Kama mnadhani Zitto anadanganya, moja ya vipengele alivyoelezea hapo juu document inasema:-
B: in the event that the dispute is not resolved through negotiation within 30 days, the parties may refer the dispute to conciliation in accordance with the UNCITRAL Conciliation Rules. The conciliator will be independent of the parties, and will not be a national of Tanzania, the United Kingdom, Canada or the United States. If a conciliator is not appointed within 14 days of acceptance of a request for conciliation, the President of the Singapore International Arbitration Centre will appoint the conciliator. A conciliator can make proposals to the parties as to how they might resolve any dispute, but cannot make any binding decision. To resolve a dispute through conciliation the parties would have to reach an agreement, recorded in a binding agreement; and
C: Upon issuance of a notice of arbitration commencing the arbitration, the parties shall seek to mutually agree on the arbitral seat or legal place of arbitration. The seat shall be in a jurisdiction which is internationally recognized and experienced in handling complex international commercial arbitration (not being Tanzania, a state which is a member of the East African Community, the UK, Canada or the United States) and is a party to the New York Convention of the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, 1958.
Maelezo hayo yapo kwenye kipengele cha Dispute Resolution! Mnaona hapo ni namna gani endapo itatokea kushindwa ku-solve any dispute, basi issue itapelekwa mbele in accordance to UNCITRAL Conciliation Rules, na sisi, of course, citizens of arguing parties hawatakuwepo kwenye team!
Sasa kama tunatarajia huko mbele watu wata-resolve issues kwa kuzitangatia maslahi yetu basi tuna safari ndefu!
Kuhusu 16% ya shares zetu kuwa Class B Shares, makubaliano yanasema:-
New OpCo will be owned 84%/16% by a subsidiary of the Acacia Group and a nominee of the GoT respectively. Acacia will hold its shares in New OpCo as Class A shares and the GoT will hold by way of Class B shares.
Haki za Class A and Class B Shareholders zimeelezewa kwenye Shareholders Agreement, lakini Zitto aliposema kwamba hizo shares zetu huwezi kuziweka hata kuwa dhamana ni kutokana na kipengele kinachosema:-
(i) Class B shares may only be issued to, held by or transferred to the GoT shareholder and may not be pledged, charged or otherwise disposed of (whereas the Class A shares are transferable to: (a) a financial institution by way of a pledge to secure bona fide debt; (b) an affiliate (with GoT shareholder consent, not to be unreasonably withheld); or (c) a third party (subject to the GoT shareholder’s right of first refusal and with Government consent, not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed), provided, in each case, the transferee enters into a deed of adherence);
(ii) regardless of the number of Class B shares in issue, the Class B shares will at all times be deemed to represent 16% of the shares holding voting and economic rights in the TMC (being collectively, the Class A shares and the Class B shares);
(iii) a holder of Class B shares will not have any pre-emption rights over any allotment of new Class A shares and its proportionate interest will not be affected by such allotment (whereas a holder of Class A shares has pre-emption rights over any allotment of new Class A shares); and (iv) the holder of Class A shares will elect from amongst the directors appointed by them, a chairman of the board of the TMC (whereas a holder of Class B shares has no such right).
Suala la kwamba lile sharti la Tanzania kumiliki 30% akina Kabudi na Magu wameliuza kwa Wazungu, makubaliano yanasema:-
the GoT will not unilaterally seek to increase its share ownership or economic participation rights in the TMCs;
Kwahiyo hiyo 16% itaendelea kubaki hivyo hivyo! Vipi kuhusu suala la kusafirisha madini nje? Makubaliano haya hapa:-
the TMCs will have the unfettered right to export minerals (including doré and concentrates) until refining (in the case of doré) and smelting (in the case of concentrates) are available in Tanzania and the GoT will provide assistance so all required authorisations and/or waivers be granted to theTMCs so as to facilitate export of doré and concentrates;
Kumbe wanayo unfettered rights ya kusafisrisha madini na makinikia nje ya nchi hadi pale tutakapokuwa na uwezo wa kufanya refining and smelting ndani ya nchi!
Kama ndivyo, kwanini basi tusiwalazimishe hawa Barrick wajenge mtambo wa kuchenjua makinikia hapa hapa Bongo ili wasiendelee kutupiga changa kwa kusafirisha makinikia nje ya nchi?! Makubaliano yanatoa jibu kwa hilo swali, kwamba:-
there will be no obligation on the TMCs to construct beneficiation facilities in country;
Aidha hapa tukumbuke kwamba, JPM alinukuliwa akiongea na Maswahiba zake, including Steven Makigo kwa kusema kwamba, uchenjuaji wa makinikia sio kazi kivile; it's a matter of building a furnace na kuongeza boiling point of so and so, kitu na box! Sasa nadhani ni wakati wa JPM kuitumia kemia yake kuongeza hiyo B.P ya Copper Concentrates ili iyeyuka mapema ili tubaki na dhahabu yetu!
Yaani hapa mtu akihoji PhD ya Mkulu, ndo basi tena yanakukuta ya Ben!!!!!!