Je, kuna uhusiano kati ya IQ ya mtu na kabila lake, umasikini wake au kimo chake?

Je, kuna uhusiano kati ya IQ ya mtu na kabila lake, umasikini wake au kimo chake?

Very good questions in a civilized manner, I applaud you for that!

First off, when we talk about environmental factors, mind you environments differ across the board! Certainly, cultures and tribes, have differences respectively.

Binafsi siamini kwamba makabila flani ama some races have higher IQ just because of that!(this is my disclaimer), kwasababu inaonekana unajaribu kuinsist on it! Environmental factors does not prove that to be true. It is the reason I dispute high IQ to be justified based on race, color, gender or nation of origin. But then again, culture, be it national or tribal, have impact on the developing of ones IQ!

HOWEVER, environmental factors goes across the board. Kwa mfano kama imetokea some tribe to be under a certain cultural environment, huwezi kuiapplaud hiyo culture na kuassociate the tribe with low IQ! Rather, you attribute it to the environmental factor of which the culture is under.

In some ways, your intention was to see the issues mixed...

One side of the mixture, you’re talking about bananas and IQ, where as you still not sure on why those people who had a lot of bananas had higher IQ. At the same time, you don’t wanna hear about the “food and nutrition” as an environmental factor affecting the IQ.

Umeleta mifano ya ufaulu wa wanafunzi wa primary na secondary schools, lakini inaonekana hukunisoma vyema kuhusu IQ and the “appropriate environmental stimuli during childhood”

Thanks for your answers. Let me express my position of this debate. I do believe that IQ test has its on merits in some areas. However, listen to me very carefully, I don't thinks that some Tanzanian tribes have higher IQ than the rest. I don't believe that just because you eat banana daily, you are IQ is higher than those don't eat banana daily. I don't believe that sh!t.

Furthermore, IQ is express in test scores. So if we want to have a healthily debate here, we should bring sample test scores from various regions or tribes and then make comparisons. Tanzania doesn't conduct IQ test scores in schools or in work places, so how do we know that Sukuma are better that Zaramo or Gogo in terms of IQ?

Can you allow me to assert that comparing to other tribes, chagga are overweight because they eat mtoli? I bet you won't allow me because there's no data to support my claim. For the same reason, we shouldn't allow people to make outlandish claim about IQ when they don't have the data.
 
Thanks for your answers. Let me express my position of this debate. I do believe that IQ test has its on merits in some areas. However, listen to me very carefully, I don't thinks that some Tanzanian tribes have higher IQ than the rest. I don't believe that just because you eat banana daily, you are IQ is higher than those don't eat banana daily. I don't believe that sh!t.

Furthermore, IQ is express in test scores. So if we want to have a healthily debate here, we should bring sample test scores from various regions or tribes and then make comparisons. Tanzania doesn't conduct IQ test scores in schools or in work places, so how do we know that Sukuma are better that Zaramo or Gogo in terms of IQ?

Can you allow me to assert that comparing to other tribes, chagga are overweight because they eat mtoli? I bet you won't allow me because there's no data to support my claim. For the same reason, we shouldn't allow people to make outlandish claim about IQ when they don't have the data.
It’s not about eating bananas pasee!

Plenty of communities in Africa were and still is lacking nutritions. Not only that! A daily meal itself was and still is problematic.

Human beings don’t grow proper if they do not consume food and right nutrients.

Our body functions depends primarily on that.

Things or nutrients that has something to do with cerebral cortex, will definitely impact ones IQ.

Pitia tena mabandiko yangu niliyokujibu, majibu ya maswali yako mengi yamo humo, ukisoma kwa utulivu utaona. Usisome ukiwa na fikra kwamba napingana na wewe, ama kwamba niko right zaidi yako, Naaw!

Rather tunaeleweshana...

Mfano kama unajuwa kuwa chakula na virutubisho ni vitu vya msingi kwenye ukuaji wa binadamu hata ubongo wake, nini kinachokushangaza kama watu waliotoka kwenye maeneo yenye less food and nutrients kuwa less effient human beings?

Unadhani kwanini breastfeeding pia inasaidia IQ?

Don’t limit your thinking...
 
It’s not about eating bananas pasee!

Plenty of communities in Africa were and still is lacking nutritions. Not only that! A daily meal itself was and still is problematic.

Human beings don’t grow proper if they do not consume food and right nutrients.

Our body functions depends primarily on that.

Things or nutrients that has something to do with cerebral cortex, will definitely impact ones IQ.

Pitia tena mabandiko yangu niliyokujibu, majibu ya maswali yako mengi yamo humo, ukisoma kwa utulivu utaona. Usisome ukiwa na fikra kwamba napingana na wewe, ama kwamba niko right zaidi yako, Naaw!

Rather tunaeleweshana...

Mfano kama unajuwa kuwa chakula na virutubisho ni vitu vya msingi kwenye ukuaji wa binadamu hata ubongo wake, nini kinachokushangaza kama watu waliotoka kwenye maeneo yenye less food and nutrients kuwa less effient human beings?

Unadhani kwanini breastfeeding pia inasaidia IQ?

Don’t limit your thinking...

Jmushi;

We have to dispel the myth. If you want to use IQ concept, please know what it entails and how to use.
The problem I am having here is some individuals here want to make a point using the IQ concept, but when you ask them to provide the average IQ score for each community in question, they don't have any data. What's worse, they don't have their own IQ score. My question is how you are going to make a compelling argument and try to put other people down when you don't have the fact?

For examples, when we say the GDP of Kenya is higher than that of Tanzania, we have the number to support it. When we say the economy of Tanzania grows by 7% annually, we the number to back up our claim. The number might not exactly represents the facts on the ground, but conceptually it's close to the reality.

On the contrary, when it comes to the IQ concept and how is applied in this debate, the only memorable thing we have is banana. For records, monkeys in captivity eat more banana than their brothers and sisters in the wildness. If we have to agree on everything brought forward here, one day without any reasoning we will say monkeys in the captivity are smarter because they eat more banana.
 
Wanabodi,

Usingizi umekata kutokana na mawazo ya huku kukaza kwa vyuma!, mtu unalala hujui kesho siku itaanza vipi, ukiwa totally empty!. Hivyo faraja yangu pekee ni JF. Nimesoma uzi fulani, nikaanza kuwaza na kujiuliza maswali huku mengine nikijijibu mwenyewe.

Huu ni uzi wa swali kuhusu I.Q za baadhi ya wanasiasa wetu wanaotuhumiwa kuwa na low I.Q, wakiwemo mawaziri, wabunge na wakuu wa mikoa, na vigogo wengine wengi, hivyo nikajiuliza kwanza jee ni kweli hawa wanaotuhumiwa kuwa na low I.Q, jee ni kweli wana low I.Q, au ni mtu tuu ametoa mawazo tofauti, wewe huyapendi, ndio unamtukana ana low I.Q?.

Ndipo nikaanza kujiuliza, jee kuna uwezekano watu wenye I.Q ndogo ni kutokana na makabila yao, kiwango chao umasikini kwenye makuzi, au pia heights zao have something to do with low I.Q, yaani mtu akiwa mfupi, anakuwa na akili fupi?.

Naomba kukiri zaidi ya kukosa usingizi, nimekuwa inspired na motivated kupandisha bandiko hili kutokana na hoja za mwana jf huyu, jidu-la-mabambasi, katika bandiko lake hili
Juma Nkamia ana tatizo la msingi!

Mkuu Jidu, kwa vile mimi nimefanya kazi na Mhe. Juma Mkamia alipojoin RTD, hivyo naomba nisicomment kuhusu I.Q yake, ila generally kuna uhusiano mkubwa kati ya kiwango cha I.Q na object poverty. Maeneo yenye umasikini uliotopea, I.Q za wengi ziko low!.

Angalia level ya umasikini ukanda wa Pwani, including Zanzibar, mikoa ya Singida, Dodoma, Lindi na Mtwara, au makabila yenye umasikini uliotopea kama Wagogo, Warangi, Wanyaturu, Wabarbaig, Wasandawe, Wataturu, Wahadzabe, Wazaramo, Wandengereko etc, linganisha na mikoa yanye neema, Kilimanjaro, Bukoba, Mbeya, Iringa, Mwanza, etc, angalia I.Q za Wachagga, Wahaya, Wanyakyusa etc, bila kusahau the royal tribe, Wasukuma, watu wanaokula vizuri, wanakuwa na I.Q kubwa. Makabila ya mlo mmoja, wanakuwa na low I.Q!.

Data zangu ni kwa mujibu wa random sampling ya matokeo ya mitihani ya kidato cha 4!. Hili hata Mwalimu Nyerere aliliona, hivyo hadi leo, japo Tanzania nzima wanafanya mtihani mmoja wa darasa la saba lakini cut off points za kufaulu ni tofauti mikoa na mikoa ili Watanzania wote wapate fursa za kuendelea kielimu. Tungetumia uniform cut off points, shule zote za sekondari zingejaa Wachagga, Wahaya na Wanyakysa na kuna makabila wasingegusa secondari!.

Mwalimu Nyerere aliwahi kuwasomesha kwa nguvu watoto 4 wa kabila la Wahadzabe, wote walifeli darasa la saba, lakini akalazimisha waende sekondari kwa lazima. Wakasomea pale Pugu, na wote wanne walipata Divisheni Zero!.

Niliwahi kuuliza swali hili, sikupata jibu
Inawezekana Vipi Zanzibar Hakuna Div I, Div II, wala Div III , Wao ni Div IV na Div Zero Tuu?!.

Ila pia kuna uhusiano kati ya heigh ya mtu na akili zake, mtu akiwa mfupi, anakuwa na akili fupi!' Anza kuwa observe heights za waropokaji bungeni, utaniambia!'
Hili la watu wafupi, nililizungumza hapa, wanafanya vitu vya ajabu kutafuta recognition ili ku compensate inferiority complex yao inayosababishwa na height!.

Je, kuna ukweli watu wafupi wana inferiority complex hivyo kukasirika sana wanapohisi kudharauliwa?

Hili la poverty level na low I.Q lina athari kubwa kisiasa, angalia levels za umasikini kwenye maeneo watu waliochagua upinzani, ulinganishe na ngome za CCM, utakuta kwenye umasikini uliotopea ndizo ngome za CCM, na kule kwenye ehueni, ndio wamewachagua wapinzani, angalia Kilimanjaro, Bukoba, Arusha, Tanga, Iringa, Mbeya etc, mkoa kama Dodoma hauwezi kuchagua upinzani, they are just too poor to understand wanachagua nini!. Hata Singida, Lissu is an exceptional case. Hivyo hii situation ya I.Q level ina effects kwenye siasa zetu, hivyo kuendelea kushinda kwa CCM, has something to do with this na nilisema hapa
Watanzania ni ignorants au tumelogwa? October 25, tutafanya informed decision au tutachagua tuu?

Mtazamo: Kanda ya Kaskazini, CCM imechokwa mpaka basi!

Ikitokea CCM ishinde, Je ushindi huo ni kutokana kuwekeza kwenye Maendeleo au kwenye Ignorance?

Kuichagua tena CCM, Je ni kielelezo cha kufanya informed decision, au ni Ignorance?

Hoja zote hizo zinauhusiano na I.Q, na kitu cha ajabu kabisa, kwa kadri vyuma vinavyobana, ndivyo CCM inavyoimarika, mtashuhudia 2020, karibu majimbo yote ya upinzani kama sio yote kabisa huku bara, yatairejesha CCM, upinzani utaanza tena 2025 baada ya rais Magufuli kuipeleka Tanzania kwenye uchumi wa kati, na kuumaliza umasikini.

NB. Kwenye every general rules, there is always exceptional to the case, hivyo hivyo kuna watu wa makabila masikini wenye high I.Q, na kuna watu wafupi wenye akili ndefu na kuna mijitu mibonge yenye akili fupi and vice versa!.

Paskali
Rejea
Kuwa Kichaa Sio Mpaka Kuokota Makopo!. Jee Tanzania Tuna Vichaa Wengi Kuliko Tunavyojidhania?!.
------------

Mdau field marshall1 amepanua wigo wa mjadala huu. Unaweza kusoma hoja zake na kushiriki mjadala >> Tatizo la ufukara kwa baadhi ya makabila ni mfumo wa maisha (Lifestyles)
Hakika uzi huu unafikirisha hasa ukitilia maanani kuwa mimi ni mtu mfupi.
 
IQ or intelligent Quotient hiki ni kipimo cha Akili MTU anazaliwa nacho hakiongezeki au hakipungui....Wengi hawajaelewa IQ ni nn tuanzie apo.....Ni Kweli IQ ina rithiwa same as km tunavorithi maradhi....Ni kweli jamii Fulani IQ yake ipo juu tofauti na jamii nyingine swala sio mashule sijui yalijengwa na wakoloni No....Chukulia Kagera na hasa Wahaya jamii hii IQ yake ipo juu tofauti na wasubi na wahangaza japo wapo mkoa mmoja na wakolon walijenga mashule pote...Chukulia Jamii ya Waisrael IQ yake ipo juu tofauti na Jamii nyingine ata waziri mkuu wao Netanyau IQ yake ni kubwa sana nadhan ndo anaweza kua anaongeza....Snopp Doggy Doggy alipimwa alikuta ana IQ kubwa sana zaid ya 150 ktk vipimo ila ndo kaishia kwenye mabangi tu....Hivyo IQ sio hizi akili zetu za kukariri Darasan No ni inborn na sometimes inherited
Safi mkuu. Hila muombe radhi snoopy kukosa yy vitu kama murder was the case tungevisikia wapi ?, mkuu kama IQ sio vitu vya kukariri darasa umejuaje kama wahaya wana IQ kubwa kuliko wengine?
 
Jmushi;

We have to dispel the myth. If you want to use IQ concept, please know what it entails and how to use.
The problem I am having here is some individuals here want to make a point using the IQ concept, but when you ask them to provide the average IQ score for each community in question, they don't have any data. What's worse, they don't have their own IQ score. My question is how you are going to make a compelling argument and try to put other people down when you don't have the fact?

For examples, when we say the GDP of Kenya is higher than that of Tanzania, we have the number to support it. When we say the economy of Tanzania grows by 7% annually, we the number to back up our claim. The number might not exactly represents the facts on the ground, but conceptually it's close to the reality.

On the contrary, when it comes to the IQ concept and how is applied in this debate, the only memorable thing we have is banana. For records, monkeys in captivity eat more banana than their brothers and sisters in the wildness. If we have to agree on everything brought forward here, one day without any reasoning we will say monkeys in the captivity are smarter because they eat more banana.
You’re stuck on bananas, so you went bananas
 
You’re stuck on bananas, so you went bananas

Let me help. Here are my simple questions:

  • What is youre IQ score or What is Pascal Mayalla IQ score?
  • What's the sample average IQ score of each of the following tribe: Chagga, Haya, Nyakyusa, Sukuma, Gogo, Zaramo, Makonde
 
Out of topic.

Sir, how is that out of topic when the entire thread is about IQ comparison? How can you associate the environmental factors with the average low or high IQ score of a particular region when you don't have IQ data set to make an argument?
 
Let me help. Here are my simple questions:

  • What is youre IQ score or What is Pascal Mayalla IQ score?
  • What's the sample average IQ score of each of the following tribe: Chagga, Haya, Nyakyusa, Sukuma, Gogo, Zaramo, Makonde
Mkuu stick on the argument on a healthy "lishe" and its effect on brain development , especially in the young.
You might just see the point.
 
Mkuu stick on the argument on a healthy "lishe" and its effect on brain development , especially in the young.
You might just see the point.

Let me help you. Below is the title of this thread. Frankly speaking, "healthy "Lishe" and its effect on brain development isn't the topic at hand.

Je, kuna uhusiano kati ya IQ ya mtu na kabila lake, umasikini wake au kimo chake?
 
Let me help. Here are my simple questions:

  • What is youre IQ score or What is Pascal Mayalla IQ score?
  • What's the sample average IQ score of each of the following tribe: Chagga, Haya, Nyakyusa, Sukuma, Gogo, Zaramo, Makonde
Mkuu stick on the argument on a healthy "lishe" and its effect on brain development , especially in the young.
You might just see the point.
Let me help you. Below is the title of this thread. Frankly speaking, "healthy "Lishe" and its effect on brain development isn't the topic at hand.

Je, kuna uhusiano kati ya IQ ya mtu na kabila lake, umasikini wake au kimo chake?
Hili la kabila is a secondary issue.
Prove the first primary issue and the rest falls into place.
 
Back
Top Bottom