one good yarn deserves another
Not only was Paul a soar away success with proconsul Sergius –
he also got given a thrashing by him! Sounds a little contradictory? Well, it is another "Church tradition" so all things are possible. But for this yarn, remarkably, there is
physical evidence – a remnant of the very column about which Paul was whipped! Apparently, the faithful can reconcile the two ideas by insisting Paul
first was thrashed by and
then converted the governor to Christianity (
it will only take you a moment to dream up the movie script – speak to Mel Gibson).
The miraculous upshot of all this is that a stump of marble selected at random in modern times provides "proof" for the missionary activity of Paul and,
ipso facto, "evidence for Jesus."
If you can believe this, you probably believed there were WMDs in Iraq and your government would not lie to you.
If it makes you happier, you can believe that St Paul was "scourged 39 times" against this innocuous stump of a pillar before converting his tormentor Sergius Paulus.
Rather more acceptable evidence (of Sergius Paulus, that is, not St Paul) is an engraved stone found at the site of ancient Soli (Kyrenia) in northern Cyprus, at the end of the 19th century.
About the same time, a boundary stone was found in Rome from the reign of Emperor Claudius (41-54) recording the name of a Sergius Paulus appointed a curator "of the banks and the channel of the River Tiber." Was it the same man? Paul's "epistle to the Romans" fails to greet him, which suggests it was not.
Reality Check
"Paul's first missionary journey under the auspices of Antioch is narrated only by Luke ... A close analysis of this account brings to light
so many improbabilities that it becomes
impossible to accord it any real confidence."
– Murphy O'Connor, Paul, His Story, p44.
In reality, the Cyprian story falls apart for a number of reasons, not least because the Governor's palace, even today, is a visible celebration of
a vibrant paganism, spanning centuries of Roman occupation. The huge palace complex, measuring 120 x 90 metres, includes the normal panoply of public and state rooms, gardens and bath houses. Exquisite mosaic floors feature the major Roman-Hellenic gods – and
all without a Christian icon in sight! Ancient Paphos had its theatre, agora and even
Asklepion, the shrine-cum-hospital of the ever-popular healing god
Asclepius, until his overthrow by Jesus. We might also reasonably suspect a fraudster's work because of a curious similarity (yet again) between the work of
"Luke" (the purported author of
Acts) and the history of
Josephus written in the 90s.
Aerial view of the proconsul's residence, Paphos.
Did Paul make it past the front door?