Je, kuna uhusiano kati ya IQ ya mtu na kabila lake, umasikini wake au kimo chake?


There are genetic variances within "same-race" populations much as there are inter-race genetic similarities. This explains why it is difficult to define "race".

But philosophically, this race/tribe and intelligence debate defies the all-important knowledge concept of tabula rasa. Tabula rasa is a theory of knowledge which states that individuals are born without built-in mental content and that therefore all knowledge comes from experience or perception.

And this quote by Maharishi sums it all: "The human brain is the hardware of the cosmic computer which, through proper programming, can compute anything."

Therefore any argument that tries to establish a link between tribes/races and intelligence is totally prejudicial.
 
Hii mikoa ilibahatika tu kupitiwa na wamisioni mapema, wakapata fursa kuingia shule za wazungu na kupata elimu ya kizungu ambayo kwa kiasi kikubwa imefifisha uwezo wao wa kufikiri na kupambanua. Ndio maana hawajaweza kulisaidia taifa hili. Usomi wao umetuongezea umaskini tuu. Hawajawahi gundua au kutengeneza kitu chochote cha kusaidia jamii. Wengi wa hao wasomi walicholitendea hili taifa ni kuliibia tu na kulisababishia ufukara. Je hiyo ni High IQ.....?

Hata huko Dodoma, Singida nk unakokusema yapo maeneo yaliyopokea wamisioni mapema yametoa hao unaoita wasomi ( high IQ) wengi tuu, jaribu kufuatilia kidogo. Na wakiingia madarasani kumeza maarifa ya kizungu wanakuwa wazuri kuliko hata hao wachaga, wahaya na wanyakyusa. Kumbe kuwa msomi wa maarifa haya ya wazungu ni kuwa na bidii tuu, na hilo linatokana na makuzi ya mtu. Hata hao wa hadzabe wakiona umuhimu wa hiyo elimu na kuamua kutia bidii wanaweza wakawa wazuri ktk maarifa ya kizungu kuliko hao unaodhani wanatoka makabila ya High IQ.

Je, ingetokea wamisioni wakajenga mashule mengi mapema Singida, Dodoma, Lindi, Mtwara nk hali ingekuwaje? wangekuwa bado wana low IQ kuliko Kilimanjaro, Mbeya na Kagera?. Hivyo sioni uhusiano wa kabila, eneo,kabila na IQ ya mtu. Nadhani wakerewe wangekuwa hapo juu ya wachaga, wanyakyusa na wahaya, kwani kisiwa hiki wana maprofessor na PhD nyingi kuliko wasukuma wote na kwa idadi ni wachache na kwao hapakuwa na shule za wamissioni. Lakini Usomi wao na wingi wao haujaikomboa Ukerewe.

Ni historia. Hao unaowaita wana High IQ walipata fursa mapema na kwa kipindi kirefu hivyo waka embrace western culture na hawa unaowaita wana low IQ hawakuwa na hiyo fursa na hawakupokea uzungu mapema. Wasomi wetu ni walaji wa maarifa ya kizungu kama sisi tunaokula sembe ya Azam, wanachojua ni ku- dispense maarifa ya wazungu kwetu sisi. Rejea Mikataba fake wanayoiingia katika taifa hili, Hawajaweza kutengeneza tekinolojia yoyote. Elimu ya kizungu ilichofanya ni ku format bongo zao ili watende na kufikiri anavyotaka mzungu (brainwashed).

Kimo, hii nayo ni dhana tu, Nyerere, Kawawa, Mkapa, Magufuli, Cleopa Msuya,Kingunge n.k wote hawa wafupi lakini waliweza kuongoza hao warefu. Fanya sensa tuone, warefu vz wafupi wapi wamekuwa na impact kubwa katika Taifa letu. Kama urefu unauhusiano na IQ basi wachina, wajapan, wakorea nk haya mataifa yangekuwa duni na South Sudan, Somalia, west Africa yakiwa kwenye High tech world.
 
Ndo maana nikasema wengi hamjui maana ya kipimo cha IQ. Unamfahamu Einstein? Unamfahamu Newton? Hawa kila taifa linajua walikuwa na IQ kubwa lakini, umewahi kuwasikia utajili wao ni wa nini au waliacha mali gani? Hakuna uhusiano kati ya cheo, pesa/mali na IQ! Hata bwege hupata mali nyingi kuliko wenye IQ ya kutosha.

NI sawa na mbio za ngiri au punda. Akikuacha maana yake siyo kwamba ana IQ kubwa zaidi yako.
 
Remember: Biology which must be respected for this case; argument says, Phenotype is a combination of genotype and environment.

IQ is a phenotype. What you see expressing itself as an IQ results from individuals' genetic makeup and environment. Tabula rasa needs to qualify itself by considering the ability to be programmed. Some brains are not programmable!
 
Wao uliowataja wamegundua vitu au topics tofautitofauti na hata wangetaka kuwa matajiri , ww Kuna vitabu vingapi vya physics worldwide vina Newton laws of motion, assume angechukua percent fulani kwenye kazi zake angepata shs ngapi ? Sijajua tumegundua nn ?
 
Kuwa na pesa siyo lazima uwe na high IQ. Yule mbunge Musukuma ni tajiri halafu standard seven, sidhani kama ana high IQ.

Kuwa na elimu inamuongezea mwenye low IQ.

Kuna environmental factors nyingi zinazochangia kuwa na either high or low high IQ, ni nyingi tu.
 
Hivi kwann IQ mnapima kwa kigezo cha mtu kufaulu darasani Tu , vp wale college dropouts waliogundua vitu ? Mnawaweka kundi gani ? Je kipimo gani sahihi cha IQ ?
 
Nona nabishana na kijana wa kidato fulani. Sorry! Tusiendelee kabisa!
 
Hivi kwann IQ mnapima kwa kigezo cha mtu kufaulu darasani Tu , vp wale college dropouts waliogundua vitu ? Mnawaweka kundi gani ? Je kipimo gani sahihi cha IQ ?
Elimu siyo kipimo cha IQ, bali inamuongezea mwenye low IQ. However mwenye high IQ ana uwezo mkubwa wa kufaulu kuliko mwenye low IQ

“Unaweza ukafaulu darasani au hata nje ya darasa”

Kwanini unadhani studies zimeonyesha breast feeding inachangia kwa mtoto kuwa na high IQ?

Jaribu kuelewa kwa upana zaidi, don’t limit yourself.
 
The hitman, siyo matajiri wote wana high IQ, wanaweza wakawa wana average IQ tu.

Wenye high IQ ambao ni matajiri wakubwa wale magnates and tycoons, kama wa Facebook na Microsoft, siyo kwamba walikuwa wanatafuta pesa, bali wali invent vitu kwenye technology ambavyo kwenye dunia ya sasa ya teknolojia, vinakupa huo utajiri mkubwa.

Kwahiyo inatokea kwenye dunia ya sasa matajiri wakubwa wa dunia, wengi wanatokea kwenye kundi la watu hao wenye high IQs’ kwasababu inventions zao zinatumika kuibadili dunia na kutoa direction tunakoelekea!

Na sizungumzii hao matajiri wa bongo, ambapo sidhani hata kama kuna kumi unaoweza kuwapa u billionaire, na hapa sizungumzii ubilionea wa pesa za madafu.

Pia chukulia mkulima wa korosho mwenye mamia au mahekari ya mashamba, ambaye amepiga bao na sasa ni tajiri mkubwa bilionea wa madafu, kwasababu bei ya korosho ime skyrocket ni lazima awe na high IQ? Au mchimbaji madini aliyetajirika?

Kwahiyo hao college dropouts, ambapo Bill Gates ni mmojawapo anayetumika sana kwenye mfano huu, yeye aliweza kuona kwamba high IQ yake inaweza kumsaidia kuwa tajiri bila kupitia utaratibu wa kawaida wa darasani. Ambapo unatakiwa umalize, uajiriwe au kujiajiri nk.

Pia kuna watu wenye high IQ ambao wanaona opportunities nje ya utaratibu wa kawaida wa darasani.

Kiufupi, watu wenye high IQ huwa wana courses higher than money.

Kwani watu kama Einstein na Newton si wangekuwa tajiri kuliko matajiri wote waliowahi kutokea? Kuna watu ni millionaires(in $),kwa utunzi tu wa vitabu nk.
Elimu ya Newton na Einstein zimewekwa kwenye vitabu vingapi? Vimetumika na magenius wangapi waliogunduwa vitu vingine baada ya kuwasoma?
 
IQ or intelligent Quotient hiki ni kipimo cha Akili MTU anazaliwa nacho hakiongezeki au hakipungui....Wengi hawajaelewa IQ ni nn tuanzie apo.....Ni Kweli IQ ina rithiwa same as km tunavorithi maradhi....Ni kweli jamii Fulani IQ yake ipo juu tofauti na jamii nyingine swala sio mashule sijui yalijengwa na wakoloni No....Chukulia Kagera na hasa Wahaya jamii hii IQ yake ipo juu tofauti na wasubi na wahangaza japo wapo mkoa mmoja na wakolon walijenga mashule pote...Chukulia Jamii ya Waisrael IQ yake ipo juu tofauti na Jamii nyingine ata waziri mkuu wao Netanyau IQ yake ni kubwa sana nadhan ndo anaweza kua anaongeza....Snopp Doggy Doggy alipimwa alikuta ana IQ kubwa sana zaid ya 150 ktk vipimo ila ndo kaishia kwenye mabangi tu....Hivyo IQ sio hizi akili zetu za kukariri Darasan No ni inborn na sometimes inherited
 

Genotype+Environment=Phenotype

Phenotype aside, determining one's intelligence objectively is where the real challenge lies. IQ tests are only an attempt to this end. Nonetheless, recent studies have established that IQ tests are only suitable for testing the mathematical and relational ability.

Aren't some brains programmable? Really?
 
Mkuu nimekuwelewa ur explanation is fantastic
 

You said that Haya people have higher IQ than Subi and Hangaza people. Could you please provide us the average score of each tribe?
 
Hujaelewa maana ya “environmental factors that impact IQ”, ukianzia hapo utapata majibu mengi tu. Ungefahamu kuwa wanaposema hivyo, ina maana IQ ni kitu mtu alichozaliwa nacho, na hayo mazingira ni vitu ambavyo vinasaidia either kuongeza au kupunguza. Mfano ukizaliwa na high IQ halafu haupati makuzi sahihi haitasaidia(nurture and parenting)

Hapo kwa Snoop Dogg unaposema “kaishia kwenye mabangi tu”, vilevile siyo sahihi. Ni mmojawapo wa east coast rap brand inventors...Hata hayo maeneo mengine uliyoyataja, environmental factor ya “ food and nutrition”, itakuwa pia imeplay role kwenye jamii hizo ie Kagera, Kilimanjaro, Baganda wale nk.

Prejudices and self belief is another factor.
 

nikopi katika ufafanuzi huo pls
 

Jmushi1;

Could you please help me? Do you have any average IQ score of each community in you last paragraph? How can we say they have higher IQ than the rest of us if we don't have the number?
 
Jmushi1;

Could you please help me? Do you have any average IQ score of each community in you last paragraph? How can we say they have higher IQ than the rest of us if we don't have the number?
Neurobiological Theory:


  • Neurobiological theory tells us that the development of a humans various forms of intelligence usually ends by the age of 16, when a criticial point is reached.

  • Afrer this point of intellectual maturity, IQ is thought to be relatively stable.

  • The environment has its biggest affect in determining someone's fluid intelligence up and till the critical point.

  • Fluid Intelligence is someone's ability to think logically in verbal and spatial terms and detect patterns too.

  • For a person to develop certain intellectual abilities, they need to be provided with the appropriate environmental stimuli during childhood, before the critical period for adapting their neuronal connections ends.

  • It should be mentioned that some researchers believe that the critical period effect is a result of the manner by which intellectual abilities are acquired—that changes in neuronal connections inhibit or prevent possible future changes which may explain differences in Intelligence types between people of different cultures.
 

Thanks for the information. However, you haven't answered the question. With all of its controversies, IQ is rigorous yardstick. So let's step back and use IQ concept they way it is supposed to be used. Can you please tell me the average IQ score of each of the following tribes: chagga, haya, baganda, subi, hangaza, Sukuma, nyakyusa, rangi, zaramo, etc?

Forget about the nutrition factor or other factors that could impact the IQ of an individual. Just please bring the raw numbers. For example, when students sit for their primary, secondary or high school exams, NECTA doesn't care about the backgrounds of individual students. If you are from a poor school, you will answer the same questions as a well prepared school.

Let's be honest in this discussion. If IQ is so important and can be improved by providing a piece of banana and a cup of milk daily, let's perform some data analysis here. If Sukuma people are a quarter of the population, you can't say they have improved their IQ because they represent 20 to 30 percent of university students.
 
Very good questions in a civilized manner, I applaud you for that!

First off, when we talk about environmental factors, mind you environments differ across the board! Certainly, cultures and tribes, have differences respectively.

Binafsi siamini kwamba makabila flani ama some races have higher IQ just because of that!(this is my disclaimer), kwasababu inaonekana unajaribu kuinsist on it! Environmental factors does not prove that to be true. It is the reason I dispute high IQ to be justified based on race, color, gender or nation of origin. But then again, culture, be it national or tribal, have impact on the developing of ones IQ!

HOWEVER, environmental factors goes across the board. Kwa mfano kama imetokea some tribe to be under a certain cultural environment, huwezi kuiapplaud hiyo culture na kuassociate the tribe with low IQ! Rather, you attribute it to the environmental factor of which the culture is under.

In some ways, your intention was to see the issues mixed...

One side of the mixture, you’re talking about bananas and IQ, where as you still not sure on why those people who had a lot of bananas had higher IQ. At the same time, you don’t wanna hear about the “food and nutrition” as an environmental factor affecting the IQ.

Umeleta mifano ya ufaulu wa wanafunzi wa primary na secondary schools, lakini inaonekana hukunisoma vyema kuhusu IQ and the “appropriate environmental stimuli during childhood”
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…