Maswali kwa Profesa Musa Assad kuhusu mkataba wa Bandari

Maswali kwa Profesa Musa Assad kuhusu mkataba wa Bandari

Huyu mzee alikuwa mwadilifu enzi za Magufuli, awamu hii naona kakosa ajira kaanza kulegea...
Retired said:
Nimesoma andiko lako kuwa watu HAWANA UELEWA ndiyo maana wanakataa mkataba wa DP World. Nomba kwa manufaa ya wengi ujibu hoja hizi mbili tu. Kumbuka wewe ni "national Figure" in academics, tamko lako linaamsha maswali)

1. Kama mkataba una manufaa , kwanini bandari za Zanzibar hazipo? (kizuri kweli uache kula na ndugu zako Zanzibar, uwape jirani?)

2. Wewe si mwanasheria (unaweza ukawa na uelewa kidogo wa sheria za uhasibu and the like). sasa authority ya kusema akina Shivji, Lugemeleza, Lisu, Mwabukusi, Madeleka na wengine hawana uelewa katika International treaties unaitoa wapi?

3. Mbona hujajibu hoja kwa hoja ambazo hao niliowataja hapo juu wanazilalamikia? Umetoa blanket answers kama za Joseph Kasheku Msukuma, Kitenge, Wasira na watu kama hao. Kama msomi you need to be specific when answering questions...kama ilivyokuwa ukiwataka wanafunzi wako wajibu


Click to expand...
 
Retired said:
search humu utaopata, upo sana JF
Click to expand...
Hakuna huo mkataba HGA humu. Uliosainiwa/unaojadiliwa na uliopo humu ni wa IGA. HGA ni mkataba wa pili unaojadiliwa na utasainiwa baada ya kuidhinishwa kwa IGA.

 
mwengeso said:
Bandari haihuzwi ila JMT inataka kuruhusu uwekezaji kutoka Dubai wa DP World kwa makubaliano, ambayo kwa mtazamo wa Prof Shivji, unampa mwekezaji haki zsidi na JMT wajibu
Click to expand...
Haya maelezo yako hapa ni ya nini tena.
Ni nani anakomalia kuuzwa Bandari, kama huo siyo msemo tu wa mitaani kuashiria masharti mabovu ndani ya mkataba huo?
Kama mkataba hauna kikomo, na una masharti hasi kwa Tanzania, kama hayo uliyoambatanisha wewe hapo; kama

Sasa sijui wewe unaelewa kitu gani hapo?
Hayo aliyosema Prof. Shivji, yanakupa tumaini wewe kuhusu manufaa ya mkataba huo?huko siyo sawa na kuuzwa ni kitu gani?
Tena ni bora ya kuuza, maanake unapata fedha unayojua utapewa, masharti ya mkataba huu ni sawa na kunyang'anywa!
 
Kifaurongo said:
Hakuna huo mkataba HGA humu. Uliosainiwa/unaojadiliwa na uliopo humu ni wa IGA. HGA ni mkataba wa pili unaojadiliwa na utasainiwa baada ya kuidhinishwa kwa IGA.

View attachment 2712938
Click to expand...
Wewe kwa fikra zako unadhani hiyo mikataba ya HGA itakuwa nafuu zaidi ya hii IGA?

Kuwa na IGA kabla ya hizo HGA maana yake ni nini? Siyo kwamba mikataba hiyo ya HGA itaongozwa na makubaliano/mkataba wa IGA?

Na zaidi ya yote, hizo HGAs hutaruhusiwa kuziona, ni siri. Sasa hapo utatueleza kitu gani kuhusu hizo HGAs unazozitegemea wewe?
 
Kalamu said:
Wewe kwa fikra zako unadhani hiyo mikataba ya HGA itakuwa nafuu zaidi ya hii IGA?

Kuwa na IGA kabla ya hizo HGA maana yake ni nini? Siyo kwamba makikataba hiyo ya HGA itaongozwa na makubaliano/mkataba wa IGA?

Na zaidi ya yote, hizo HGAs hutaruhusiwa kuziona, ni siri. Sasa hapo utatueleza kitu gani kuhusu hizo HGAs unazozitegemea wewe?
Click to expand...
Hoja mwanasheria wetu wa ujerumani anatuambia IGA ndio HGA na tumeingia chocho kuaminishwa hivyo. Mikataba yenye usiri ni hatua ya tatu mikataba ya TPA na Mukodishwaji ambayo wambunge wana access nayo wakiihitaji.
 
makwega7 said:
Swali hili kuhusu bandari ya Zanzibar limeshajibiwa mara nyingi tu hapa tena na watu tofauti, lakini bado linarudi tu waulizaji wakihisi wanauliza swali la pointi saaaaana kumbe pumba tu.
Ni hivi bandari ya Zanzibar ilishapata muekezaji kutoka Ufaransa kabla ya DPW, hivyo isingekua rahisi kuvunja mkataba.
Click to expand...
Na hapa unadhani mjuaji ni wewe, au siyo?
Kama maswala ya Bandari ni ya Muungano, uwekezaji huo wa Ufaransa ulishughulikiwa na serikali ya Muungano?
Tena hata hivyo unasema uongo mtupu kuhusu huyo mfaransa kuhusika hapo.
 
Pantosha said:
Nacheka utadhani yanafurahisha. Inasikitisha kuona Professor naye anashindwa kujibu hoja. Njaa hatari sana
Click to expand...
Kuna profesa mwingine alifyatua ufahamu wake akaongea hovyo hovyo akateuliwa siku chache baadaye
 
Dan Zwangendaba said:
Haya siyo maswali ya kujibu Professor Assad. Hata sisi wanafunzi wake tunaweza kukujibu vizuri kabisa.

Jibu kwa swali la Kwanza.
Bandari ya Zanzibar haipo kwasababu muwekezaji hana interest na Bandari hiyo kutokana na Investment Plan yake. Hajaona faida ya kuendeleza Bandari ya Zanzibar huku akijua biashara ipo Rwanda, Zambia, Malawi, DRC, Burundi na mikoa ya mbali. Hiyo mizigo atayoishushia Zanzibar itaenda wapi? Hivi hili nalo linahitaji muende mahakamani nyie wapinga maendeleo.

2. Jibu kwa swali la pili
Japo kuna mgawo wa kitaaluma lakini hakuna ownership of knowledge. Yeyote anaweza kuelewa chochote.

3. Jibu kwa swali la tatu
Hakuna hoja ya maana ndio maana professor Asad hakuna haja ya kujibu upotofu. By the way, hoja zenyewe zimekuwa zikibadilika siku hata siku na kutokana na mtu na mtu. Wako wanaosema mkataba, wako wanaosema mgeni asipewe nafasi ya kufanya uwekezaji katika Bandari, wako wanaosema watanzania tuna uwezo, mitaji na teknolojia. Yaani vurugu mechi.
Professor Asad amekuwa smart kwa kugusia upotoshaji unaofanywa kwenye maeneo machache hususan umiliki na matumizi ya ardhi.
Click to expand...
Tatizo uislamu unawasumbua kwenye mkataba huu sijaona mwislamu anaupinga there something hidden
 
Lupweko said:
Acha kutembelea nyota ya member mwenzako, jitegemee. Yaani mwekezaji asilazimishwe kwa jambo la maslahi la taifa? Kwa hiyo asilazimishwe kuajiri baadhi ya wafanyakazi wazawa kwa kazi wanazoziweza, hata akiamua kuja na vibarua waarabu iwe sawa tu?
Click to expand...
Hayo tunatakiwa tuyaseme kwenye hii mikataba ya kibiashara, huko bungeni hayahusiki.
 
Kifaurongo said:
Hoja mwanasheria wetu wa ujerumani anatuambia IGA ndio HGA na tumeingia chocho kuaminishwa hivyo. Mikataba yenye usiri ni hatua ya tatu mikataba ya TPA na Mukodishwaji ambayo wambunge wana access nayo wakiihitaji.
Click to expand...
Wewe unamjua huyo "mwanasheria wenu wa Ujerumani", mimi simjui, kwa hiyo usinihusishe na hilo.
Hizo hatua 4 zilizoonyeshwa hapo kama kuelimisha ni upuuzi mtupu.
Elezeni, IGA inahusika vipi na hizo IGA na hizo hatua za upotoshaji mnazofanya hapo?

Kama mnaona IGA haina maana kwenu, iondoeni, tuendelee na hizo HGA, tupigiwe huko huko.
 
Kalamu said:
Hapana.
Katika jambo hili inaonekana wazi kwamba ni zaidi ya "njaa" inayowasukuma baadhi ya watu kufunga akili zao upande fulani.
Hili lipo wazi tokea mwanzo, na lipo kwa muda mrefu.
Kwa baadhi ya watu, ukiweka kwenye mizani na kupima uTanzania wao na dini zao wanazoziamini wao, dini zinakuwa ni kila kitu kwao, na kusahau kwamba Tanzania ipo siyo kwa manufaa ya dini yoyote bali kwa waTanzania wote.

Kama ni mungu wanayemwamini ndiye aliyeiweka hapo Tanzania na kuwaweka wengine wote waliomo humo na kuwapenda, wao hilo hawalioni kabisa.

Huu ni upumbavu mkubwa sana, bila kujali kiwango cha usomi alionao mhusika.
Click to expand...
Prof Assad huyu huyu mliyemuonea huruma alipopigwa chini na hayati JPM leo hii mnamshutumu baada ya kusimamia weledi!. Kazi ipo.
 
Retired said:

DP World wins latest judgement in Hong Kong Court over Djibouti concession​


Dubai, UAE,
20 September 2022


DP World has won the latest in a string of court rulings, as it defends its rights as shareholder and concessionaire in Djibouti’s Doraleh Container Terminal.

The Court of Appeal of Hong Kong has dismissed the latest request by China Merchants Port Holdings seeking permission to file a second appeal before the Court of Final Appeal, against its previous decision that DP World’s suit against the company should be heard before Hong Kong Courts, and not the courts of Djibouti.

DP World and joint venture company Doraleh Container Terminal are bringing multi-billion dollar claims against China Merchants alleging that it induced the government of Djibouti to expel DP World from the country and hand over the Doraleh terminal to China Merchants. China Merchants investments in other ports and free zone projects in Djibouti, in breach of DP World’s exclusivity rights, will also be examined.

China Merchants surprisingly argued that the case should be heard by the Djibouti courts, despite Hong Kong being its home jurisdiction. The High Court of Hong Kong agreed with DP World’s arguments that the case should proceed in Hong Kong and ordered China Merchants to pay its legal costs. The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal against that decision, and has now refused to grant China Merchants permission to file a second appeal before the Court of Final Appeal.

The Hong Kong court ruling follows a ruling in January 2022, by the London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA) against the Republic of Djibouti, awarding interim damages of US$ 200 million for damages caused over the period between for the period 23 February 2018 to 31 December 2020. That was the eighth decision by an international court or tribunal in favour of DP World in its ongoing dispute with the Republic of Djibouti, and total damages due to DP World now amount to US$ 686.5 million, plus accruing interest, while the Concession itself remains legally in force.

The Doraleh Container Terminal is the largest employer and biggest source of revenue in Djibouti and has operated at a profit every year since it opened.

DP World is a leading provider of worldwide smart end-to-end supply chain logistics, enabling the flow of trade across the globe. With a portfolio of 295 businesses in 78 countries across six continents, with a significant presence in both high-growth and mature markets, the company enjoys strong relationships with governments around the world, working in partnership to strengthen economies through investment in infra-structure and the implementation of smart trade solutions.
Click to expand...
Siasa za kuhamisha magoli. Elewa kwanini mkataba kwanza ulipita bungeni ndio uje na hoja hizi za kujaribu kujipa umuhimu kwenye suala hili la bandari.
 
Steven Joel Ntamusano said:
Hayo tunatakiwa tuyaseme kwenye hii mikataba ya kibiashara, huko bungeni hayahusiki.
Click to expand...
Lakini yanayohusika Bungeni ni kuwa kama Tanzania haiyataki yatakayokuwemo humo ndani ya HGA, haina njia ya kujinasua na kuondoka bila ya ruhusa ya Dubai, au siyo? Hii ni akili sawasawa hii?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Our Community

Regional Communities

Back
Top Bottom
Menu
Forums
New posts
Log in
Register