaja mfano mishahara pia ajira kwa watu inaongeza velocity of money using quantity theory of money. Huyu mtu tangu aingie madarakani kapiga chini kabisa watu kuajiriwa. Uchumi hauendi hivyo lazima ukuze consumption rate through individual income or rather disposable income ili kukuza C= a + bY. Kinachokua kwa Sasa Ni 'a' ambayo haina positive impact kwa health economy. Pili command economy imeshafeli nchi nyingi. State ikiongoza uchumi eventually unasease tu. Mf shirika la ndege na shirika la sim lilipaswa liendeshwe na private companies through ppp I'll kuongeza ufanusi kwani completion leads to efficiency hence profit maximization. Upo hapo!

Chief

Uelewa wako ni mkubwa sana. Hivi ina maana mambo haya ofisi ya rais haishauriwi? Ofisi ya rais ni taasisi kubwa sana sitaki kumlaumu mtu mmoja. Ina maana wote hawajui haya kweli?

 

[Smart Contract]

Wachina tofauti na race nyingine za watu weupe i mean wazungu kwa sababu Wachina hata kama serikali yako inachinja raia wake huwa awaiingilii mambo yenu ya ndani wapo bize na kuiba mali na ndiyo maana hupendwa na serikali za Kiafrika haswa zenye kutofuata democracia wazungu kosa lao ni yale malezi ya tangu utotoni wametengenezwa kutomudu uvunjwaji wa haki za binadamu.

Umeelewa vibaya. Uchumi Ni Mambo yafuatayo.
C= individual consumption
I= Both foreign and domestic investments.
G= Government spending both recurent and progressive
(X-M) = Net exports

Vyote happy juu jpm anaviharibu na hivyo haukui unadiminis at high decreasing rate.
Mfano ukiincrase mishara ya wafanyakazi unakuza (C) na ukiruhusu mikutano ya wanasiasa unakuza (I) Mana investors wanawekeza kwenye sehemu zenye demokrasia ili serikali ikiwanyanyasa wanapitia kwa wapinzani kutetea maslahi yao bungeni, Sasa hivi bunge limewekwa mfukoni hivyo hakuna mwekezaji mwehu atakayewekeza ambapo serikali onaongozwa kwa matamko tu, it's too risky to investors.
Mwisho kabisa soma uelewa usidownload material na kujustify upumbavu wako.

OMG what Am I reading here, eti 'wazungu kosa lao ni yale malezi ya tangu utotoni wametengenezwa kutomudu uvunjwaji wa haki za binadamu' kuna kiumbe duniani mwenye unyama, katili, muongo, mnyonyaji, muuwaji esp. kwa watu weusi kama Mzungu, afu leo hii mtu mweusi anathubutu kumdescribe kidesign hii, minyororo ya fikra ni mibaya asee. Sasa assume mtu mwenye mentality hii akipewa Uraisi si ndio atatuuza kabisa kwa hawa beasts from Caucas caves.
Mungu mpe nguvu Rais wetu aendelee kuwadhibiti watu wenye mawazo kama haya waliofungwa ufahamu na viElimu vya Mzungu, Afrika hatutaki Economic formula za mzungu kutuprove tunapanda au tunashuka we are going to make it on our own ways, African ways. F$"* what you learn on your dumb a** Universities we don't need that dumbed down a** education it was designed to keep us Slaves so European could stay on the throne, Time is Over imefika mahala hatutahitaji wasomi mchwara tena, but those who can see beyond the illusion.
I'm not Sorry for being different.

 

[stakehigh]

Nadhani hujaelewa nilichomaanisha.Mkuu aliondoa fedha za serikali na kuzipeleka BoT.Uliona Commercial Banks zilivyoathirika?Pia fedha zote za nchi zinasimamiwa na BoT na siyo Commercial Banks kama sijakosea.

kusimamia sio creating: wenye nguvu kwenye uchumi sio BOT but ni commercial banks: BOT kazi yake ni kusmamia kazi zote zinazohusiana na fedha nchini:mfano kutoa fedha halali kwa ajili ya nchi, official currency: mifumuko ya bei: mwenendo wa fedha , lakini wanaoendesha uchumi ni commercial banks at a large percent (na wananchi wenyewe), ndo maaana unakuta mtu analalamikia serikali kuhusu ela wakisahau ela haitoki serikalini: wao wenyewe wanategemea kodi , mapato na mikopo: ingekua ivo kama unavosema isingekua na haja ya kuanza kusumbuana wananchi kuhusu ela ingekua rahisi sana: serikali ikitaka ela inaenda tu BOT nataka trillion moja kwa ajili ya SGR: chap chap inatolewa na ujenzi unafanyika, but things dont go that way

Kujibu swali lako la kutoa pesa kupeleka BOT, hilo ni swala la kawaida, na kila bank inakuaga na reserve yake kutokana na ukubwa wa hio bank: but as long its still operational thats how it operates

 

[stakehigh]

Mkuu tatizo lako halipo kwenye kingine zaidi ya ufahamu wako na hamu ulionayo ya kuwaaminisha watu kuwa yaliyo nje ya mawazo yako sio sahihi. Ubishi mkubwa hapa ni mishahara...na umekiri kuwa hujui UCHUMI still, hutaki kujifunza.

Ukiwanyang'anya mashamba watu 60,000 na ukayatumia kuzalisha miwa ufungue kiwanda cha sukari, ni kweli utakuwa umefanikiwa kuzalisha sukari kwa wingi, lakini at the same time utakuwa umeua PURCHASING POWER ya zaidi ya watu 40,000 na umeshusha demand ya sukari kwa asilimia kadhaa. Wewe umeichukulia mishahara kama zawadi ambayo wafanyakazi wanapewa na serikali kwa hisani lakini kwenye uchumi ni determinant factor.

Ujenzi wa miundombinu nao huchochea uchumi ikiwa umefanyika kwa uwiano sahihi na sectors zingine. Ukipeleka barabara shambani huku uwezo wa mkulima umeushusha sana, utabaki na barabara lakini mazao hakuna. Wanaokupinga wanazungumzia uwiano na si kwamba wamesema havina maana.

Ukiwanyang'anya mashamba watu 60,000 na ukayatumia kuzalisha miwa ufungue kiwanda cha sukari, ni kweli utakuwa umefanikiwa kuzalisha sukari kwa wingi, lakini at the same time utakuwa umeua PURCHASING POWER ya zaidi ya watu 40,000 : kiwanda cha sukari kikiua lazma utahitaji miwa zaidi: na miwa zaidi itatoka wap? lazma watu waanze kulima mashamba , ukitengeneza sukari zaidi, utauza mpaka nje zaidi apo umedouble purchasing power mara 1000: na cha zaidi umeongeza foreign currency, na hatimae umechangia ada kwa mtu anaetaka kwenda kusoma nje ya nchi akarudi na ujuzi akakuza sector ingine: wangebaki na hayo mashamba unategemea nn?

 

[Midimay]

OMG what Am I reading here, eti 'wazungu kosa lao ni yale malezi ya tangu utotoni wametengenezwa kutomudu uvunjwaji wa haki za binadamu' kuna kiumbe duniani mwenye unyama, katili, muongo, mnyonyaji, muuwaji esp. kwa watu weusi kama Mzungu, afu leo hii mtu mweusi anathubutu kumdescribe kidesign hii, minyororo ya fikra ni mibaya asee. Sasa assume mtu mwenye mentality hii akipewa Uraisi si ndio atatuuza kabisa kwa hawa beasts from Caucas caves.
Mungu mpe nguvu Rais wetu aendelee kuwadhibiti watu wenye mawazo kama haya waliofungwa ufahamu na viElimu vya Mzungu, Afrika hatutaki Economic formula za mzungu kutuprove tunapanda au tunashuka we are going to make it on our own ways, African ways. F$"* what you learn on your dumb a** Universities we don't need that dumbed down a** education it was designed to keep us Slaves so European could stay on the throne, Time is Over imefika mahala hatutahitaji wasomi mchwara tena, but those who can see beyond the illusion.
I'm not Sorry for being different.

Kuna watu wameshindwa kunua true colors za wazungu pamoja na mauaji mengi wanayosababisha Africa na Duniani kote.

 

[Midimay]

Hivi watu wanaosema serikali imezuia ajira wapo nchi hii kweli? Tembeleeni www.ajira.go.tz muone ajira zinavyotangazwa kila wakati. Ajira haijazuiwa ila ajira zile za wizara ya elimu, afya na tamisemi za kuwaajiri watu wrote wanaomaliza vyuo vikuu ndio zimekuwa selective

 

[stakehigh]

Hivi watu wanaosema serikali imezuia ajira wapo nchi hii kweli? Tembeleeni www.ajira.go.tz muone ajira zinavyotangazwa kila wakati. Ajira haijazuiwa ila ajira zile za wizara ya elimu, afya na tamisemi za kuwaajiri watu wrote wanaomaliza vyuo vikuu ndio zimekuwa selective

sio lazma uajiriwe serikalini, unaweza ata ukajiajiri ama ukaajiriwa nje ya nchi: ama ukawork online mbna option kibao tu: mbna watu wanatoka nchi zingine wanakuja kuwork uku kwetu, so means sisi wavivu sana

 

[Mohammed Khatibu]

we are on the Right track.......to hell

(rephrased from anonymous jf member!

Habari za Mchana wakuu!
Mimi nimejijengea tabia ya kutokuwa debe tupu pale unapotaka kushauri, kukosoa au kusifia jambo lililo au linalo au litakalo fanywa na mtu, kikundi cha watu, taasisi binafsi, taasisi ya umma, serikali za mitaa au serikali kuu.
Mojawapo ya kitabu nilichosoma katika kujiondolea ujinga na udebe tupu ni kitabu cha "Dead Aid" cha Dambisa Moyo. Kina mambo mengi lakini kwa leo nimeona niwashirikishe wanaJF point 4 zinazoonekana kubeba mtazamo au maoni ya Dambisa Moyo katika kitabu hicho. Natamani tusome na kuelewa hizi pointi za kujaribu kuzioanisha na Uchumi inayojengwa na serikali yetu kwa sasa au hata basi Uchumi unaoonekana na aina ya mikakati ya kufikia huo uchumi. Pointi hizo kwa kiingereza ni;

1. African countries should follow Asian emerging economies in accessing International Bond Markets and taking advantages of falling yields paid by sovereign borrowers.

2. They should encourage the Chinese policy of large-scale direct investment in infrastructure. (China invested US$900 million in Africa in 2004, compared with just US$20 million in 1975.)

3. They should continue to press for genuine free trade in agricultural products, which means that the
US, the EU and Japan must scrap the various subsidies they pay to their farmers, enabling African countries to increase their earnings from primary product exports.

4. They should encourage financial intermediation. Specifically, they need to foster the spread of microfinance institutions of the sort that have flourished in Asia and Latin America. They should also
follow the Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto’s advice and grant the inhabitants of shanty towns secure legal title to their homes, so that these can be used as collateral. And they should make it cheaper for emigrants send remittances back home.

Mimi sio mchumi lakini naona JPM yupo kwenye raiti traki, japo kwa point #2 na kidogo sana #4.

 

[Midimay]

Hivi watu wanaosema serikali imezuia ajira wapo nchi hii kweli? Tembeleeni www.ajira.go.tz muone ajira zinavyotangazwa kila wakati. Ajira haijazuiwa ila ajira zile za wizara ya elimu, afya na tamisemi za kuwaajiri watu wrote wanaomaliza vyuo vikuu ndio zimekuwa selective

Na ni kawaida kwa sababu mahitaji ya nchi kwa muongo uliopita ni tofauti na mahitaji ya sasa. Hata diplomasia ya kimataifa pia hubadilika. Globalization inaelekea kufa, tunakuja kwenye nationalists politics na resources nationalism. Sasa utafanyeje hayo bila kupigia debe kujitegemea? Utajitegemeaje bila kuelekeza fedha nyingi kwenye miradi ya maendeleo?

 

[The coolest jw]

Hivi watu wanaosema serikali imezuia ajira wapo nchi hii kweli? Tembeleeni www.ajira.go.tz muone ajira zinavyotangazwa kila wakati. Ajira haijazuiwa ila ajira zile za wizara ya elimu, afya na tamisemi za kuwaajiri watu wrote wanaomaliza vyuo vikuu ndio zimekuwa selective

Wewe ndugu uelewi kitu watu wanaitwa kwenye interview 800 ila nafasi ni tano hapo kweli kunausawa

 

[stakehigh]

Na ni kawaida kwa sababu mahitaji ya nchi kwa muongo uliopita ni tofauti na mahitaji ya sasa. Hata diplomasia ya kimataifa pia hubadilika. Globalization inaelekea kufa, tunakuja kwenye nationalists politics na resources nationalism. Sasa utafanyeje hayo bila kupigia debe kujitegemea? Utajitegemeaje bila kuelekeza fedha nyingi kwenye miradi ya maendeleo?

Kuna msemo unasema :WE ARE THE CITIZENS OF THE WORLD" , tatizo la watu wanaokupinga ni wana usemo wa "WE ARE THE CITIZENS OF TANZANIA" while itsnot there anymore: people trade in any currency they feel like and they can move anywhere and work there and far most be cizitens there: sasa kama watu hawajui kujitegemea mm sjui when will they ever enjoy life

 

[stakehigh]

Wewe ndugu uelewi kitu watu wanaitwa kwenye interview 800 ila nafasi ni tano hapo kweli kunausawa

sasa kama nafasi zipo tano unategemea vp: we apo sasa hivi watu 800 wanakufuata tunataka ajira, waajiri sasa: kama huezi acha kurusha mawe kwa waliojitahidi ata kuajiri hao 5

 

[Analogia Malenga]

Umeelewa vibaya. Uchumi Ni Mambo yafuatayo.
C= individual consumption
I= Both foreign and domestic investments.
G= Government spending both recurent and progressive
(X-M) = Net exports

Vyote happy juu jpm anaviharibu na hivyo haukui unadiminis at high decreasing rate.
Mfano ukiincrase mishara ya wafanyakazi unakuza (C) na ukiruhusu mikutano ya wanasiasa unakuza (I) Mana investors wanawekeza kwenye sehemu zenye demokrasia ili serikali ikiwanyanyasa wanapitia kwa wapinzani kutetea maslahi yao bungeni, Sasa hivi bunge limewekwa mfukoni hivyo hakuna mwekezaji mwehu atakayewekeza ambapo serikali onaongozwa kwa matamko tu, it's too risky to investors.
Mwisho kabisa soma uelewa usidownload material na kujustify upumbavu wako.

Dambisa Moyo ana Phd ya uchumi, ungemsoma kwanza Dambisa kabla ya kumjibu mleta uzi, ili uweze kumjibu Dambisa mwenyewe