kekule benzene
JF-Expert Member
- Sep 28, 2016
- 1,970
- 4,448
Quran haijapangwa na maswahabaNani aliwapa mamlaka ya kupangua vile Allah amepanga???
Kulikuwa kinashindikanika nini kupanga kama vile Allah alipanga???
Unashindwa hata kuangalia chartgpt ili usiandike uozo hapa?Nani aliwapa mamlaka ya kupangua vile Allah amepanga???
Kulikuwa kinashindikanika nini kupanga kama vile Allah alipanga???
Iliandikwa ama iliteremshwa wewe jitu jeus unashadadiamila za kiarabu?Ndio sijapinga kwani Qur'an ilishuka katika Lahaja mbalimbali za kiarabu kipindi hiko ili kurahisisha usomaji , ilichofaywa ni kisawazisha yaani kuwekwa katika Lahaja Moja ambayo ndio standard na nyinginezo kuchomwa moto ili kuondoa tofauti katika usomaji. Na hiyo Lahaja iliyowekwa ambayo standard hakuzua yeye ilikuwa ni miongoni mwa Lahaja amabazo zilikuja katika Qu'ran kwa hiyo hapo hakuna ubaya wala makosa .
Watu wa maeneo tofauti wakapewa Amri kuwa wasome Qur'an wote katika Lahaja Moja na sio nyingine au kila mtu ajitungie ya kwake , hata bongo lafudhi za kiswahili lakini hayo yanaishia katika mazungumzo yenu ya kawaida na Kiswahili Cha kufundishia darasani ni kimoja Standard kilichonyooka .
Hata kiswahili Mkenya Moja anaita "Moya" na Mtanzania anaita Moja hivyo kimaana inakuwa sawa hakuna tofauti
Jitahidi kusoma kobaz mwenzio kaandika nini na Mimi nikauliza niniQuran haijapangwa na maswahaba
Kabla ya mtume kufa mpangilio (wahy) ulikuwepo
Hadith Support:
Narrated by Ibn Abbas:
“The Prophet used to review the Qur’an once every year (in Ramadan), but the year he died, he reviewed it twice with Jibreel.”
— (Sahih al-Bukhari)
Sasa mtume alikuwa hasomi kwa mpangilio?
Alikuwa akiswali anasoma bila mpangilio?
Hata kamaMAKAFIRI ongeeni ukweli
Umedandia gari Kwa mbele soma Kwanza alichoandika kobaz mwenzio au soma tulipoanzia ndiyo uje ukomentiUnashindwa hata kuangalia chartgpt ili usiandike uozo hapa?
SWALI: Was a structure of Quran arranged before prophet death?
ChatGPT said:
Yes, the structure and arrangement of the Qur'an were completed before the Prophet Muhammad’s (ﷺ) death, though the final written compilation into one Mushaf (book form) was done after his death. Here's how scholars and early sources explain it:
1. Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) Oversaw the Order of Verses and Surahs
Verses’ Placement:
When verses were revealed, the Prophet ﷺ would instruct his companions where to place each verse—i.e., in which surah and in what order. This is clear evidence that the order of verses within surahs was directly guided by the Prophet, based on divine instruction through Jibreel (Angel Gabriel).
Surah Order (Partial but Guided):
The order of many surahs was also known during the Prophet’s lifetime. He used to recite them in specific sequences in Salah (prayer), during Ramadan with Jibreel, and in teaching his companions. For example:
He recited Al-Baqarah, Aal Imran, and An-Nisa’ together.
He taught to recite Surah Al-Fatiha at the beginning of every prayer.
Hadith Support:
Narrated by Ibn Abbas:
“The Prophet used to review the Qur’an once every year (in Ramadan), but the year he died, he reviewed it twice with Jibreel.”
— (Sahih al-Bukhari)
This double revision of the Qur’an with Jibreel in the final year is understood by scholars to mean that the arrangement was finalized before the Prophet passed away.
2. Written Copies and Memorization During His Lifetime
The Qur’an was written down during the Prophet’s life by appointed scribes (e.g., Zayd ibn Thabit, Ubayy ibn Ka‘b).
Many companions memorized the entire Qur’an, including in the final arrangement taught by the Prophet.
However, the Qur’an was not compiled into one bound book (mushaf) during his lifetime—because:
Revelation was ongoing.
The Prophet was alive to guide and teach.
3. Full Compilation After the Prophet’s Death
Under Abu Bakr (r.a):
After the Prophet’s death, during the Caliphate of Abu Bakr and due to fear of loss (especially after the Battle of Yamama), the Qur’an was compiled into a single written volume.
Under Uthman (r.a):
Later, Caliph Uthman standardized the recitation and written copies, sending them to different regions to unify the Muslim Ummah on the same version.
In Summary
Yes, the structure of the Qur’an (verse and surah order) was arranged by the Prophet himself before his death, based on divine revelation.
The actual physical compilation into a complete mushaf was done after his death, but according to the exact arrangement he taught.
This is why all Muslims around the world, across centuries, read the same Qur’an—word for word, verse for verse, surah for surah.
Let me know if you want the names of the
scribes or more details on the compilation process!
Huwa sipendi kujibu wanafiki wewe mbona uhukuja kutoa majibu babla kama unaujua uislamu ? Sinta kujibu labda nikuulize maswali je katika uislamu kuna mitume wanao weza kuja baada ya muhammad? Hata kama waliopita ...je mtume wa mwisho kutumwa duniani ni yesu au muhammad? Nipe majibu kisha sasa tuanze mjadala na wewe ....usikimbie mada ....je katika uislamu mnakubali kuwa mitume bado wanaweza kuletwa duniani baada ya muhammad au la ?Lete hizo aya, hakuna aya hiyo labda kwenye Biblia
Edit kwa kiswahili sanifu ni kuhariri, hii ni hatua ya uandishi ambayo inahusika zaidi na kupangilia, kuondoa na kuweka kitu kingine ili zao la uhariri liwe zuri na lenye mvuto kwa hadhira.Ilikuaje othman akaedit kitabu kilichokamilika🤔
Abu Ja´far at-Twahaawiy (Rahimahu Allaah) amesema:Lete hizo aya, hakuna aya hiyo labda kwenye Biblia
Maelezo yako yapo sahihi, lakini kichwa cha uzi wako kipo tofauti na yaliyomo.Shalom, Salam alaikum.
Baada ya kusoma Biblia kuanzia Genesis Hadi Revelation nikaamua kuanza kusoma pia Quran (Mwaka huu).
Ila Huwa napenda kufahamu chanzo, uandishi Hadi uwasilishaji wa kitabu kabla ya kuanza kukisoma kitabu hicho (Napima uzito).
Na Hiki ndicho nilichogundua kwa upande wa chanzo cha Quran.
Vitabu vya Quran vilivyokuwa vimeandikwa kabla ya kifo cha Mtume Muhammad vilikusanywa na kuunganishwa kuwa kitabu kimoja baada ya kifo chake. Mchakato huu ulifanywa hasa na makhalifa wawili wa mwanzo, Abu Bakr na Uthman ibn Affan. Hapa kuna muhtasari wa hatua muhimu katika uunganishaji wa Quran:
1. Wakati wa Uhai wa Mtume Muhammad: Wakati Mtume Muhammad alikuwa hai, wahyi wa Quran ulipokelewa na kuandikwa na wafuasi wake kwenye nyenzo mbalimbali kama vile ngozi, mifupa, na majani. Wengi walikuwa pia wameuhifadhi katika akili zao.
2. Mchakato wa Abu Bakr: Baada ya kifo cha Mtume Muhammad mwaka 632 CE, baadhi ya wafuasi ambao walikuwa wamehifadhi Quran kwa kuikumbuka waliuawa katika mapigano. Khalifa wa kwanza, Abu Bakr, alihofia kwamba wahyi huo ungepotea, hivyo akaamuru uandikaji wa Quran kuwa kitabu kimoja. Zayd ibn Thabit, mmoja wa wahitimu wa Mtume, aliteuliwa kukusanya na kuandika vipande vya Quran kutoka kwa vyanzo mbalimbali.
3. Uthman na Usawazishaji: Baadaye, chini ya utawala wa Khalifa Uthman ibn Affan (644-656 CE), aliona kwamba katika maeneo mbalimbali kulikuwa na tofauti za usomaji na maandiko. Ili kuleta usawa, Uthman aliamuru kutengenezwa nakala rasmi ya Quran na kupeleka nakala hizo katika maeneo tofauti. Nakala nyingine zilisitishwa ili kuepuka tofauti.
Mchakato huu wa uunganishaji na usawazishaji ulihakikisha kwamba Quran iliifadhiwa katika fomu moja na inayoaminika hadi leo, kulingana na imani ya Kiislamu.
Samahani, nikuulize kituAisha anakiri aya za kupiga mawe na kunyonyesha mtu mzima zilikuwepo mpaka kifo cha muhammad , muhammad kafa aya zipo na aisha anasema zililiwa na mbuzi lakini watu walikuwa wamezikariri,
- sasa ujibu nani kaziondoa kwenye koran
- Aishah said: “The Verse of stoning and of breastfeeding an adult ten times was revealed1, and the paper was with me under my pillow. When the Messenger of Allah died, we were preoccupied with his death, and a tame sheep came in and ate it.” Sunan Ibn Majah 1944
- Sahih Muslim 1452a 'A'isha (Allah be pleased with, her) reported that it had been revealed in the Holy Qur'an that ten clear sucklings make the marriage unlawful, then it was abrogated by five sucklings and Allah's Apostle (ﷺ) died and it was before that time (found) in the Holy Qur'an (and recited by the Muslims).
- Sahih Muslim 1452b ...There was revealed in the Holy Qur'an ten clear sucklings, and then five clear (sucklings)
Na mwambie kabisa akiona mahali kuhusu kufutwa na kufuta kwa ayah moja dhidi ya nyingine haina maana ya deleting or erasing to disappearance bali kilichofutwa na kufuta ni hukumu (maelezo ya kisheria) ya ayah husika ambayo mara nyingi yalitokea kutokana na strength ya Imani ya masahaba kwa wakati husika, kwa maana hiyo ayah zote zilizofutwa na zilizofuta zipo na zinasomwa tofauti ni matumizi yake kisheria kwa mfano kwenye suala la pombe kuna ayah mbili zipo moja ilianza kushuka na ilikuwa inakataza kufanya ibadan ukiwa umelewa na nyingine ikashuka kukataza pombe mazima kuwa ni haramu, ko moja inaitwa yenye kufutwa na nyingine ni yenye kufuta, but zote zipo kwenye Quran na zinasomwa.Samahani, nikuulize kitu
Kwenye hizo Hadith za Kunyonyesha umeelewa nini?
Maana binafsi sioni kitu chochote cha kupinga, natamani uelezee ulichoeelwa ndio nikuelezee hiyo hadith na utajishangaa mwenyewe.
Conclusion
- The hadith refers to verses that were abrogated in recitation, and thus not part of the final Qur’an.
- The mention of the paper being eaten by a sheep is not a flaw in Qur’anic preservation, because the Qur’an was memorized and preserved in many other copies and hearts.
- This narration, even if taken as authentic, is understood in the context of abrogation and divine instruction, not accidental loss.
Kumuelewesha mtu ambaye hata herufi za kiarabu hajui, halafu uanze kumuelezea aya zilizofutwa, zilizofuta ni kazi inayohifaji mshahara kabisa
Kuna sababu nyingi za kufutwa aya kwa aya au HadithHuu sasa uongo wa wazi wazi..mbona unamtukana Allah wako..ina maana ana madhaifu hivi..ina maana wakati anashusha aya hakujua kwamba zina uzito(What a non sense defending)
Yeah, maelezo ya msingi maana wanadhani hizo aya zimeondolewa kabisaNa mwambie kabisa akiona mahali kuhusu kufutwa na kufuta kwa ayah moja dhidi ya nyingine haina maana ya deleting or erasing to disappearance bali kilichofutwa na kufuta ni hukumu (maelezo ya kisheria) ya ayah husika ambayo mara nyingi yalitokea kutokana na strength ya Imani ya masahaba kwa wakati husika, kwa maana hiyo ayah zote zilizofutwa na zilizofuta zipo na zinasomwa tofauti ni matumizi yake kisheria kwa mfano kwenye suala la pombe kuna ayah mbili zipo moja ilianza kushuka na ilikuwa inakataza kufanya ibadan ukiwa umelewa na nyingine ikashuka kukataza pombe mazima kuwa ni haramu, ko moja inaitwa yenye kufutwa na nyingine ni yenye kufuta, but zote zipo kwenye Quran na zinasomwa.
Sidhani hata kama umeelewa bali umekurupuka tu kujibuNi kweli kabisa. Badala ya kusifia wanashuku kitu ambacho kimeletwa na wapwakiaji wakapwakia na kujikana wa na utu na mila zao. Hawa ndo wanatuchelewsha sana. Hizi hadithi za Pwagu na Pwaguzi hazitusaidii zaidi ya kutopea kwenye uchochole na ujoli tena vya kujitakia
Chief kwani shida iko wapi? Kabla ya mwaka 1924 waislam hamkuwa na official Quran. Mfalme Fuad wa pili wa Misri asingeamua itengenezwe Quran moja kwa ajili ya waislam wote wa Misri leo hii msingekuwa na Hafs version ya Quran.Ukisema hauna kwani utapungua nini?
Humu humu mnatofautiana kuonesha mnaongea uwongo
Kuna MAKAFIRI wenzako wanasema Quran hii ni ya Othman ila aliedit
Kuna wewe wengine wanasema hii ni Quran ya Misri ya miaka ya 1900
Mtume ambaye alikuwa mpaka anasahau baadhi ya aya za Quran? Hadiyza Bukhari zimekuja kuwa compiled karibia miaka 400 baada ya Mohamed,na wewe unazichukulia kama ni mamlaka ya kweli kwenye inachosema!!!Quran haijapangwa na maswahaba
Kabla ya mtume kufa mpangilio (wahy) ulikuwepo
Hadith Support:
Narrated by Ibn Abbas:
“The Prophet used to review the Qur’an once every year (in Ramadan), but the year he died, he reviewed it twice with Jibreel.”
— (Sahih al-Bukhari)
Sasa mtume alikuwa hasomi kwa mpangilio?
Alikuwa akiswali anasoma bila mpangilio?
Hata kamaMAKAFIRI ongeeni ukweli
adrizIliandikwa ama iliteremshwa wewe jitu jeus unashadadiamila za kiarabu?
PSL god K11 Chaliifrancisco Mpaji Mungu
Mzee kwani umesahau kama Google wanakubali kuhariri taarifa na kufanya updates kutoka kwa yeyote, acha kujitoa ufahamu basi!!!Chief kwani shida iko wapi? Kabla ya mwaka 1924 waislam hamkuwa na official Quran. Mfalme Fuad wa pili wa Misri asingeamua itengenezwe Quran moja kwa ajili ya waislam wote wa Misri leo hii msingekuwa na Hafs version ya Quran.
Wanadamu wa lawaiytu kutoka Al Azhar university wakakaa na kukusanya andiko moja kisha serikali ikairasmisha . Serikali ya Saudi Arabia imekuja kuirasmisha Quran (Hafs 1924) ilipofika mwaka 1985.
Ina maana hata Saudi Arabia hawakuwa na Quran ya kale (Uthman) mpaka wategemee hii ya Misri? Nenda hata Google basi, najua ukiwa kama muislam hizi taarifa lazima ziutatize moyo wako.
Hata nawe hujaelewa nyama niliyofunga. Ni kama ngamia anamcheka nundu ng'ombe. Ndkchio nilichomaanisha.Sidhani hata kama umeelewa bali umekurupuka tu kujibu
Maelezo yanakuface wewe na umesapoti
Aisha mke mtoto , anasemaSamahani, nikuulize kitu
Kwenye hizo Hadith za Kunyonyesha umeelewa nini?
Maana binafsi sioni kitu chochote cha kupinga, natamani uelezee ulichoeelwa ndio nikuelezee hiyo hadith na utajishangaa mwenyewe.