Thomas Sowell: Jinsi Ujamaa wa Nyerere ulivyoiharibu Tanzania

[JUA ni Kali Sana]

Premature entrance to socialism was one of the worst failure of Nyerere regime

Kwa msiomjua, Thomas Sowell ni mchumi, mwanahistoria, mwandishi, mkufunzi mwandamizi katika Taasisi ya Hoover nchini Marekani,na kadhalika.

Sowell ni mzaliwa wa Gastonia, NC.

Kwenye hii video, anaizungumzia Tanzania na sera yake ya Ujamaa chini ya Rais Nyerere.

Isikilize/ iangalie halafu tuambie ni wapi kakosea.

I think he is spot on!


View: https://youtu.be/H-tUQmXQ-xk?si=UryuPvS5grgzt_rr

 

[Intelligent businessman]

It was indeed the economic policy of socialism which killed Nyerere reputation to western, and they made him look bad and chosen Kenya, which infact adopted Capitalism from its inception.

Kosa la Nyerere nadhan ni kutumia resources za Tanzania kujaribu kutengeneza superiority ya Tanzania kwa nchi nyingi za SADC ambazo bado zilikuwa kwenye independence struggle...

He failed economically to the western view point, lakini alifanikiwa kutengeneza Reputation ya Tanzania na Watanzania kwa mataifa mengi Africa, offcourse with costs.

Tanzania trusted ally now wapo SADC wengi kuliko EAC.. because of him.

Nafikiri aliamini akiondoka Economics zinaweza tengenezwa na his successor.. and Mkapa Proved somehow , JPM too.

Issues za Kilimo na Railyway we are doing that bad, but as personal weaknesses hakuwa anapenda wajuaji, kwakuwa alijua gharama ya kuzungukwa na wajuaji kama kina Kambona...😂

Thanks.

ali waweka rumande baadhi ya matajiri, babu yetu akiwemo😂🤣

 

[Fortilo]

ali waweka rumande baadhi ya matajiri, babu yetu akiwemo😂🤣

Alijua watamsumbua..

Alikuwa mjamaa kweli kweli, lakini kuendesha nchi changa kama hii yenye watu milion karibu kumi kipindi hicho na wasomi hawafiki 200.. haikuwa rahisi

 

[Intelligent businessman]

Alijua watamsumbua..

Alikuwa mjamaa kweli kweli, lakini kuendesha nchi changa kama hii yenye watu milion karibu kumi kipindi hicho na wasomi hawafiki 200.. haikuwa rahisi

Shida historia ime wekwa kijamaa, Kuna watu hawaja pewa heshima walio stahili.

kina Sykes wame saidia Sana, Kuna watu wa tabora pia.

 

[The Assassin]

Lawama kwa nyerere zinasaidia nini kipindi hiki

Baada ya miaka 40 ya Nyerere kustaafu. Ni hoja mfu. Halafu hoja kwamba ujamaa umeiharibia Tanzania, ukilinganisha na nchi ambazo hazikua na ujamaa mbona hakuna tofauti?

 

[Yoda]

It was indeed the economic policy of socialism which killed Nyerere reputation to western, and they made him look bad and chosen Kenya, which infact adopted Capitalism from its inception.

Kosa la Nyerere nadhan ni kutumia resources za Tanzania kujaribu kutengeneza superiority ya Tanzania kwa nchi nyingi za SADC ambazo bado zilikuwa kwenye independence struggle...

He failed economically to the western view point, lakini alifanikiwa kutengeneza Reputation ya Tanzania na Watanzania kwa mataifa mengi Africa, offcourse with costs.

Tanzania trusted ally now wapo SADC wengi kuliko EAC.. because of him.

Nafikiri aliamini akiondoka Economics zinaweza tengenezwa na his successor.. and Mkapa Proved somehow , JPM too.

Issues za Kilimo na Railyway we are doing somewhat good compared to our counterparts... Now we are leading in Africa Maize Production... According to data.

Almost 30 p ya GDP ya TZ sasa ni kilimo, up from less than 20% back then...

Generally Nyerere wasn't that bad, but as personal weaknesses hakuwa anapenda wajuaji, kwakuwa alijua gharama ya kuzungukwa na wajuaji kama kina Kambona...😂

Thanks.

Tanzania ni kubwa karibia mara mbili ya Kenya, ina rasilimali nyingi zaidi ya Kenya na ardhi kubwa ya kilimo kuliko Kenya.

 

[Lecheminduroi2]

Lawama kwa nyerere zinasaidia nini kipindi hiki

Zao la ujamaa, unadhani nyumba inaanza kujengwa roof kabla ya foundation?

 

[Lecheminduroi2]

Kwa hiyo sasa unataka kuwapongeza waliouza bandari?

Hao ndio zao la siasa za familia yako, nyie ndio mmetuharibia nchi

 

[Rorscharch]

Malengo yalikuwa mazuri ila matokeo yakaja ndivyo sivyo
Ingawa maendeleo aliyokua anayapigania Mzee Nyerere na Hali ilivyo kwa nchi zilizoiga ubepari toka mwanzo hata hatutofautiani sana, South Africa hiyo hapo mbona nao wamefeli tu

 

[eliakeem]

Tanzania ni kubwa karibia mara mbili ya Kenya, ina rasilimali nyingi zaidi ya Kenya na ardhi kubwa ya kilimo kuliko Kenya.

Kenya ndiyo unapenda kuitumia kama baseline? Nilidhani ungelinganisha between two time lines

 

[Al-mukheef]

Nimezaliwa wakati President Mkapa ni Raisi, hivyo siwezi nikasema nina jua yaliyojiri wakati wa Urais wa Nyerere.

But, kutoka hadithi za Babu na Babaangu, na kutoka vitabuni n.k. Nyerere was the Greatest, still the greatest amongst African and World leaders alike Today.

His intellect and vision were unmatched then and still unmatched Today.

Hata hivyo sihitaji mzungu aje kuniambia mazuri au mabaya yake.

Ushahidi upo wazi leo hii.

Watanzania wanajitambua.

Bado hujasema

 

[Yoda]

Malengo yalikuwa mazuri ila matokeo yakaja ndivyo sivyo
Ingawa maendeleo aliyokua anayapigania Mzee Nyerere na Hali ilivyo kwa nchi zilizoiga ubepari toka mwanzo hata hatutofautiani sana, South Africa hiyo hapo mbona nao wamefeli tu

Nchi zina sababu zao za kufeli kulingana na muktadha mbalimbali na matatizo waliyokuwa nayo.

 

[Fortilo]

Tanzania ni kubwa karibia mara mbili ya Kenya, ina rasilimali nyingi zaidi ya Kenya na ardhi kubwa ya kilimo kuliko Kenya.

Upo Sawa mkuu,

Lakini ukubwa wa nchi na resources sio hoja, Mindset za viongoz wake ndio kila kitu...

Kama mindset hazipo sawasawa kuendelea ni ndoto ..

Miaka 40 baada ya Nyerere kutoka madarakani kuendelea kumlaumu sio kumtendea haki ..

Mambo mengine tunakosea wenyewe .

Wapo watu hawastahili kabisa kupewa uongozi, lakini tujiulize nani anawafanyia vetting?

Wananchi wanawapigia tu kura bila kujali...

Huko Upinzani ndio balaa tupu.

 

[Fortilo]

Shida historia ime wekwa kijamaa, Kuna watu hawaja pewa heshima walio stahili.

kina Sykes wame saidia Sana, Kuna watu wa tabora pia.

Mkuu wanasiasa wa Tanzania Nyerere aliwajua kitambo sana...

Angalia kina Msigwa, Dr. Slaa, Lema, Covid?

Unadhani anaeandika historia ya Upinzani asipowataja atakuwa kakosea mahali?

 

[Nkaburu]

Bado hujasema

✋️🗑🚮

 

[Nanren]

Wazungu wa west siku zote wamekuwa wakidemonize socialism na communism. There is no way watasifia ujamaa au kumsifia kiongozi wa kijamaa. Chuki za kiitikadi zipo deeply ingrained ni kama ambayo hamas hawezi kusifia chochote cha yahud au shabiki mnazi wa simba asivyoweza kuisifia Yanga.
Ni wazungu hao ndio ambao wamekuwa wakitoa skolaship kwa baadhi yetu kwenda kusoma kwenye vitabu vyao, vyuo vyao, kufundishwa na hao wazungu, na tunakuwa indoctrinated kuwa ujamaa ni mbaya na Nyerere was bad.

Kuna nchi jirani kadhaa, ambazo hazikufuata ujamaa wala hazikuwa na mtu kama Nyerere, ZIKO WAPI KIUCHUMI?

Na toka Nyerere kaondoka, tuko wapi kiuchumi?

 

[John Wickzer Mulholland]

Malengo yalikuwa mazuri ila matokeo yakaja ndivyo sivyo
Ingawa maendeleo aliyokua anayapigania Mzee Nyerere na Hali ilivyo kwa nchi zilizoiga ubepari toka mwanzo hata hatutofautiani sana, South Africa hiyo hapo mbona nao wamefeli tu

South Africa hakuna Siasa za Ujamaa wala Ukomunisti. South Africa ni full Ubepari.
Je, hao South Africa wamefeli nini?

 

[saiko]

Kqa

It was indeed the economic policy of socialism which killed Nyerere reputation to western, and they made him look bad and chosen Kenya, which infact adopted Capitalism from its inception.

Kosa la Nyerere nadhan ni kutumia resources za Tanzania kujaribu kutengeneza superiority ya Tanzania kwa nchi nyingi za SADC ambazo bado zilikuwa kwenye independence struggle...

He failed economically to the western view point, lakini alifanikiwa kutengeneza Reputation ya Tanzania na Watanzania kwa mataifa mengi Africa, offcourse with costs.

Tanzania trusted ally now wapo SADC wengi kuliko EAC.. because of him.

Nafikiri aliamini akiondoka Economics zinaweza tengenezwa na his successor.. and Mkapa Proved somehow , JPM too.

Issues za Kilimo na Railyway we are doing somewhat good compared to our counterparts... Now we are leading in Africa Maize Production... According to data.

Almost 30 p ya GDP ya TZ sasa ni kilimo, up from less than 20% back then...

Generally Nyerere wasn't that bad, but as personal weaknesses hakuwa anapenda wajuaji, kwakuwa alijua gharama ya kuzungukwa na wajuaji kama kina Kambona...😂

Thanks.

Hyo successor wa nyerere ni mkapa na na magufuli ambae hata kujua kama atakua raisi hakushuhudia hv unaupofu au unamalengo yako jee nyerere alipokelewa uraisi na mkapa than akampasia magufuli hii ni historia au maharage ya wapi au ni sucseer wa kigangoni hebu weka wazi

 

[The Assassin]

Zao la ujamaa, unadhani nyumba inaanza kujengwa roof kabla ya foundation?

Miaka 40 yote bado unalalamikia msingi? Mipango miji mibovu analalamikiwa Nyerere wakati yeye mini yake ameacha imepangiliwa, barabara mbovu analaumiwa Nyerere, rais kua na msafara wa magari 120 kwenye ziara yake lawama ni kwa Nyerere, ufisadi mkubwa lawama ni Nyerere, elimu mbovu lawama ni Nyerere, huduma mbovu za afya lawa ni Nyerere, mtu akishindwa kumpa mkewe mimba lawama ni Nyerere, mwanaume akishindwa kusimamisha lawama ni Nyerere, uchawa lawama ni Nyerere.

Tunakoelekea hata mtu akila chakula kichafu akaharisha lawama zitaenda kwa Nyerere, mtu akikosa choo lawama zitaenda kwa Nyerere, mtu akinywa sumu akaua figo zake na maini lawama zitaenda kwa Nyerere, mtu akigongwa na gari barabarani lawama zitaenda kwa Nyerere. Hii nchi imejaa watu wa hovyo sana.

 

[Al-mukheef]

✋️🗑🚮

.....