Mimi sisukumwi na hoja za kihisia (emotional arguments). Hebu nioneshe udhaifu wa hoja za Mswahili.
a. Amejitahidi kwa kila namna kuonesha kuwa "wingi" wa Wachagga TRA ni matokeo ya Ukabila na si kwa sababu nyingine yoyote. Nimeuliza na hajanijibu. Kuna makabila mangapi yanafanya kazi TRA na mgawanyo wake ukoje? Je kuna Wapare wangapi, Wangoni wangapi, Wasukuma, n.k Wangapi? Je kuna kitengo chochote TRA ambacho hakiongozwi na mchagga? Je kuna kituo chochote cha mpaka, au ofisi ya mkoa, wilaya isiyoongozwa na mchagga? Ratio ya vituo/ofisi zisizoongozwa na Wachagga na zile zinazoongozwa na wachagga ukoje? Naambiwa mimi ndio nifanya utafiti!!
b. Unapojenga hoja juu ya ukweli wa kundi fulani ni lazima uoneshe ukweli huo kwa kulinganisha na kundi jingine. Unapofanya utafiti kuthibitisha madai fulani (in this case Ukabila) unahitaji kuwa na control group. Amechagua TRA kuonesha kuna ukabila, that is fine, sasa anipe control group yake kwenye ofisi nyingi ni vipi?
c. Lengo la Mswahili na watu wanaokubaliana naye siyo kuonesha ukabila au kutafuta suluhisho la "ukabila" wauonao bali kupandikiza mbegu za chuki dhidi ya "genge la kilimanjaro", huku akidai " iweje mrangi awe meya wa DAR?" wakati "wenye mji wao wapo"! Kwa maelezo ya Mswahili, watu wote wenye asili ya bara hamtakiwi Dar au kushika nafasi yoyote, siyo Umeya peke yake, bali TRA, mashuleni n.k!! Rudini kwenu pwani ni kwa ajili ya watu wa pwani!!! Lengo lake ni kuwa mimi nikifungua ofisi yangu Dar na nikatangaza nafasi za kazi na watu wakituma maombi basi nikiona majina ya wachagga.. nifikiri mara mbili!!!
Angalia maneno ya WorM hapa:
Duh!
mswahili this term umekuja kwa kasi nyingine kabisaaa!
Nilianza naona kama utaboronga lakini uandikayo kwa kiwango flani yana ukweli mkubwa tu. Mswahili hawa wa Kilimanjaro walikufanyia nini mzee? Yani unawakandia hadi naanza kuwaogopa. Ebana unawafahamu kwa kina haswa!
Mh!!!
Tukianza kuwashuku Wachagga, na kuanza kuwanyima nafasi ati kwa vile ni Wachagga, tutakuwa tumetimiza lengo la Mswahili.
d. Nilipoonesha idadi ya makabila yote Tanzania nilitaka watu waelewe ratio ya wachagga in general population na kwenye ajira mbalimbali kazini. Nikatoa mfano kuwa Waasia walioko Marekani ni asilimia 4 tu ya Idadi wa watu wote (general population) lakini ni asilimia 14 katika nafasi za elimu na wanaongoza kwa kuwa na digrii ya kwanza asilimia 44! how is that possible? Je, Wachagga ni asilimia ngapi ya population yetu? Hebu tuachane na TRA for a second, je Wachagga wanapatikana kwa kiasi gani kwenye ofisi nyingine? Nitajaribu kusaidia hapa:
CHUO KIKUU CHA DAR-ES-SAALAM
Angalieni makabila yao (msiangalie elimu zao please)
Mkuu wa Chuo -
Balozi Fulgence Kazaura (Mhaya)
Makamu Mkuu wa Chuo
Rwekaza Mukandala (Mhaya)
Naibu Makamu Mkuu
PROF. MAKENYA A. H. MABOKO (Mha)
Naibu Makamu Mkuu
PROF. YUNUS D. MGAYA (Mpare - Mtu wa Kaskazini, karibu na Wachagga)
Haya tuangalie wakuu wa Vitivo
Faculty of Commerce and Management
Dr.E.S. Kaijage (Mhaya) B.A.(Dar.), MBA. (KU Leuven), Ph.D. (Sheffield
Faculty of Education
Dr. W.L.Lugoe (kabila???)
Faculty of Electrical and Computer Systems Engineering
Prof. A.H.Nzali (Kabila???)
Faculty of Civil Engineering and Built Environment
Prof. N.L.Lema (Mchagga)
Faculty of Mechanical and Chemical Engineering
(Acting-Dean) Prof. J. H.C.Katima (Mhaya)
Faculty of Law
Dr.I.H.Juma (kabila???)
Faculty of Science Associate
Prof. R. T. Kivaisi (Mhaya???)
B.Sc., M.Sc. (Dar), Ph.D. (Stockholm)
Wakuu ya Vyuo, Taasisi, na Vituo
Principal Muhimbili University College of Health Sciences
Prof.Kisali.J.Pallangyo (Mchagga)
Principal University College of Land and Architectural Studies
Prof. I. S. Kikula (kabila???)
Chairman-Prospective College of Engineering and Technology
Prof. B. L.M. Mwamila (Mhehe?)
B.Sc.(Eng).), M.Sc.(Dar), Ph.D. (London)
Director Institute of Development Studies (IDS)
Prof. H.M Mlawa (???)
B.A., M.A. (Dar), M Phil., D Phil, (Dar)
Director Institute of Kiswahili Research
Prof. M.M.Mulokozi (Mhaya)
B.A.(Ed.), Ph.D. (Dar)
Director Institute of Marine Sciences
Dr. A.M. Dubi (???)
Director African Virtual University (AVU)
Prof.Mwinyiwiwa (???)
Director Institute of Resource Assessment
Prof. R.B. Mwalyosi (Mnyakyusa)
Managing Director) University Computing Centre Ltd
Prof. Beda Mutagahywa (Mhaya)
B.Sc., M.Sc. (Dar), Ph.D. (Loughborough)
B.Sc., M.Sc.(Dar), Ph. D. (AUN)
Dr.ing (Trondheim)
Director Postgraduate Studies
Prof. L.H.K. Rutashobya (Mhaya)
Ph.D.(UDSM)
Director) The University Consultancy Bureau (Director)
Prof. S.A.K.Mlacha (???)
The University Consultancy Bureau
Prof. G. K. Munishi (Mchagga)
Directorate of Planning and Development (DPD)
Prof. Mashala (???)
Center for Continuing education
Director,Dr. Masoud H. Muruke (???)
Institute of Journalism and Mass Communication
Prof. M.K.Possi (???)
Sasa kwa kuangalia hapo ni watu wa kabila gani wanaongoza Chuo Kikuu cha Dar, tutafanya nini ili tuwapunguze na kuondoa ukabila huo?
Haya tutoke Chuo Kikuu twenda Wizara ya Fedha.
Hawa ndio Viongozi wakuu:
Staff
Position
Hon. Z. Meghji (MP)
Minister for Finance
Hon. A. Khatib (MP)
Deputy Minister for Finance (Treasury Services)
Hon. M. Mkulo (MP)
Deputy Minister for Finance ( Policy)
Mr. G.Mgonja
Permanent Secretary Treasury (Paymaster General)
Mr. A.Nyumayo
Deputy Permanent Secretary
Mr. R.Khijjah
Deputy Permanent Secretary (Policy and Resource Mobilisation)
Ms. B. Nyoni
Accountant General Department(Government)
Mr. I. Kasekwa
Assistant Accountant General - Expenditure Management
Mr. J. Mwanza
Assistant Accountant General - Financial Management
Mr. A. Kifile
Assistant Accountant General - Systems and Audit
Ms. I. Kasambala
Assistant Accountant General - Public Debt/Pensions management
Mr. M.Kamugisha
Commissioner for Policy Analysis
Mr. B. Shallanda
Assistant Commissioner for Policy Analysis (Macroeconomic Policy)
Mr. S. Madata
Assistant Commissioner for Policy Analysis (Debt Policy and Strategy)
Mr. S. Msangi
Assistant Commissioner for Policy Analysis (Fiscal Policy)
Mr. N. Magonya
Commissioner for External Finance
Ms. P. Malisa
Assistant Commissioner for External Finance (Aid Coordination)
Mr. P. Mwafongo
Assistant Commissioner for External Finance
M. Ngingite Acting Assistant Commissioner for External Finance (Bilateral)
Mr. N. Magambo
Commissioner for Budget
Mr. R. Hamis Assistant Commissioner for Budget (Ministries)
Ms. M. Mwamunyange Assistant Commissioner for Budget (Technical)
Mr. J. Cheyo Acting Assistant Commissioner for Budget (Payroll)
Mr. E. Maswi Assistant Commissioner for Budget (Region)
Ms. A. Bukuku
Treasury Registrar
Mr. G. Msella Assistant Treasury Registrar (Reform)
Ms. E. Mlaki Assistant Treasury Registrar (Management)
Ms. T. Mwakahesya
Director of Administration and Personnel
Mr. F. Lwiza
Director of Stock Verification
Mr. W. Mgonja Assistant Director Stock Verification
Mr. E. Msanya Assistant Director Stock Verification
H.Chanuriho Assistant Director Stock Verification
Mr.F. Mwakibinga Assistant Director Stock Verification
Mrs. B. Kamazima
Director of Information Technology Services
Mr. T. Mfikwa Assistant Director Computer Services (Systems Development)
Mr. L. Masano Assistant Director Computer Services (Infrastructure)
Mr. P. Mshangila Assistant Director Computer Services (Operations)
Ms. S. Mkapa
Director of Legal Services
Mr. A. Mcharo
Director - Technical Audit Unit
Mr. B. Shallanda
Assistant Commissioner for Policy Analysis (Macroeconomic Policy)
Mr. J. Kachenje
Acting Chief Internal Auditor (Vote 50 - Ministry of Finance)
Ms. V. Lyapa
Principal Accountant, Treasury
*******
Registrar, Tax Revenue Appeals Tribunal
Mr. R. Mwijage
Secretary, Tax Revenue Appeals Board
Ms. B. Malambugi
Secretary, Public Procurement Appeals Authority
Dr. R. Mlinga
Chief Executive Officer - Public Procurement Regulatory Authority
Ms I. Mduma
Principal Information Officer
Kati yao ni wangapi Wahaya, Wanyakyusa, na Wachagga...??? Kuna Ukabila hapo?
Kwa vile ndugu zetu hapa wanaonesha ukabila wa TRA kwa vile wana uchungu na fedha za Watanzania, hebu tuangalie basi Benki Kuu ambao ni "Pesa yenyewe" siyo wakusanyaji!!
Bodi wa Wakurugenzi
Mr. D. T. S. Ballali
Governor, Chairman
Mr. Juma H. Reli
Deputy Governor, Vice Chairman
Mr. G. S. Mgonja (Mpare)
Permanent Secretary to the Treasury (URT)
Mr. K. M. Omar (Zanizibar)
Principal Secretary to the Treasury (RGZ)
Prof. L. K. Rutashobya (Mhaya)
Director
Prof. J. Semboja (Mtu wa Tanga???)
Director
Prof. B. J. Ndunguru (Mngoni)
Director
Mr. M. N. Shirima (Mchagga)
Director
Dr. N. E. Mwamba (???)
Director
Mr. B. Kimela (???)
Ag. Secretary to the Bank