Hatimaye Marekani na washirika wake wamejaa kwa Zelensky kuhusu drone!

Hatimaye Marekani na washirika wake wamejaa kwa Zelensky kuhusu drone!

Umkonto

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2018
Posts
3,337
Reaction score
5,876
Nchi za Mashariki ya Kati na Ghuba, pamoja na Marekani, zimeiomba Ukraine iwauzie vifaa vya kuzuia ndege zisizo na rubani ili kukabiliana na ndege zisizo na rubani za "Shahed" za Iran. Lakini Kiev bado haijakubaliana na mauzo hayo. lakini kwa nini?

"Mahitaji ya ndege zisizo na rubani yameongezeka. Kila mtu anataka kuzinunua kwa bei yoyote," mwakilishi kutoka mojawapo ya watengenezaji wakubwa wa ndege zisizo na rubani za kuzuia mashambulizi aliambia BBC.

Kulingana naye, wajumbe kutoka nchi nyingi za Mashariki ya Kati, na Ghuba ya Uajemi tayari wamesafiri hadi Kiev kujadili suala hili na Ukraine.

Nchi hizi zilitaka vifaa hivi kabla ya vita kati ya Marekani na Israel upande mmoja na Iran kwa upande mwingine.

Vyombo vya habari vya Marekani viliripoti kuwa Marekani inataka kifaa hiki kukabiliana na ndege zisizo na rubani ili kulinda vituo vyake vya Mashariki ya Kati.

Waziri wa Ulinzi wa Marekani Pete Hegseth alizungumza kuhusu ndege zisizo na rubani, akisema zimekuwa "tatizo kubwa kuliko ilivyotarajiwa".

Ukraine haijajibu haraka madai ya nchi zingine. Watu wanaofanya kazi katika baadhi ya masoko ya silaha wanasema kuna upinzani usio rasmi.

Rais wa Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky amesema nchi yake imepokea ombi maalum kutoka kwa Marekani la kuunga mkono ndege zisizo na rubani katika Mashariki ya Kati.

Mapema mwezi Machi, makampuni ya silaha ya Ukraine yalipokea ofa ya kusafirisha silaha katika Mashariki ya Kati. Nakala ya waraka huo ilipatikana na huduma ya BBC Ukraine

Rais wa Ukraine ameeleza mara kwa mara masharti yanayowezekana ya ushirikiano na nchi za Kiarabu. Kulingana na yeye, Ukraine haitafuti fedha pekee, lakini pia kwa ajili ya makubaliano ya kibiashara.

Ukraine inaweza kuzipatia nchi hizi ndege zisizo na rubani, lakini badala yake, inataka kupokea makombora ya ulinzi wa anga ya Patriot kutoka nchi hizi ili kukabiliana na makombora ya masafa marefu ya Urusi.

"Tungependa kupokea kimya kimya mifumo ya ulinzi wa makombora kutoka kwa nchi hizi, na tunaweza kuwapa ndege zisizo na rubani," Zelensky alisema mnamo Machi 5.

Katika siku za hivi karibuni, Zelensky amejadili suala hili na viongozi wa Bahrain, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, na Umoja wa Falme za Kiarabu.

Jinsi droni za ulinzi zinavyofanya kazi

Ili kukabiliana na drones za mashambulizi ya Kirusi, Ukraine hutumia aina kadhaa za hatua za kukabiliana nazo.

Wakati rada au mifumo mingine inapogundua ndege isiyo na rubani ya adui, droni ya ulinzi huruka, kufikia ndege isiyo na rubani ya adui, na kisha kugonga moja kwa moja ndani yake, na kuiharibu. Ndege isiyo na rubani ya ulinzi ina kamera ili rubani aweze kufuatilia mashambulizi yanayokuja.

Ndege hizi zisizo na rubani ni nafuu mara kumi kuliko makombora ya ulinzi, ambayo yanagharimu zaidi kwa kila kombora linalorushwa.

Chanzo: BBC Swahili
 
Nchi za Mashariki ya Kati na Ghuba, pamoja na Marekani, zimeiomba Ukraine iwauzie vifaa vya kuzuia ndege zisizo na rubani ili kukabiliana na ndege zisizo na rubani za "Shahed" za Iran. Lakini Kiev bado haijakubaliana na mauzo hayo. lakini kwa nini?

"Mahitaji ya ndege zisizo na rubani yameongezeka. Kila mtu anataka kuzinunua kwa bei yoyote," mwakilishi kutoka mojawapo ya watengenezaji wakubwa wa ndege zisizo na rubani za kuzuia mashambulizi aliambia BBC.

Kulingana naye, wajumbe kutoka nchi nyingi za Mashariki ya Kati, na Ghuba ya Uajemi tayari wamesafiri hadi Kiev kujadili suala hili na Ukraine.

Nchi hizi zilitaka vifaa hivi kabla ya vita kati ya Marekani na Israel upande mmoja na Iran kwa upande mwingine.

Vyombo vya habari vya Marekani viliripoti kuwa Marekani inataka kifaa hiki kukabiliana na ndege zisizo na rubani ili kulinda vituo vyake vya Mashariki ya Kati.

Waziri wa Ulinzi wa Marekani Pete Hegseth alizungumza kuhusu ndege zisizo na rubani, akisema zimekuwa "tatizo kubwa kuliko ilivyotarajiwa".

Ukraine haijajibu haraka madai ya nchi zingine. Watu wanaofanya kazi katika baadhi ya masoko ya silaha wanasema kuna upinzani usio rasmi.

Rais wa Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky amesema nchi yake imepokea ombi maalum kutoka kwa Marekani la kuunga mkono ndege zisizo na rubani katika Mashariki ya Kati.

Mapema mwezi Machi, makampuni ya silaha ya Ukraine yalipokea ofa ya kusafirisha silaha katika Mashariki ya Kati. Nakala ya waraka huo ilipatikana na huduma ya BBC Ukraine

Rais wa Ukraine ameeleza mara kwa mara masharti yanayowezekana ya ushirikiano na nchi za Kiarabu. Kulingana na yeye, Ukraine haitafuti fedha pekee, lakini pia kwa ajili ya makubaliano ya kibiashara.

Ukraine inaweza kuzipatia nchi hizi ndege zisizo na rubani, lakini badala yake, inataka kupokea makombora ya ulinzi wa anga ya Patriot kutoka nchi hizi ili kukabiliana na makombora ya masafa marefu ya Urusi.

"Tungependa kupokea kimya kimya mifumo ya ulinzi wa makombora kutoka kwa nchi hizi, na tunaweza kuwapa ndege zisizo na rubani," Zelensky alisema mnamo Machi 5.

Katika siku za hivi karibuni, Zelensky amejadili suala hili na viongozi wa Bahrain, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, na Umoja wa Falme za Kiarabu.

Jinsi droni za ulinzi zinavyofanya kazi

Ili kukabiliana na drones za mashambulizi ya Kirusi, Ukraine hutumia aina kadhaa za hatua za kukabiliana nazo.

Wakati rada au mifumo mingine inapogundua ndege isiyo na rubani ya adui, droni ya ulinzi huruka, kufikia ndege isiyo na rubani ya adui, na kisha kugonga moja kwa moja ndani yake, na kuiharibu. Ndege isiyo na rubani ya ulinzi ina kamera ili rubani aweze kufuatilia mashambulizi yanayokuja.

Ndege hizi zisizo na rubani ni nafuu mara kumi kuliko makombora ya ulinzi, ambayo yanagharimu zaidi kwa kila kombora linalorushwa.

Chanzo: BBC Swahili
Kazi ipo.
 
Siku zijazo Ukraine itakuwa ni kati ya nchi za viwango vya juu kwenye vita. Kukaa katika vita kwa zaidi ta miaka mitatu na Urusi, siyo jambo rahisi, lazima hii nchi kila siku inazidi kupata uzoefu kwente nyanja mbalimbali za kivita. Na kile kitendo cha kupewa na kununua silaha kutoka nchi mbalimbali, inakuwa na nafasi ya nzuri zaidi ya kufanya assessment ya ubora wa kila silaha. Ukraine ipo kwenye battle, siyo kama nchi zinazotengeneza na kufanya majaribio mawili matatu na kisha kusema hii silaha ni nzuri sana.
 
Nikasema subiri kwanza niongee na mjomba AI tuzungumzie hii vita. Nikamuuliza kweli mjomba unataka kuniambia Iran ni tishio kwa Israel na Marekani? Anko akaniambia:

Short answer: Iran is a threat but not an existential one to the U.S. or Israel in this war — it can impose damage and disruption regionally (and raise political costs), but it lacks the combination of precision, integrated sustainment, and force-projection to decisively defeat either country or destroy their strategic power. It can — and has — struck U.S. forces and bases in the region, mainly with ballistic missiles, cruise missiles, and attack drones, but most attacks are limited in scale, often intercepted, and intended to retaliate or signal, not to win a conventional campaign.

Why Iran is unlikely to be an existential threat to the U.S. or Israel in this war (concise points)
  • Range/volume vs. precision: Iran fields large numbers of short- and medium-range ballistic missiles, rockets and drones. Those can hit bases and cities inside the region but have limited precision compared with Western/Israeli strike systems, so they cause damage and disruption rather than systematic destruction of a peer military’s war-fighting capacity.
  • Air defenses and defenses-in-depth: U.S. and Israeli forces use layered air defenses (Patriot, THAAD, naval Aegis/SM-3/SM-6, Israeli Iron Dome/Tamuz/Arrow) and allied host-nation systems; many Iranian launches are intercepted or degraded before causing major damage.
  • Targeting vulnerability: U.S. expeditionary forces are distributed, hardened, and use dispersion, redundancy, deception and mobility to reduce vulnerability; key assets (carriers, long-range strike aircraft, strategic command nodes) are not easily destroyed by single salvoes.
  • Logistics and sustainment limits: Iran lacks the global logistical reach to sustain long-range, high-intensity operations against U.S. forces beyond attrition/retaliation; its massed strikes also deplete its own stocks.
  • Strategic consequences: Direct major strikes on the U.S. homeland would cross red lines inviting massively escalatory U.S. responses; Iran has so far preferred retaliation inside the region and via proxies rather than direct attacks on U.S. territory.

Can Iran strike U.S. military bases during this war?
- Yes. Iran has the missile, cruise-missile and drone capability to strike U.S. bases and facilities in the Middle East and nearby countries, and Iranian forces and allied militias have used those options in this conflict. Attacks have typically focused on regional U.S. facilities, regional partner infrastructure, shipping, and diplomatic sites rather than on the U.S. homeland.

U.S. military bases and facilities in the region that are within reach / have been threatened or struck (examples)
  • Al Udeid Air Base (Qatar) — major regional air hub and CENTCOM/US Air Forces forward base; reported target/interception zone.
  • Naval Support Activity Bahrain / Juffair (Bahrain) — home of U.S. Fifth Fleet; reported struck or threatened.
  • Al Dhafra Air Base (UAE) — U.S. Air Force operations hub; within range of Iranian strikes.
  • Camp Arifjan (Kuwait) — major logistics and supply base.
  • Ali Al Salem Air Base (Kuwait) — reported intercepted missile attempts near this base.
  • Camp Buehring (Kuwait) — staging/logistics for U.S. Army.
  • Prince Sultan Air Base (Al Kharj, Saudi Arabia) — used for expeditionary operations.
  • Al Asad Air Base / Erbil / Harir / other Iraqi bases hosting U.S. forces — regularly threatened/attacked by missiles/drones and militias.
  • Jebel Ali (UAE) and other maritime/logistics hubs — naval/logistics nodes vulnerable to missile/drone attack.
  • U.S. installations in Jordan (Muwaffaq Salti/Muwaffaq al‑Salti) — used for air operations and within reach of some Iranian systems.
  • Forward-deployed ships and aircraft carriers in the Persian Gulf, Arabian Sea and Red Sea — mobile but persistent targets for anti-ship missiles, mines, drones and swarms.

Limitations and caveats
  • Interceptions are common; many reported launches are shot down or fall short.
  • Damage reported has typically been partial (infrastructure, runways, non‑hardened facilities, support/logistics), with relatively few large-scale casualties among U.S. forces to date.
  • Iran also uses proxies (Hezbollah, Iraqi militias, Houthis) to strike U.S. interests outside Iran; that multiplies avenues of attack but tends to limit control and precision.
  • Long-range strikes on the U.S. homeland are currently beyond Iran’s credible operational ballistic/cruise capability without external assistance; Iran focuses on regional effects.

Nikamwambia Anko AI sasa nionyeshee ni maeneo gani ambayo Iran anaweza kupiga kwenye bases za Marekani. Anko akaniambia:

Overview
Below are (A) concise lists of specific U.S. bases/positions in the region with approximate distances from Iran and the missile/drone range classes that can reach them, and (B) a short chronological summary of documented strikes/claims on those bases (recent years). Distances are approximate straight-line (great‑circle) estimates from Iran’s western/northwestern launch areas (e.g., near Kermanshah/West Azerbaijan) or from central Iran (Tehran area) where noted. Range classes: short-range ballistic/rocket (SRBM/ART: up to ~300 km), short-medium (MRBM: ~300–1,000 km), medium-long (IRBM: ~1,000–3,000 km); cruise missiles/drones noted separately.

A — Bases, approximate distances, and weapon-range classes
- Al Udeid Air Base (Qatar)
- Distance from central Iran: ~1,200–1,400 km
- Reachable by: MRBMs/IRBMs, medium-range cruise missiles, long-range attack drones
- Naval Support Activity Bahrain / Juffair (Bahrain)
- Distance: ~1,000–1,200 km
- Reachable by: MRBMs/IRBMs, cruise missiles, attack drones
- Al Dhafra Air Base (UAE)
- Distance: ~900–1,100 km
- Reachable by: MRBMs, cruise missiles, drones
- Camp Arifjan (Kuwait)
- Distance: ~600–800 km
- Reachable by: SRBMs/MRBMs, cruise missiles, drones
- Ali Al Salem Air Base (Kuwait)
- Distance: ~600–800 km
- Reachable by: SRBMs/MRBMs, cruise missiles, drones
- Camp Buehring (Kuwait)
- Distance: ~600–800 km
- Reachable by: SRBMs/MRBMs, cruise missiles, drones
- Al Asad Air Base (Iraq)
- Distance: ~300–700 km (varies by Iraqi location)
- Reachable by: SRBMs, short MRBMs, cruise missiles, drones
- U.S. bases in Erbil / Harir / other northern Iraq sites
- Distance: ~400–1,000 km
- Reachable by: SRBMs/MRBMs, cruise missiles, drones
- Forward bases in Syria (e.g., al-Tanf area)
- Distance: ~300–900 km
- Reachable by: SRBMs/MRBMs, cruise missiles, drones
- Prince Sultan Air Base (Al Kharj, Saudi Arabia)
- Distance: ~700–1,000 km
- Reachable by: MRBMs/cruise missiles, drones
- U.S. installations in Jordan (e.g., Muwaffaq Salti)
- Distance: ~800–1,000 km
- Reachable by: MRBMs/cruise missiles, drones
- Maritime targets (ships, carriers) in Persian Gulf/Red Sea/Arabian Sea
- Distance: variable; coastal waters within 100–600+ km
- Reachable by: anti-ship missiles, cruise missiles, sea-launched drones, mines
- Logistics hubs/ports in UAE, Oman, Bahrain
- Distance: ~700–1,200 km
- Reachable by: cruise missiles, drones, MRBMs

B — Chronological summary of documented strikes/claims (concise)
  • Jan 2020 — Qasem Soleimani strike aftermath: U.S. bases in Iraq (including Al Asad) on heightened alert; multiple militia rocket/rocket-propelled attacks on bases hosting U.S. forces during following months (small arms, rockets, mortars).
  • Jan 2020 (Jan 8–11, 2020 window) — Iran launched ballistic missiles at Al Asad and Erbil in retaliation for Soleimani’s killing. Weapon: ballistic missiles (IRBMs/MRBM-class reported). Reported damage: runway/facility damage and traumatic injuries among U.S. personnel (some cases of brain injury later reported). Many missiles reportedly impacted within base perimeters; some intercepted or fell outside.
  • 2021–2023 — Recurrent missile/rocket/drone attacks by Iran-aligned militias against U.S. bases in Iraq and Syria; weapon types: short-range rockets, artillery rockets, limited drones. Damage: sporadic infrastructure damage and occasional casualties.
  • 2023–2024 (regional escalation periods) — Houthi forces in Yemen (aligned with Iran) struck commercial and military-support shipping in Red Sea and launched missile/drone attacks on ships and nearby bases; some attacks threatened bases in the region and naval forces.
  • Oct–Nov 2023–2024 (examples during Israel–Hamas war period) — Iran-backed militias conducted multiple rocket/drone attacks against U.S. bases in Iraq and Syria (Al Asad, Erbil, K-1, others); Iran reportedly launched ballistic- and cruise-missile barrages in some episodes, with many intercepts reported by U.S. air defenses. Reported damage: infrastructure damage and limited personnel injuries; several attacks repelled.
  • April 2024 (example regional strike wave) — Iranian ballistic/cruise missiles and attack drones launched against partner facilities and coalition assets in retaliation for specific events; several launches intercepted by U.S. and allied air defenses; limited confirmed base damages.
  • Ongoing pattern (2024–2026) — Repeated tit-for-tat: Iran or proxies launch limited salvoes (rockets, SRBMs, drones, cruise missiles) against U.S. bases in Iraq, Syria, Kuwait-area logistics hubs, and maritime targets; U.S. responds with strikes on militia infrastructure or Iranian proxies. Many launches are intercepted or fall short; some cause damage to non-hardened facilities.

Notes and caveats
  • Reporting varies by incident; governments sometimes withhold detailed damage assessments.
  • Iran uses a mix of direct launches and proxy attacks; attribution and weapon type can be contested.
  • Interception rates and damage assessments change incident-by-incident; the pattern is constrained by ranges noted above and by defensive measures.

Nikamwambia Anko sasa naomba unionyeshee umbali inakuaje kuaje kwenye suala la umbali? Anko ananiambia:

Delivering the full requested package:

(A) compact distance table (straight-line km from Tehran and from Kermanshah in western Iran), estimated weapon-range classes that can reach each site, and coordinates; and

(B) a concise, sourced chronological timeline of documented strikes/claims on those sites (dates, weapons claimed, short reported effects). Sources are public news and official statements; I include citation tags you can check.

Note: distances are great‑circle approximations; “range class” is an operational estimate (SRBM ≈ ≤300 km, MRBM ≈ 300–1,000 km, IRBM ≈ 1,000–3,000 km). Kermanshah coordinate used: 34.3142°N, 47.0650°E (western-launch-area proxy). Tehran coordinate used: 35.6892°N, 51.3890°E.

A — Distance table (site — coords — distance from Tehran km — distance from Kermanshah km — likely weapon-range classes able to reach)
- Al Udeid Air Base (Qatar) — 25.1278°N, 51.1900°E
- Tehran → Al Udeid: ~1,370 km
- Kermanshah → Al Udeid: ~1,170 km
- Reachable: MRBM / IRBM, medium/long-range cruise missiles, long-range attack drones
- Sources: base coordinates and range class assessment.
- Naval Support Activity Bahrain / Juffair (Bahrain) — 26.2190°N, 50.5831°E
- Tehran → Bahrain: ~1,140 km
- Kermanshah → Bahrain: ~940 km
- Reachable: MRBM/IRBM, cruise missiles, drones, anti-ship missiles
- Al Dhafra Air Base (UAE) — 24.2481°N, 54.5584°E
- Tehran → Al Dhafra: ~1,070 km
- Kermanshah → Al Dhafra: ~940 km
- Reachable: MRBM, cruise missiles, attack drones
- Camp Arifjan (Kuwait) — 29.0833°N, 47.9167°E
- Tehran → Camp Arifjan: ~800 km
- Kermanshah → Camp Arifjan: ~560 km
- Reachable: SRBM / MRBM, cruise missiles, drones
- Ali Al Salem Air Base (Kuwait) — 29.3558°N, 47.9947°E
- Tehran → Ali Al Salem: ~820 km
- Kermanshah → Ali Al Salem: ~580 km
- Reachable: SRBM / MRBM, cruise missiles, drones
- Camp Buehring (Kuwait) — 29.4017°N, 47.7317°E
- Tehran → Camp Buehring: ~790 km
- Kermanshah → Camp Buehring: ~550 km
- Reachable: SRBM / MRBM, cruise missiles, drones
- Al Asad Air Base (Iraq) — 34.0100°N, 41.8397°E
- Tehran → Al Asad: ~870 km
- Kermanshah → Al Asad: ~380 km
- Reachable: SRBM, short MRBM, cruise missiles, drones
- Erbil (Hewler) / Erbil Air Base (Iraq) — 36.1911°N, 44.0094°E
- Tehran → Erbil: ~590 km
- Kermanshah → Erbil: ~230 km
- Reachable: SRBM / MRBM, cruise missiles, drones
- Forward bases in Syria (e.g., al‑Tanf region) — 34.3800°N, 40.9900°E (approx)
- Tehran → al‑Tanf: ~1,000 km
- Kermanshah → al‑Tanf: ~420 km
- Reachable: SRBM / MRBM, cruise missiles, drones
- Prince Sultan Air Base (Al Kharj, Saudi Arabia) — 24.0889°N, 47.3600°E
- Tehran → Prince Sultan: ~1,160 km
- Kermanshah → Prince Sultan: ~900 km
- Reachable: MRBM/IRBM, cruise missiles, drones
- Muwaffaq Salti Air Base (Azraq / Jordan region, prox. coordinates) — 31.936
 
Back
Top Bottom