Special Thread: Yanayojiri Mgogoro wa Ukraine na Urusi. Nini chanzo na hatma ya mzozo?

Kwa hiyo unataka kusema hypersonic missiles ni nadharia tu lkn kwenye uhalisia haiwezekani!?

Hebu funguka kdg mkuu ututoe tongotongo
Context.
First thing first ICBM zote zinatembea kwa Speed ya Hypersonic but they can not maneuver kama cruise missiles so it is possible to detect their trajectory.

Kwa sasa kuna aina mbili za hypersonic cruise missile ambazo zinameet criteria ya hapo juu (Hard to intercept) ambazo ni hypersonic boost-glide weapons, and scramjet-powered hypersonic cruise missiles. China na Russia wao wanasema zao zinatumia HBGV

Hypersonic Boost Glide Vehicles hizi hazina kabisa tofauti na Warheads za kawaida zilizoweka kwenye ICBM katika hatua za mwanzo za kuruka kwake, hizi zenyewe inabidi zibebwe na ndege vita into very high atmosphere ili zipate high velocity (inaweza fika hadi mach 20), In theory ukiichukua iskander ukaboost velocity yake inakuwa hypersonic.

1. Maintaining high temperature due to kinetic energy
Hili Cruise Hypersonic Missiles ziwe na maneuverability kama cruise zilizopo zinahitaji extra components ndani yake kuwezesha hili, but due to high Kinetic Energy they move with, inasababisha thermal energy (heat) kwenye kwenye air molecules around the glide vehicle, hii heat inatosha kabisa kuharibu surface ya missile na components za ndani, ili kusolve hili inahitaji very resistant material to heat (hii ni expensive and we don't have cheap technology yet).

2. Hypersonic Missile hazifanyi kitu ambacho missile za kawaida haziwezi.
Hapa ni swala la cost na efficiency.

Hata kama S-300 ikiwa ni good interceptor utahitaji kurusha makombora mengi kuliko inayoweza kuzuia kwa pamoja, mfano 100/10

In this case unaweza kutumia cruise missile 100 badala ya hypersonic ambayo cost yake moja inaweza ikawa ni zaidi ya cruise missile mia, ndio maana Russia alitumia akaacha.

3. Not all hypersonic missile provide advantage they claim to.
Mfano Hypersonic missile inayobeba Nuclear, imagine unazo ICBM ambazo haziwezi kuzuiliwa bado unataka tena uzibebe kwenye Hypersonic missile.
 
Hypersonic missiles zimetumika na dunia nzima imeshuhudia leo wewe unasema by laws of physics hazimake sense? Au kwa sababu majaribio ya hypersonic za US zilikua zinafeli hivyo hutaki kukubali kwamba zipo na zinawork?

Kusema kwamba hypersonic missiles ni ICBM iliyowekwa kwenye ndege?? Binafsi sijawahi kuona ICBM inafungwa kwenye ndege hii itakua taarifa mpya kwangu nitaenda kutafuta nione ICBM na ukubwa wake ule ifungwe kwenye ndege ili itumike kama hypersonic.

Zaidi nenda kapitie taarifa za hypersonic What to know about Russia's hypersonic missiles
 
Kuhusu Hypersonic missiles, by laws of Physics silaha za Hypersonic bado hazimake sense, due to current technology in material physics, hata Russia silaha walizotumia Ukraine ni trial.

Kama trials zote ambazo pentagon wanakadiria kuwa 10-12 zimehit target perfectly tafsiri yake ni kwamba trials zimefanikiwa kwa 100%.
 
Nikumbushe Jambo. Kizhal ilipata sehemu ya kujaribiwa TU na bila shaka hazipo nyingi hata zikiwepo zinasubiri potential adversary na hata hivyo zitatumika zikiwa na nuclear war heard.
Kwenye bombers zenye uwezo wa kurusha missiles km 7000 Ni kwajili ya makombora ya nuclear na si conventional missiles.
 
Haya maelezo yanachanganya. Ulikuwa unajaribu kuelezea namna ambavyo Hypersonic missiles hazimake sense according to laws of physics km ulivyosema mwanzo au ulikuwa unaelezea cost efficient ya Hypersonic missiles!?
 
Ukweli ni kuwa anatafuta fanya revenge kwa kilichotokea juzi
 
Wagner Group wanasajili wafungwa waliomaliza vifungo toka Africa kwenda kupigana Ukraine.Hapo ndipo Akili ya Urusi ilipofikia 🤔
.......
 
Sasa shida ipo wapi hapo.wagner ni kundi la kukodi kwa iyo yoyote yule hana haki ya kujiunga.sasa sijaelewa point yako ni nini
 
Kwa taarifa yako, just for your information, hii ni kwa Elimu tu

Kuna Hypersonic Boost Glide Vehicles and scramjet based, Russia wanatumia HBGV which is technically a modified Iskander missile, also soma Avangard.

Hivi za Russia na China ni deterrent weapons tu, kuonesha they can strike with Nuclear very fast.

All Russia, China na USA wanafanya researchers za Scramjet and there is no any country ina Hypersonic missiles zinazotumia Scramjet zilizo operational.
 
Haya maelezo yanachanganya. Ulikuwa unajaribu kuelezea namna ambavyo Hypersonic missiles hazimake sense according to laws of physics km ulivyosema mwanzo au ulikuwa unaelezea cost efficient ya Hypersonic missiles!?
cost of materials to make them move very fast, bila kuungua.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…