Injili ya Yohana hadi leo hi mwandishi wake hajulikani

Injili ya Yohana hadi leo hi mwandishi wake hajulikani

Wazolee

Wazolee

JF-Expert Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2018
Posts
4,177
Reaction score
4,887
We may never know for certain who wrote the Gospel of John, any more than we can know who wrote the books of Matthew, Mark and Luke. We do know that John is a gospel apart, however. Early Matthew, Mark and Luke are so alike in their telling that they are called the Synoptic Gospels, meaning “seen together”—the parallels are clear when they are looked at side by side.

Hatuwezi kamwe kujua kwa hakika ni nani aliyeandika Injili ya Yohana, zaidi ya vile tunavyoweza kujua ni nani aliyeandika vitabu vya Mathayo, Marko na Luka. Tunajua kwamba Yohana ni injili tofauti, hata hivyo. Mathayo , Marko na Luka wanafanana sana katika kueleza kwao zinaitwa Injili za Muhtasari, kwa maana kwamba “zina uwiano wa pamoja”—uwiano huo unaonekana wazi zinapoangaliwa bega kwa bega. Mathayo na Luka wanafuata toleo la matukio katika Marko, ambalo wasomi wanafikiri kuwa ndiyo Injili ya kwanza na sahihi zaidi kihistoria.

Injili ya Yohana iliokotwa huko Misiri wakati huo kikijulikana kama kitabu Cha Papyrus 52
Wataalamu wa tarehe wanasema kwamba ni kitabu kilichoandikwa katika ya 64 - 70 AD

Hapo mwanzo kulikuwako na neno naye neno alikuwako Kwa Mungu nae neno alikuwa Mungu

Yani mtu aliyesema hayo Maneno hadi Leo hii hajulikani ni nani

Source
Website ya Cambridge university
 
Gily Gru said:
Seriously, na inaitwa Unjili ya Yohana. And you Wazolee
Haujui aliyeandika

what am I missing,
Click to expand...
Kama wewe unao ushahidi kuwa Yohana mwanafuzi wa Yesu ndio aliyeandika hicho kitabu weka huo ushahidi Ili Dunia ikupe zawadi maana Hadi Leo bado anatafutwa

Na utakuwa genius kuliko maprophesa wa Cambridge university
 
Injili ya yohana halafu hujui ameiandika nani, ila injili ya Luka unajua ameiandika Luka. Hayo ni matope sio akili
 
Injili ya Yohana iliandikwa na mtu aliyekuwa na malengo ya kutengeneza Yesu kuwa mungu kupitia Sanaa ya uandishi.
 
Wazolee said:
We may never know for certain who wrote the Gospel of John, any more than we can know who wrote the books of Matthew, Mark and Luke. We do know that John is a gospel apart, however. Early Matthew, Mark and Luke are so alike in their telling that they are called the Synoptic Gospels, meaning “seen together”—the parallels are clear when they are looked at side by side.

Hatuwezi kamwe kujua kwa hakika ni nani aliyeandika Injili ya Yohana, zaidi ya vile tunavyoweza kujua ni nani aliyeandika vitabu vya Mathayo, Marko na Luka. Tunajua kwamba Yohana ni injili tofauti, hata hivyo. Mathayo , Marko na Luka wanafanana sana katika kueleza kwao zinaitwa Injili za Muhtasari, kwa maana kwamba “zina uwiano wa pamoja”—uwiano huo unaonekana wazi zinapoangaliwa bega kwa bega. Mathayo na Luka wanafuata toleo la matukio katika Marko, ambalo wasomi wanafikiri kuwa ndiyo Injili ya kwanza na sahihi zaidi kihistoria.

Injili ya Yohana iliokotwa huko Misiri wakati huo kikijulikana kama kitabu Cha Papyrus 52
Wataalamu wa tarehe wanasema kwamba ni kitabu kilichoandikwa katika ya 64 - 70 AD

Hapo mwanzo kulikuwako na neno naye neno alikuwako Kwa Mungu nae neno alikuwa Mungu

Yani mtu aliyesema hayo Maneno hadi Leo hii hajulikani ni nani

Source
Website ya Cambridge university
Click to expand...
Where is here you said, desciple of Jesus wrote gospel of John

ni kawaida kwa mwandishi kuandika jina lake kama Yohana akivyoandila injili ya Yohana

Ingawa, kama unamzungumzia mwanafunzi wa Yesu, hapo sina uhakika
Ila ninachojua imeandikwa na Yohana
 
Kwa maoni yangu hakuna mwandishi aweza kuandika injili ya yohana zaidi ya Yohana mwenyewe.Mtume huyu ndiye pekee aliyekuwa karibu sana na Yesu kiasi Cha kumwegamia kama kakake.Ndiyo maana injili ya yohana imeandika mambo mengi ya ndani kuliko wengine.Kwa kuwa karibu na Yesu,yohana ameandika mengi yanayomletea binadamu UZIMA kwa sababu alipata ufunuo wa Roho mtakatifu.Tatizizo la yohana katika maandishi yake alikuwa hajitaji jina kwa mf yoh 18:15
Kama yohana siye mwandishi wa injili yake,je ufunuo wa yohana alimwandikia nani?Kuna uwezekano wa mtu kumwandikia ndoto alizoota mtu mwingine?
 
Nani kakudanganya?

Gospel of Desciple John:
Eyewitness Testimony: The text presents itself as the testimony of an eyewitness—traditionally identified as John the Apostle, one of the inner circle of Jesus.

Historical Attestation: Early Church Fathers like Irenaeus and the Catholic Encyclopedia maintained that John wrote the gospel toward the end of his life in Ephesus.
 
Wazolee said:
We may never know for certain who wrote the Gospel of John, any more than we can know who wrote the books of Matthew, Mark and Luke. We do know that John is a gospel apart, however. Early Matthew, Mark and Luke are so alike in their telling that they are called the Synoptic Gospels, meaning “seen together”—the parallels are clear when they are looked at side by side.

Hatuwezi kamwe kujua kwa hakika ni nani aliyeandika Injili ya Yohana, zaidi ya vile tunavyoweza kujua ni nani aliyeandika vitabu vya Mathayo, Marko na Luka. Tunajua kwamba Yohana ni injili tofauti, hata hivyo. Mathayo , Marko na Luka wanafanana sana katika kueleza kwao zinaitwa Injili za Muhtasari, kwa maana kwamba “zina uwiano wa pamoja”—uwiano huo unaonekana wazi zinapoangaliwa bega kwa bega. Mathayo na Luka wanafuata toleo la matukio katika Marko, ambalo wasomi wanafikiri kuwa ndiyo Injili ya kwanza na sahihi zaidi kihistoria.

Injili ya Yohana iliokotwa huko Misiri wakati huo kikijulikana kama kitabu Cha Papyrus 52
Wataalamu wa tarehe wanasema kwamba ni kitabu kilichoandikwa katika ya 64 - 70 AD

Hapo mwanzo kulikuwako na neno naye neno alikuwako Kwa Mungu nae neno alikuwa Mungu

Yani mtu aliyesema hayo Maneno hadi Leo hii hajulikani ni nani

Source
Website ya Cambridge university
Click to expand...
Yohana ana uafadhali ili muongo mkibwa na mzushi ni injili Mathayo kaibua mambo mengi ambao wenzake hawakugusia kabisa, in short bibilia imejaa uongo mwingi
 
Kwakuwa inaitwa injili ya Yohana bila shaka mwenye injili yake ndiyo alii name hilo jina. Lakini pia kuhusu kuwa na mawazo tofauti nadhani ni kawaida kwa Yohana maana hata ukisoma kitabu cha ufunuo nacho kina complexity fulani hivi
 
Wazolee said:
We may never know for certain who wrote the Gospel of John, any more than we can know who wrote the books of Matthew, Mark and Luke. We do know that John is a gospel apart, however. Early Matthew, Mark and Luke are so alike in their telling that they are called the Synoptic Gospels, meaning “seen together”—the parallels are clear when they are looked at side by side.

Hatuwezi kamwe kujua kwa hakika ni nani aliyeandika Injili ya Yohana, zaidi ya vile tunavyoweza kujua ni nani aliyeandika vitabu vya Mathayo, Marko na Luka. Tunajua kwamba Yohana ni injili tofauti, hata hivyo. Mathayo , Marko na Luka wanafanana sana katika kueleza kwao zinaitwa Injili za Muhtasari, kwa maana kwamba “zina uwiano wa pamoja”—uwiano huo unaonekana wazi zinapoangaliwa bega kwa bega. Mathayo na Luka wanafuata toleo la matukio katika Marko, ambalo wasomi wanafikiri kuwa ndiyo Injili ya kwanza na sahihi zaidi kihistoria.

Injili ya Yohana iliokotwa huko Misiri wakati huo kikijulikana kama kitabu Cha Papyrus 52
Wataalamu wa tarehe wanasema kwamba ni kitabu kilichoandikwa katika ya 64 - 70 AD

Hapo mwanzo kulikuwako na neno naye neno alikuwako Kwa Mungu nae neno alikuwa Mungu

Yani mtu aliyesema hayo Maneno hadi Leo hii hajulikani ni nani

Source
Website ya Cambridge university
Click to expand...
Basi kimeandikwa na Roho Mtakatifu mwenyewe
 
Gily Gru said:
Where is here you said, desciple of Jesus wrote gospel of John

ni kawaida kwa mwandishi kuandika jina lake kama Yohana akivyoandila injili ya Yohana

Ingawa, kama unamzungumzia mwanafunzi wa Yesu, hapo sina uhakika
Ila ninachojua imeandikwa na Yohana
Click to expand...
Ilitakiwa ujiulize kama haijaandikwa na Yohana mbona imepewa jina la Yohana

Kitu ambacho hamkijui hayo majina ya wanafunzi wa Yesu yamewekwa Ili kuwazuga hata hicho kitabu Cha Mathayo aliandika sio Mathayo mwanafunzi wa Yesu

Kitabu Cha Mathayo na Matendo mwandishi ni Paulo
 
Mwandishi wa hiyo injili ni YOHANA mwana wa Zebedayo nduguye na Yakobo. YOHANA 21:24.
 
Wazolee said:
Ilitakiwa ujiulize kama haijaandikwa na Yohana mbona imepewa jina la Yohana

Kitu ambacho hamkijui hayo majina ya wanafunzi wa Yesu yamewekwa Ili kuwazuga hata hicho kitabu Cha Mathayo aliandika sio Mathayo mwanafunzi wa Yesu

Kitabu Cha Mathayo na Matendo mwandishi ni Paulo
Click to expand...
Mimi niko tifauti kidogo, na sufatilii sana vitabu tofauti na Mark na Mathew.

Paulo alikuwa tapeli mkubwa sana na ndio chanzo cha uharibifu wa imani

Vitabu ni guidance, kuwa spiritual its a journey most fail to embark
Anyways vitabu vyote vya paulo ni utapeli wa akili yake

Samahani kwa yeyote nitayemkwanza
Ingawa napenda sana kusoma maandiko ya kale ya wayahudi tena ambayo hayako kwenye Bible
 
Covax said:
Yohana ana uafadhali ili muongo mkibwa na mzushi ni injili Mathayo kaibua mambo mengi ambao wenzake hawakugusia kabisa, in short bibilia imejaa uongo mwingi
Click to expand...
Mnapata tabu sana lakini mnachopaswa kujua ni hiki Biblia ni mkusanyiko wa maandishi mbalimbali hivyo lazima utakutana story mbalimbali kutegemeana aliyesikia na kuandika.Mfano leo hata ukiweka watu 100 walikuwepo wakati wa Nyerere utapata script tofauti tofauti maana kila mtu alimsikia Nyerere kwa namna tofauti,Hivyo hata mitume wakati wa kuitangaza injili walinakiliwa kwa namna tofauti tofauti
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Our Community

Coming Soon

Regional Communities

Coming Soon
Back
Top Bottom
Menu
Forums
New posts
Log in
Register