Msikilize Mzungu akitoa sababu za Sub-Saharan Africa kuwa Masikini

[longi mapexa]

Humjui hata Yuval noah harari.
historia ipi unasoma?

✌

 

[love life live life]

Huyo jamaa msamehe tu

Naona unakuja na id yako nyingine leta fact acha porojo.

 

[love life live life]

✌

Next time uje na fact sio habari za kuokoteza..
Ulete na reference ya unachokija sio kusema mwanzo wa historia ni 3100 bc.

 

[Lavit]

Kama kuna wa kulaumiwa basi mzungu anapaswa kuwa mtu wa mwisho kabisa

Sent using Jamii Forums mobile app

 

[pye Chang shen]

Wazungu si watu wazuri

 

[ujoka]

Shida ya Africa ni African leaders wazungu tuna wa tumia kama scapegoat tu, to hide our weakness

Hao viongoz wabovu ndio babylons pappets akienda tofauti na matakwa ya wakulungwa analala yoooo

 

[Kalunya]

Umasikini wa mtu chanzo ni mtu mwenyewe

 

[Muju4]

Kinachotuumiza ni ubinafsi tuu ya baadhi ya tunaowapa mamlaka kwao ni familia zao nchi baadae, lakini kama kweli tunahitaji kusonga mbele ni muhimu kuukata huu mnyororo wa kinyonyaji tuwe na win win situation.

 

[longi mapexa]

Usihamishe magoli bhana...
before 3100bc hamna historia?
Naomba reference zako unazocopy na kupaste.

Scholars now recognize that writing may have independently developed in at least four ancient civilizations: Mesopotamia (between 3400 and 3100 BCE), Egypt (around 3250 BCE),[6][7][3] China (1200 BCE),[8] and lowland areas of Southern Mexico and Guatemala (by 500 BCE).[9]

Ref:Brian M. Fagan, Charlotte Beck, ed. (1996). The Oxford Companion to Archaeology. Oxford University Press. p. 762. ISBN 978-0-19-507618-9

 

[longi mapexa]

Tuwekane sawa kwanza umesema umerudi historia ilipoanzia..
Umemnukuu nan aliyesema historia imeanzia 3100bc na reference ip?
Bado sijajiridhisha kama wewe sio form five kweli.

The Sumerian archaic (pre-cuneiform) writing and Egyptian hieroglyphs are generally considered the earliest true writing systems, both emerging out of their ancestral proto-literate symbol systems from 3400–3100 BCE, with earliest coherent texts from about 2600 BCE. The Proto-Elamite script is also dated to the same approximate period

Ref:Walker, .C. (1989). Reading The Past Cuneiform. British Museum. pp. 7

 

[Abuu Said]

Hii dhana wa Africa kuwa masikini imekaa kimkakati sijaelewa kwa nn tunashindwa kuinuka jibu ndio hilo tumekaliwa tusiinuke kwa masilahi ya Westerns

 

[Mwanamkiwi]

Mugabe alipoingia mara ya kkwanza uraisi media zao zilimpigia upatu ni reformer huku watu wake wakimuona ni msalit.
Alipoanza kuwafukuza kwenye umiliki wa ardhi ambayo More than 90% waliimiliki, ukawa mwanzo wa ugomvi na vikwazo
kutoka western.

Si mtindo wake ulikuwa bovu? Zimbabwe walikuwa wapi kabla ya mwaka 2000, sasa wako wapi?

 

[Abuu Said]

Hiyo Row uliyotumia sio sahihi bali ni Raw.....
Kwa mada nikijikita sasa...nina swali kwako.
Kwa siasa hizi za Tanzania na taasisi zetu nyeti unaona ziko kwaajili ya kufanya maendeleo? Kabla ya kumuhusisha mzungu.
Fact; Mzungu kaingia Africa karne za hivi karibuni tukwa harakaharaka ni tangu ya 15 ukiondoa hii miaka 500 ya Mzungu Africa ilikuwa na nini kuwalinganisha na hao Wazungu wq kipindi hicho.

Huko nyuma sisi tulikua tunajiweza kwa kila kitu tulikua na mahitaji yote na tungeweza kuwauzia wao wazungu ika kutokana na uzwazwa wetu walitulaghai na kutupora kwa njia ya kututawala

 

[longi mapexa]

Umesema historia imeanza 3100bc...
Naomba reference yako kitabu kinaitwaje ulichosoma na ukurasa.

Now why nilisema hivyo ni kwa sababu wajuzi wa maswala haya tunasema Katika kuichunguza past ya binadamu utagawa kwa vipindi viwili Pre History na History ambapo atleast kama nakumbuka vyema 99%ni pre history while only 1% ni History.

Kwasababu Pre history inakwenda beyond writing era Huku history ikiwa in Writing era atleast 5000 years.

Nikakuonyesha mfano wa Sumerians kama ancient civilisation kwa hapo Datings zangu zinakwenda 3100BC beyond hapo ni pre history ambapo itabidi tushift tutoke History mpaka Archaeology....Nenda UDSM Pale huone kwamba ni Two depertments Ingia Library ya Mchina pale uone vitabu vya archaeology vipo mtaa gani na History wapi Jitahidi sana Kutafuta Maarifa.
Now nikupe desa kidogo mzee.
👇👇👇👇
Scholars make a reasonable distinction between prehistory and history of early writing[21] but have disagreed concerning when prehistory becomes history and when proto-writing became "true writing." The definition is largely subjective


Ref;Smail, Daniel Lord. On Deep History and the Brain. An Ahmanson foundation book in the humanities. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2008.

 

[Abuu Said]

Shida ya Africa ni African leaders wazungu tuna wa tumia kama scapegoat tu, to hide our weakness

African leaders ni vibaraka wa wazungu ukijifanya mjuaji wanakula kichwa kutetea maslahi yao

 

[longi mapexa]

Huko nyuma sisi tulikua tunajiweza kwa kila kitu tulikua na mahitaji yote na tungeweza kuwauzia wao wazungu ika kutokana na uzwazwa wetu walitulaghai na kutupora kwa njia ya kututawala

Samahani mkuu biashara zote tumefanya na wazungu zilikua na uhalali kabisa kutoka kwetu hatukuibiwa....Hatuna Sugar...lakini tuna ndovu tukakubali kuweka value ya ndovu kwa sugar kulingana na uhitaji....Tukasign mikataba mpaka leo.

 

[Abuu Said]

Hao leaders kama Muamari Gadafi, Lumumba, Sankara huwa wanaishia wapi zaidi ya kupigwa risasi
wakianza kufanya hizo reforms?
Ni waafrica wote tuna matatizo sio leaders kwa sababu hao leaders wanazalishwa na jamii
ambayo ni ya hovyo huwezi pata viongozi bora na mzungu anatumia hiyo kama karata yake.

Isitoshe Cylubus katika masomo yetu wametunga wao wao ndio wanawalisha viongozi wetu matango pori

 

[longi mapexa]

Next time uje na fact sio habari za kuokoteza..
Ulete na reference ya unachokija sio kusema mwanzo wa historia ni 3100 bc.

We mjinga nimekujibu tayari na mpaka pages ulizotaka na nakukumbusha tena umeamua kuingia Katika historical field ni too deep jitahidi kujisomea.....So far hujanijibu chochote katika niliyokuuliza sasa nikikutaka ujibu na unipe ref utajiweza kweli? Ama utawalalamikia wazingu pia.

Sasa Nakupa homework
👇👇👇
Historians mark the "historicity" of a culture by the presence of coherent texts in the culture's writing system(s).

Ref; Shotwell, James Thomson. An Introduction to the History of History. Records of civilization, sources and studies. New York: Columbia University Press, 1922.

NB; Ujinga Sio tusi Ni Hali.

 

[Manelezu]

Hii dhana wa Africa kuwa masikini imekaa kimkakati sijaelewa kwa nn tunashindwa kuinuka jibu ndio hilo tumekaliwa tusiinuke kwa masilahi ya Westerns

Umesoma historia ya tiger countries? Kati ya historia Huwa zinani sisimua ni ya Singapore, usilaumu wazungu, viongozi wetu wengi ni ma Puppet wa wazungu na wameamua kuwa hivyo, hawajalazimishwa, why blame a white man? Nchi kibao Asia huko in 1960s zilikuwa masikini, mbona zimeinuka kiuchumi? Tuna viongozi wa ajabu sana...wanaona ufahali kupiga picha na wazungu kukaa na wazungu, kwenda ulaya lakini hawana mikakati ya kututoa hapa.
Wanajiona wana belong zaidi na wazungu, lakini siku zote mzungu hawezi heshimu mtu mjinga, wanatumia ila moyoni they know we are stupid and foolish. They just use us as they want.

 

[love life live life]

Scholars now recognize that writing may have independently developed in at least four ancient civilizations: Mesopotamia (between 3400 and 3100 BCE), Egypt (around 3250 BCE),[6][7][3] China (1200 BCE),[8] and lowland areas of Southern Mexico and Guatemala (by 500 BCE).[9]

Ref:Brian M. Fagan, Charlotte Beck, ed. (1996). The Oxford Companion to Archaeology. Oxford University Press. p. 762. ISBN 978-0-19-507618-9

Mbona sioni mahali wanaposema historia imeanza mwaka 3100bc?