Kinachoikumba Shule ya Mt. Jude: TRA waliondoa 500,000,000 kwenye akaunti za Shule

[Jidu La Mabambasi]

Tanzania kila kitu kinawezekana. Mgonjwa Hsp anaondolewa drip hadi atakapolipa pesa ya kufungulia file. Maana yake unataka yule mgonjwa afe na siyo apone akulipe.

Du....!

 

[Fundi Mchundo]

Mfanyakazi anahusiana nini na kodi ya shule! Yeye analipa kodi ya mshahara wake tu. Vitabu! Jipange uandike

Na huyo mfanyakazi ataendelea kulipa hiyo kodi hata atakapo poteza ajira kwa sababu shule haina pesa za kumlipa?
Na wewe pia ni msomi!

Amandla...

 

[and 998 others]

Acheni kutafuta huruma humu. Lipeni Kodi stahiki

 

[pepsin]

Wapumbavu wanasema kuwa eti shule ilikataa kupeleka watoto kujaza uwanja wakati wa kampeni za urais. Watu sijui wakoje!! Mimi nimewaambia watafute sababu nyingine

 

[Sophist]

Wewe umefuatilia huu mgogoro?

Mgogoro huu upo toka 2012 wakati walipofanyiwa Audit na baadaye Audit findings zikaonyesha hawakuwa na sifa ya Charitable Organisation kwa maana ya sheria za kodi.

Tokea hapo wamepelekana kwenye mabaraza ya kodi mpaka Mahakama ya Rufani ambayo maamuzi yake hayajatofautiana na maamuzi ya Bodi ya Rufani za kodi na Baraza la Rufani za Kodi. Inakuwaje leo mnakimbilia ni Magufuli kabana?

Ukitaka kuwa NGO ambayo hailipi KODI fuata TARATIBU ZOTE ZA KISHERIA acheni kutengeneza mabomu ambayo yakiripuka mnatafuta huruma za kisiasa.

Actually ukisoma na kuelewa andiko la St. Jude utabaini kuwa kinachofanywa na shule ni sawa na kinachofanywa na TASAF ispokuwa St. Jude wanatumia the best strategy and advanced approach for sustainable eradicating of poverty from communities wakati TASAF wanatumia elementary rudimental strategic approach for eradicating poverty from communities. Ila cha kushangaza pesa wanazotumia TASAF hazikatwi kodi wakati St. Jude wanashurutishwa kulipa kodi!

 

[Akimuz]

Maelezo mazuri lakini yana mapungufu. Kwa kuwa wameamua kutoa malalamiko yao kwa umma maana yake wameshindwana na serikali, sasa basi, ili umma tuweze kutoa 'hukumu'ya haki ingekuwa Vema na Haki wakaainisha kodi wanazodaiwa na malimbikizo yake na Kwanini walilimbikiza.

Vinginevyo tukianza kuilaumu serikali bila kujua Hoja za pande zote mbili itakuwa tumekosa maarifa na busara

Misaada hainaga tozo ya Kodi.
Leo hii sirikali wanaleta hoja za kodi, thus y kuna huo mgogoro.

 

[MIRONJO]

mwisho

Daah Hali mbaya tunataka tuingie uchumi was Kati mkubwa

 

[Zillion]

Hifadhi ushoga wako. Nilichokupa ni fact. Na nimeifanyia kazi by 100%. Ndegelec

Matusi ya nini mkuu,

Wewe una research yako na mimi nina yangu kwani ni lazima nikubali mawazo yako
Naamini research yangu
Matusi ni ishara ya malezi mabovu, upungufu wa ufahamu na maadili.

 

[Kamukhm]

Who projects? a fool of ua caliber takes such oaths. Don’t derail the truth abnoxiously . Looks idiotic.

Tf is "Truth" you referring to!?

Get over your struggles with Homosexual-OCD kwanza maana that's the "Fact/Truth" you can take to the Bank!

No Homo! Just a brother looking out for you!

 

[Freddie Matuja]

Kimsingi kama PAYE haikuwahi kulipwa huko nyuma hapakuwa na haja ya kukwapua mil 500 za uendeshaji wa shule kwa kuwa tu walimu walikuwa hawakatwi PAYE.

Shule kwa kuwa msingi wake ni donations, TRA ingeweka waiver ya kutokuwadai kilichopita na kuanza kudai sasa.

Barrick na ACACI tulijua wanatupiga, yet tulikaa nao mezani.
Bart Airtel hali kadhalika.

Sasa haya mambo ya kubanana namna hii sio sawa.
TRA hawajui how it takes kuandika proposals kupata donor funding.

Unaweza kuandika propose 100 ukapata 1 au ukakosa. Kama kuna watu wamejua kuna uhitaji, forex inakuja Tz na inakuwa spent kwa manunuzi ya chakula, kulipa walimu/wafanyakazi wasio walomu mishahara na kukarabati shule; iwepo busara ya hali ya juu maadam kinachoingia kiko proven sio kwa ajili ya kutengeneza faida but charitable.

Kwenye hilo nalo mpaka JPM atoe maelekezo kweli??

Labda kama kuna mambo hayajakaa sawa kwenye uendeshaji wa taasisi, ni vema yakawa addressed yenyewe bila kuingilia mkondo wa fedha za matumizi ya kawaida.

TRA wawe na weledi wa hali ya juu. Na kama sheria ya waiver haipo itafutwe. Donation zikikata, watoto wetu watakosa kusoma na hiyo amounts inayokuja ikikata, hata zile indirect taxes zinazopatikana via spending nazo zitakata.

 

[katitu]

Sijui hata nicomment nini

Du sijui na sijajua nn kipo nyuma ya pazia.Tusubiri vyombo husika watueleze yanayoendelea.

 

[Mwandwanga]

Nimependa mtazamo wako katika hii kesi. Vipi juu ya hoja ya TRA kuwa hii shule haikuomba/haikuwa na Ruling ya CG ambayo ndio KIBALI haswa cha Taasisi tajwa kuwa Charitable Organisation?

Kwanini uendeshe jambo kwa DHAHANIA? (bila kufanya Compliance na sheria husika)

Very interesting case, tunatabia ya kufanya copy and paste ya sheria zetu ila tafsiri halisi na implemention zake inakuwa shida.

Binafsi nadhani wakili wa hiyo shule ‘Mr Duhia’ or rather one of its board members appears to know his accounting legal staff.

Kwanza inaonekana kuna issue ya kutokuwa na sheria mahususi (nor case laws) zinayotoa tafsiri ya ‘badges of trade’ kuelezea mipaka yako kabla ujaonekana unafanya biashara, having said that (kwa sheria za nchi za wenzetu hiyo shule bado inaangukia kama charity organisation).

Hatari ni kwamba ukiweka tafsiri ya badges of trade kwa Tanzania kama inavyotumika kwa nchi za wenzetu halafu utake watu wanao qualify walipe kodi kutokana na activities zao kuna watu wengi watalia aijawahi tokea. Mifano kidogo tu umwambie dalali anatakiwa awe na TIN number kwa sababu nyumba na viwanja anavyouza ni more than 2 million kwenye hiyo hela 18% ni VAT ya serikali na faida ya mapato yake 20% ni profit ya serikali anatakiwa alipe kodi as a sole trader; au machinga aonyeshe risiti zake hao watu awawezi kukuelewa kabisa).

Pili asilimia kubwa ya income iliyopata hiyo shule kama bank interest, miscellaneous income etc. Sababu zinazofanya TRA idai kodi falls into capital gain tax, rather than corporate tax kwa nchi za wenzetu ili charity isiathirike.

Ijumaa leo mida hii kidogo akili ipo nusu, ila huyo Mr Duhia arguments zake ndio sahihi sio TRA at least in global view of what a charity is. Inawezekana sheria zetu zina tafsiri nyingine (but then the, Law is the Law) kwa ivyo lazima ziheshimike nonetheless if the purpose of a charity is to help the needy with that line of reasoning amendments are required.

Huu mjadala kama unaendelea kesho ntaweka senti 50 zangu when I am sober, ila TRA needs proper accountants.

 

[katitu]

Non profit organization inalipaje kodi.? Kwanza Kodi maana yake nini tuanzie hapo

Ki msingi kuna Kodi ambazo zinapaswa kulipwa Kama PAYE lkn Kama nilivyosema tuosubiri upande wa pili ambao ni serikali watufunulie pazia.lifting the veil.

 

[Kamukhm]

Very interesting case, tunatabia ya kufanya copy and paste ya sheria zetu ila tafsiri halisi na implemention zake inakuwa shida.

Binafsi nadhani wakili wa hiyo shule ‘Mr Duhia’ or rather one of its board members appears to know his accounting legal staff.

Kwanza inaonekana kuna issue ya kutokuwa na sheria mahususi (nor case laws) zinayotoa tafsiri ya ‘badges of trade’ kuelezea mipaka yako kabla ujaonekana unafanya biashara, having said that (kwa sheria za nchi za wenzetu hiyo shule bado inaangukia kama charity organisation).

Hatari ni kwamba ukiweka tafsiri ya badges of trade kwa Tanzania kama inavyotumika kwa nchi za wenzetu halafu utake watu wanao qualify walipe kodi kutokana na activities zao kuna watu wengi watalia aijawahi tokea. Mifano kidogo tu umwambie dalali anatakiwa awe na TIN number kwa sababu nyumba na viwanja anavyouza ni more than 2 million kwenye hiyo hela 18% ni VAT ya serikali na faida ya mapato yake 20% ni profit ya serikali anatakiwa alipe kodi as a sole trader; au machinga aonyeshe risiti zake hao watu awawezi kukuelewa kabisa).

Pili asilimia kubwa ya income iliyopata hiyo shule kama bank interest, miscellaneous income etc. Sababu zinazofanya TRA idai kodi falls into capital gain tax, rather than corporate tax kwa nchi za wenzetu ili charity isiathirike.

Ijumaa leo mida hii kidogo akili ipo nusu, ila huyo Mr Duhia arguments zake ndio sahihi sio TRA at least in global view of what a charity is. Inawezekana sheria zetu zina tafsiri nyingine (but then the, Law is the Law) kwa ivyo lazima ziheshimike nonetheless if the purpose of a charity is to help the needy with that line of reasoning amendments are required.

Huu mjadala kama unaendelea kesho ntaweka senti 50 zangu when I am sober, ila TRA needs proper accountants.

Nitakununulia Kahawa urejee leo... Kuna kitu unatakiwa utupatie hapa!

 

[KUCHITIMBO1970]

Nadhani shida ni mgonano wa kimaslahi ndo unaotesa taasisi na miradi mingi hapa nchini,kutakuwa na wakubwa wana shule yao huko Arusha na wameona St.Jude ni tishio kwa uhai wa shule yao,hivo wafanye figisu kuifungia lengo shule yao ipate wateja,wanamadai ya kodi,kama ni kodi leo ndo wameiona?.
Kuna shule ilikuwa Kongowe kule chini barabara ya kuelekea Kigamboni pia ilifanyiwa figisu kuwa iligushi usajiri watoto wakaondolewa wote wakati ilikuwa na miaka kibao tangu ilipo jengwa na kupokea watoto.
Wananchi tufikirie kiundani na siyo kushabikia mambo ya kiuonevu

 

[katitu]

Elimu kwa Watanzania ni jukumu na kazi ya Serikali JMTZ na siyo Mzungu wa sijui Australia, kwani huko kwao hana matatizo ? ...

Huku ndo kukosa maarifa.mpaka leo hujui maana ya private sectors na umuhimu wake kea nchi hii?kwamba serikali inaweza fanya kila kitu bila private sectors ku chip in.Hatari Sana kama kuna wtz wenye akili Kama hizi.

 

[Mazaya]

Watanzania wengi ni aidha ni wavivu wa kusoma au wanapotosha makusudi, utakuta jitu zima limeng'ang'ana kulaumu Serikali ya Awamu ya tano au jingine linasema hawakupeleka watoto uwanjani kwenye kampeni ndio maana TRA wamewafuata!

Pamoja na maelezo mazuri na ushahidi maridhawa wa msingi wa madai yenyewe tangu mwaka 2009 na kesi ya msingi ya mwaka 2012 ambayo imewekwa kwenye uzi huu bado kuna mapopoma yanalaumu Serikali ya awamu ya 5.

Ujinga mwingine ni pale jitu linaingiza chuki za kikanda na kikabila kwenye ishu huu mfano hili jamaa Zanzibar asp na hili Salary Slip

 

[Eric Cartman]

Nimependa mtazamo wako katika hii kesi. Vipi juu ya hoja ya TRA kuwa hii shule haikuomba/haikuwa na Ruling ya CG ambayo ndio KIBALI haswa cha Taasisi tajwa kuwa Charitable Organisation?

Kwanini uendeshe jambo kwa DHAHANIA? (bila kufanya Compliance na sheria husika)

Porojo tu za TRA shule from the outset ilisajiliwa as a ‘limited by guaranteed company’ kupitia Brella na vibali vyote vimewekwa kwenye post number 1 ya hii mada na vielelezo vingine vimewekwa kwenye kesi.

Kwa maana hiyo mgogoro wa kuamua shule ni charity or not that is not issue in this matter, kuna ushahidi wa kutosha it’s a charity.

Mzozo ni kodi za 2009 and 2010 kuhusu allowable expenditures claimed during that period (ambazo TRA inapinga in some) and income surpluses which their sources are allowable based on charity organisation operation be it they might be subjected to capital gain tax; rather than cooperate tax.

Just get proper accountants in TRA sio kuweka watu tia maji, tia maji and use qualified judges to decide on tax matters.

Asubuhi njema, I need a rest.

Ila tatizo lilipo based on the evidence there is enough evidence of sharing blame. More on TRA side for their incompetence.

Off to sleep, laters 👋

 

[katitu]

Kazi kwelikweili!

Nadhani pia wazazi ambao watoto wao wanasoma katika shule hizo Wana kitu wanachokijua au kinachoendelea hata hao wanaofadhiliwa ni kweli wanastahili kudhaminiwa?Kitu vitu viko chino ya pazia napenda kusikia kutoka upande wa pili pia watueleze kilichojiri.

 

[Am the One]

Sisi wachache ambai familia zilipitia changamoto na tukasomeshwa na hizo non-profit ogranizations mpaka kufika chuo tunaelewa mamumivu na jinsi gani familia za wanafunzi hao zimeumia.


Lakini pia siasa isikufanye mjinga kiasi hiki.

Mbona hujaongelea zile ARV za msaada.

[emoji122][emoji122]